Journal of Neuroscience, Vol 9, 3188-3208, Copyright © 1989 by Society for Neuroscience
Integration of distributed cortical systems by reentry: a computer simulation of interactive functionally segregated visual areas
LH Finkel and GM Edelman
Neurosciences Institute, New York, New York.
A computer model based on visual cortex has been constructed to analyze how
the operations of multiple, functionally segregated cortical areas can be
coordinated and integrated to yield a unified perceptual response. We
propose that cortical integration arises through the process of
reentry--the ongoing, parallel, recursive signaling between separate maps
along ordered anatomical connections. To test the efficacy of this
reentrant cortical integration (RCI) model, we have carried out detailed
computer simulations of 3 interconnected cortical areas in the striate and
extrastriate cortex of the macaque. The simulated networks contained a
total of over 222,000 units and 8.5 million connections. The 3 modeled
areas, called VOR, VOC, and VMO, incorporate major anatomical and
physiological properties of cortical areas V1, V3, and V5 but are vastly
simplified compared with monkey visual cortex. Simulated area VOR contains
both orientation and directionally selective units; simulated area VMO
discriminates the direction of motion of arbitrarily oriented objects; and
simulated area VOC responds to both luminance and occlusion boundaries in
the stimulus. Area VOC is able to respond to illusory contours (Kanizsa,
1979) by means of the same neural architecture used for the discrimination
of occlusion boundaries. This architecture also generates responses to
structure-from-motion by virtue of reentrant connections from VMO to VOC.
The responses of the simulated networks to these illusions are consistent
with the perceptual responses of humans and other species presented with
these stimuli. The networks also respond in a consistent manner to a novel
illusion that combines illusory contours and structure-from-motion. The
response synthesized to this combined illusion provides a strong argument
supporting the need for a recursive reentrant process in the cortex.
Functional integration of the simulated areas in the RCI model were found
to depend upon the combined action of 3 reentrant processes: (1)
conflicting responses among segregated areas are competitively eliminated,
(2) outputs of each area are used by other areas in their own operations,
and (3) outputs of an area are "reentered" back to itself (through lower
areas) and can thus be used iteratively to synthesize responses to complex
or illusory stimuli. Transection of the reentrant connections selectively
abolished these integrative processes and led to failure of figural
synthesis. The proposed model of reentry suggests a basis for understanding
how multiple visual areas as well as other cortical areas may be integrated
within a distributed system.