 |
Previous Article | Next Article 
Volume 16, Number 12,
Issue of June 15, 1996
pp. 3960-3967
Copyright ©1996 Society for Neuroscience
Synaptic Vesicle Movements Monitored by Fluorescence Recovery
after Photobleaching in Nerve Terminals Stained with FM1-43
A. W. Henkel1,
L. L. Simpson2,
R. M. A. P. Ridge3, and
W. J. Betz1
1 Department of Physiology, University of Colorado
Medical School, Denver, Colorado 80262, 2 Departments of
Medicine and Pharmacology, Jefferson Medical College, Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania 19107-6799, and 3 Department of Physiology,
Bristol University School of Medical Sciences, Bristol BS8 1TD, United
Kingdom
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
MATERIALS AND METHODS
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
FOOTNOTES
REFERENCES
ABSTRACT
We used the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching technique to
monitor movements of synaptic vesicles in top views of living frog
motor nerve terminals that had been prestained with the fluorescent dye
FM1-43. In each experiment, a small portion of a single stained vesicle
cluster was bleached with a laser and monitored subsequently for signs
of recovery as neighboring, unbleached vesicles moved into the bleached
region. In resting terminals, little or no recovery from photobleaching
occurred. Repetitive nerve stimulation, which caused all fluorescent
spots to grow dim as dye was released from exocytosing vesicles, did
not promote recovery from photobleaching. Pretreatment with botulinum
toxin (type A, C, or D) blocked exocytosis and destaining, but intense
nerve stimulation still did not cause significant recovery in bleached
regions. These results suggest that lateral movements of synaptic
vesicles are restricted severely in both resting and stimulated nerve
terminals.
We tested for laser-induced photodamage in several ways. Bleached
regions could be restained fully with FM1-43, and these restained
regions could be destained fully by nerve stimulation. Partially
bleached regions could be destained, although the rate of destaining
was lower than normal. Brisk recovery from photobleaching occurred
after treatment with okadaic acid, which disrupts synaptic vesicle
clusters and causes vesicles to spread throughout the nerve terminal.
These results suggest that vesicle translocation and recycling
machinery was intact in photobleached regions.
Key words:
photobleach recovery;
FPR;
FRAP;
synaptic
vesicles;
okadaic acid;
FM1-43;
exocytosis
INTRODUCTION
In nerve terminals, synaptic vesicles exist in
compact clusters near sites of exocytosis. During repetitive nerve
activity, vesicles move to the presynaptic membrane and undergo
exocytosis. The mechanisms governing vesicle clustering and
mobilization are only partly understood. It is not known, for example,
whether vesicles in resting terminals mix freely, as granules in
chromaffin cells seem to do (Terakawa et al., 1993 ), or are immobile,
as suggested by studies of synapsin I (for review, see DeCamilli et
al., 1990 ). Nor is it known how synaptic vesicles, once mobilized by
nerve activity, move to the presynaptic membrane. In the present work,
we have studied these and other questions by measuring the
intracellular movement of the fluorescent dye FM1-43. This dye stains
membranes of recycled synaptic vesicles in motor nerve terminals and is
released during exocytosis (Henkel et al., 1996 ). For example, if a
frog muscle is exposed to FM1-43 during nerve stimulation, synaptic
vesicles that undergo exocytosis take up the dye during endocytosis,
and clusters of recycled, stained vesicles appear as bright fluorescent
spots 1-3 µm in diameter (each comprising hundreds of stained
vesicles) distributed at regular intervals along the length of the
terminals (Betz and Bewick, 1992 , 1993 ; Betz et al., 1992a ; Betz et
al., 1993 ; Bewick and Betz, 1994 ; Henkel and Betz, 1995 ; Ribchester and
Betz, 1994 ).
In the present study, we used the fluorescence recovery after
photobleaching (FRAP) technique (Axelrod et al., 1976 ; Wade et al.,
1986 ; Jacobson et al., 1991 ) to study synaptic vesicle movements within
single vesicle clusters. We used a laser to photobleach a small segment
of a fluorescent spot, and then we monitored the bleached region for
signs of recovery as dye moved from neighboring (unbleached)
territories into the bleached region. The results suggest that vesicles
do not move freely either in resting or stimulated terminals.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Experiments were performed on acutely dissected frog (Rana
pipiens) cutaneus pectoris muscles. To stain nerve terminals,
preparations were exposed to 2-4 µM FM1-43
(Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) dissolved in normal frog Ringer's while
the nerve was stimulated electrically at 10 Hz for 4.5-5 min (Betz et
al., 1992a ). For imaging and photobleaching, we used a Biorad 600 laser
scanning confocal microscope with a mixed-gas Kr-Ar laser, fitted on
an upright Nikon microscope with a Zeiss 40× water immersion objective
lens. The following settings were used: 488 nm excitation line; 1%
transmittance filter, photomultiplier tube gain manual and maximal,
black level manual, zoom 3-5, scan speed normal or slow. The aperture
usually was fully open. For processing and analysis, images were sent
to a Silicon Graphics computer running software by G. W. Hannaway. For
any series of images of the same terminal, all images were acquired and
processed identically. For spot photobleaching, the ``park'' command
was used to position the laser beam, and the shutter then was opened
for 0.2-1.0 sec. For line photobleaching, 1000-3000 linescans were
given to produce bleaching. Results from line photobleaching
experiments were not significantly different from spot photobleaching
experiments and are not illustrated here. Only terminals on surface
muscle fibers were studied.
Botulinum toxin serotype A was isolated and tested for potency as
described previously (Simpson et al., 1988 ). Serotypes C and D were
purchased from WAKO Fine Chemicals (Dallas, TX); their potency was
confirmed with tests on both mouse (Simpson and Dasgupta, 1983 ) and
frog (J. Coffield and L.L. Simpson, unpublished observations)
nerve-muscle preparations. FM1-43-loaded preparations were exposed to
2-10 nM botulinum toxin for 3-5 hr at room
temperature (~23°C); complete paralysis required exposure for ~3
hr. The block of destaining was not reversible by prolonged
washing.
The use of black widow spider venom was described elsewhere (Henkel and
Betz, 1995 ). Briefly, the venom glands from Latrodectus
mactans were purchased from Sigma (St. Louis, MO) and a crude
extract prepared the day of the experiments. Solutions contained ~0.3
gland/ml Ringer's and were applied for 40-60 min.
Image orientation. We acquired only top views of
nerve terminals. That is, the terminals that we imaged lay on the upper
surface of muscle fibers. Thus, the laser bleached columns of vesicles
oriented primarily perpendicular to the presynaptic membrane.
Consequently, all results concern only lateral movements of vesicles
and dye. We attempted to perform experiments on terminals viewed from
the side, but the dye spots were too thin (seldom more than 1 µm) to
permit partial bleaching of a fluorescent spot viewed in this
orientation, even in linescan mode.
Quantification of photobleach recovery. In some
experiments, the overall brightness of images decreased slightly during
the experiment. This image ``fade'' may have resulted from
photobleaching during repeated image acquisition or from slight focus
changes, or both. Usually, we made no compensation for such changes,
although in some cases (Fig. 1) the brightness of a
control region (outside the region of intended photobleaching) was
measured and normalized to the first image in the series by adding a
constant value to all pixels within the confines of the terminal.
Fig. 1.
Okadaic acid promoted recovery from photobleaching
in resting nerve terminals. A, Control nerve terminal before
bleaching (top), immediately after bleaching
(middle; the bleached region is marked with an
arrowhead), and 28 min after bleaching (bottom).
The bleached regions in the middle and bottom are
almost identical, indicating that little or no dye moved from the
neighboring, unbleached regions into the bleached region.
Inset, The brightness (y-axis, not normalized) of
the bleached spot is plotted for each of the three panels.
Circles are from controls (A); squares
are from okadaic acid-treated terminals (B). Data represent
average brightness of three concentric circles (radii 0.2, 0.4, and 1.0 µm) centered on the bleached regions. Note that each region began at
the same brightness and was bleached by a similar amount. Only the
okadaic acid-treated preparation showed significant recovery.
B, Nerve terminal treated with okadaic acid. These images
are like those in A, except that okadaic acid (5 µM) was added 40 min before bleaching (and was
present throughout the experiment), and the last image was acquired
only 5.4 min after bleaching. It is clear that significant recovery
from photobleaching occurred relatively rapidly. Scale bar, 2 µm.
C, Quantification of photobleach recovery. Bars
show mean percent recovery (+1 SEM) from photobleaching for various
treatments. In each case, measurements were made 25-30 min after
photobleaching. The control and okadaic acid (OA) results
are like those illustrated in Figures 1 and 2. The third
column (CD-OA) shows that CD (20 µM for 20 min) did not block the recovery from
photobleaching induced by okadaic acid. The last two columns
(Ssp-OA and Calmid-OA) show that Ssp (2 µM for 60 min) and calmidozolium
(Calmid) (10 µM for 30 min) each
blocked the action of okadaic acid.
[View Larger Version of this Image (58K GIF file)]
We measured the brightness of the center of the bleached region before
and at various times after photobleaching and calculated the percent of
recovery. For example, if the average pixel value (brightness) of the
bleached region was 200 before bleaching, 100 immediately after
bleaching, and 150 later, the recovery was 50%. In addition, we
measured the brightness of unbleached control regions and normalized
all results to correct for changes in control regions (e.g., Fig.
2C). For example, if a control region
brightness decreased by 10% during the postbleach waiting period, it
was assumed that full recovery of the bleached region also decreased by
10%. Thus, in the example above, recovery from 100 to 150 would be
50/80, or 62.5%, rather than 50%. Usually, control regions decreased
in brightness slightly, probably as a result of slight focus changes
and slight photobleaching during image acquisition. These effects would
cause the amount of recovery from photobleaching to be somewhat
overestimated and make it likely that the average measured recovery
(18% recovery 25-30 min after bleaching) (Fig. 3) is
not significantly different from zero recovery. Because the recovery
was so meager, our attempts to quantify photobleach recovery rates in
resting terminals were unsuccessful; estimates of diffusion constant
were consistently less than 10 12
cm2/sec.
Fig. 2.
Nerve stimulation did not promote recovery from
photobleaching. A, Image of nerve terminal immediately
before photobleaching. B, Same terminal immediately after
bleaching. Note the bleached center in the spot marked with an
arrowhead. C, Same terminal after repetitive
nerve stimulation (10 Hz for 5 min). All of the spots destained as a
result of the nerve stimulation. The bleached spot is less evident as a
result of the surrounding destaining. Scale bar, 4 µm. D,
Brightness of pixels along a line drawn through the center of several
adjacent spots for each image in A-C
(A, solid line; B, dotted
line; C, dashed line). The bleached region
is shaded. Note that nerve stimulation did not cause the
bleached region to grow brighter, indicating that no net movement of
dye into the bleached region occurred during the stimulation
period.
[View Larger Version of this Image (48K GIF file)]
Fig. 3.
Averaged results from six experiments
confirmed that no significant recovery from photobleaching occurred
during nerve stimulation. Each filled symbol shows the
average brightness of pixels lying a fixed distance from the center of
the bleached region [distance = 0.5 µm (squares), 1.0 µm (triangles), and 1.8 µm (diamonds)]. The
open circles show the average brightness in several control
regions, far away from the bleached spot. Pixels closest to the center
of the bleached region (filled squares) were most completely
bleached, whereas at slightly farther distances (triangles
and diamonds), less bleaching occurred. A 5 min rest period
followed the bleach, and then the nerve was stimulated continuously at
10 or 20 Hz while additional images were acquired. The center of the
bleached region (filled squares) showed no significant
recovery. Brightnesses were calculated as the average brightness of
pixels lying along concentric circles centered on the bleached region
(which was approximately circular). Vertical lines show 1
SEM for the center of the bleached regions; other SEs were of similar
magnitude and are omitted for clarity.
[View Larger Version of this Image (15K GIF file)]
RESULTS
Recovery from photobleaching in resting terminals
Figure 1A shows the results of an experiment on a
normal, resting nerve terminal. The control image (top)
shows typical fluorescent spots in a nerve terminal (the
arrowhead marks the region to be bleached). These spots,
each of which consists of several hundred to a few thousand recycled
synaptic vesicles stained with FM1-43, persist in resting terminals for
many hours without significant changes in brightness, position, or
shape (Betz et al., 1992a ). The middle shows the same terminal
immediately after a small patch was bleached with the laser. The image
in the bottom was obtained 28 min after photobleaching; the bleached
region still is evident (arrowhead). Similar results were
obtained in experiments on 11 other muscles (25 terminals; 35 bleached
spots and 5 bleached lines). Overall, 25-60 min after photobleaching
there was only ~18% recovery of brightness in the bleached regions,
an amount that, owing to slight amounts of focus change and
photobleaching during image acquisition (see Materials and Methods),
may not be different from zero (i.e., completely immobilized
vesicles).
Effects of okadaic acid and other agents
One simple explanation for the lack of recovery from
photobleaching in resting nerve terminals is that the laser beam
damaged the terminal and arrested vesicle movements that otherwise
would have led to recovery from bleaching. We tested for this
possibility in several ways. First, as illustrated in Figure
1B, we repeated the photobleach experiments on preparations
pretreated with okadaic acid, an inhibitor of protein phosphatases
(Haystead et al., 1989 ). In separate work (Betz and Henkel, 1994 ), we
showed that okadaic acid disrupts synaptic vesicle clusters and causes
vesicles to spread throughout the terminal. The dye movements do not
appear to be diffusion-driven. Rather, it appears that okadaic acid
unmasks powerful and widespread active translocators that move vesicles
bidirectionally in the terminals. If the laser beam caused nonspecific
damage to the cytoplasm and immobilized organelles, then one might
expect that okadaic acid-treated preparations would not recover from
photobleaching. This was not observed. As shown in Figure
1B, significant and prompt recovery from photobleaching
occurred in terminals pretreated with okadaic acid. The images in
Figure 1B are like those in Figure 1A, except
that the time interval between bleaching and the last image in the
series was only 5 min. It is clear that significant recovery from
photobleaching occurred during this 5 min period. Note, for example,
that in the bottom of Figure 1B, the bleached region
(arrowhead) clearly is brighter than it was immediately
after bleaching (middle). This prompt recovery from
photobleaching was typical in preparations treated with okadaic acid
but was never seen in control preparations. In other experiments, we
found that okadaic acid, applied after photobleaching, also
could mobilize vesicles and lead to recovery in photobleached regions
(data not shown).
We tested the effects of several agents on the recovery from
photobleaching induced by okadaic acid. Results are summarized in
Figure 1C, which shows mean (+1 SEM) percentage of
photobleach recovery under several different conditions. The two left
columns show results from control and okadaic acid-treated
preparations, as illustrated in Figures 1A,B. The
next three columns show, respectively, that cytochalasin D (CD), which
disrupts actin polymerization and depolymerization (Cooper, 1987 ), did
not block the okadaic acid effect, but that calmidozolium (Calmid), a
calmodulin inhibitor, and staurosporine (Ssp), a protein kinase
inhibitor, did block recovery from photobleaching induced by okadaic
acid. By themselves, CD, Calmid, nor Ssp promoted recovery from
photobleaching (data not shown).
Effect of nerve stimulation on recovery from photobleaching
As illustrated in Figure 2, repetitive nerve stimulation did not
promote recovery from photobleaching. First, a control image was taken
(Fig. 2A). Then the center of one spot was bleached almost
completely (Fig. 2B, arrowhead). Additional
images were acquired during a 5 min rest period and during a subsequent
period of repetitive nerve stimulation (10 Hz for 5 min); the last
image in this series is shown in Figure 2C. Note that after
nerve stimulation, all of the fluorescent spots were dimmer, reflecting
the activity-dependent destaining of the terminal. The bleached region
also is less evident, which might suggest that recovery from
photobleaching had occurred during the nerve stimulation. However, as
shown in Figure 2D (which shows the brightness of pixels
under a line drawn along the length of the terminal, through the center
of fluorescent spots, at different times; the bleached region is
shaded), the bleached region did not grow brighter, the
surround simply grew dimmer during repetitive nerve stimulation. Thus,
there was no net movement of dye into the bleached region during or
after nerve stimulation. In addition, the bleached region did not grow
dimmer during nerve stimulation, probably because the bleach was nearly
complete. We examined the ability of lightly bleached terminals to
destain in other experiments (see Fig. 7).
Fig. 7.
Partially bleached regions can be destained
completely by nerve stimulation. The profile of brightness through a
single fluorescent spot is plotted as in Figure 6D. The
solid line shows the profile before photobleaching. The
extent of photobleaching was reduced by shortening the duration of
exposure to the laser. In this case, the fluorescent spot was bleached
(shaded region) by only 30-40% (dotted line).
Then the nerve was stimulated (10 Hz for 5 min). The spot destained
completely (dashed line). This shows that vesicles located
in the center of a bleached region still can undergo destaining.
[View Larger Version of this Image (26K GIF file)]
We also measured the average brightness of pixels lying a fixed
distance from the center of the bleached spot. Averaged results from
six experiments are shown in Figure 3. The brightness near the center
of the bleached region (filled squares), closer to the
periphery of the bleached region (triangles and
diamonds), and in remote control areas (open
circles) is plotted. It is clear that on average, the bleached
regions showed virtually no recovery after nerve stimulation, and in no
individual case did we observe significant brightening in a bleached
region.
Effects of botulinum toxin
These results suggest that, even during repetitive nerve
stimulation, synaptic vesicles are not free to move laterally within a
vesicle cluster. However, another possibility is that mobilized
vesicles did move into the bleached region, but then underwent
exocytosis and lost their dye, so that the recovery from photobleaching
was incomplete and transient and was undetected by us. To test this
possibility, we repeated the nerve stimulation experiments on
preparations that had been poisoned with botulinum toxin, a potent
inhibitor of exocytosis that acts by cleaving peptides involved in
synaptic vesicle docking at the presynaptic membrane (for review, see
Simpson, 1989 ; Montecucco and Schiavo, 1994 ). Consistent with this
interpretation, we found that botulinum toxin blocked
activity-dependent destaining of nerve terminals that had been
preloaded with FM1-43 (serotypes A, C, and D gave indistinguishable
results). Results from a typical experiment are shown in Figure
4. We also found, as expected, that pretreatment with
botulinum toxin blocked subsequent staining of nerve terminals with
FM1-43 (data not shown). The block of destaining could be overcome by
treatment with black widow spider venom (Fig.
5A). Botulinum toxin treatment did not,
however, block the vesicle-mobilizing actions of okadaic acid (Betz and
Henkel, 1994 ). As illustrated in Figure 5B, vesicle clusters
were disrupted by okadaic acid (2 µM) in
preparations pretreated with botulinum toxin to an extent that was
indistinguishable from controls. Okadaic acid treatment, however, did
not overcome the botulinum toxin-induced block of destaining by nerve
stimulation (data not shown). In summary, these results are entirely
consistent with evidence that botulinum toxin acts by blocking vesicle
docking.
Fig. 4.
Botulinum toxin blocked destaining of frog motor
nerve terminals preloaded with FM1-43. Preparations were stained with
FM1-43, and then one (B) was exposed to botulinum toxin
(type D) (10 nM) for 4 hr. Then the
prestimulation images (top) were acquired. Next, the nerves
to each preparation were stimulated (10 Hz for 10 min), and images
again were taken (bottom). The control terminal
(A) destained during the nerve stimulation, whereas the
botulinum toxin-poisoned terminal (B) did not. In the
control panels, a myelinated axon is visible in the upper left
corner. Scale bar, 5 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (41K GIF file)]
Fig. 5.
Botulinum toxin did not block the actions
of black widow spider venom or okadaic acid. A, These
preparations were stained with FM1-43, and then one (right)
was poisoned with botulinum toxin (type C) (10 nM
for 3 hr). The control images (top) show fluorescent spots
characteristic of normal staining. Then black widow spider venom (0.3 glands/ml) was applied for 40 min, and the images (bottom)
were acquired. It is clear that black widow spider venom caused
destaining in control and botulinum-poisoned terminals alike. Scale
bar, 10 µm. B, The control image (top) shows a
terminal in a preparation that was stained with FM1-43 and then
poisoned with botulinum toxin (type C) (10 nM for
3 hr). Then 5 µM okadaic acid was applied for
120 min, and the terminal was reimaged (bottom). The
blurring of fluorescent spots is clearly apparent. This is an extreme
example of the okadaic acid effect, probably resulting from the
prolonged exposure to okadaic acid. In general, blurring of dye spots
could be seen after exposure to okadaic acid for 30-40 min. Scale
bars, 10 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (40K GIF file)]
Next, we repeated the photobleach experiments on botulinum-poisoned
preparations (Fig. 6). After a control image was
acquired (Fig. 6A), two spots were bleached (Fig.
6B, arrowheads). Then the nerve was stimulated
(30 Hz for 5 min), and the image in Figure 6C was acquired.
It is clear that destaining was blocked (compare Fig. 4) and that
little or no recovery from photobleaching occurred. Figure
6D shows the profile of brightness for the spot on the right
obtained from the images in A-C. Figure
6E shows averaged results from six experiments. The centers
of the bleached spots were aligned on the x-axis
(x = 0). The top line (solid) shows the mean
brightness +1 SEM for all six experiments before bleaching. The dotted
line shows the same for spots immediately after bleaching and the
dashed line after nerve stimulation. For clarity, error bars, which
were about the same length as controls, are not shown. The two
postbleach lines are nearly identical, showing that virtually no
vesicle mixing occurred during stimulation of botulinum-poisoned
terminals.
Fig. 6.
Fluorescence photobleach recovery did not occur in
botulinum toxin-poisoned preparations. A, A nerve terminal
stained with FM1-43 and poisoned with botulinum toxin before
photobleaching. B, The same terminal immediately after
photobleaching (arrowheads mark bleached regions).
C, After repetitive nerve stimulation (30 Hz for 5 min).
Little or no change occurred as a result of the nerve stimulation.
Scale bar, 5 µm. D, Profile of brightness along a line
passing through the bleached region for the images in
A-C. E, Averaged results from six
different experiments with centers of bleached regions aligned at
x = 0. Solid line shows mean +1 SEM before
bleaching. Results obtained immediately after bleaching and after
repetitive nerve stimulation are shown with dotted and
dashed lines, respectively. Error bars, which were about the
same length as before bleaching, are omitted from these two lines for
clarity.
[View Larger Version of this Image (65K GIF file)]
Destaining of partially bleached regions
Once an area was bleached, we, of course, could not monitor
directly the behavior of the bleached vesicles. However, we performed
several additional tests to examine the overall functional integrity of
bleached regions. First, we used smaller amounts of bleaching (shorter
bleaching periods) than in the experiments shown in Figures 4, 5, 6 to
test for the ability of a partially bleached region to destain during
nerve stimulation. An example is shown in Figure 7. The
graph shows the profile of brightness along the length of the terminal
(compare Fig. 6D) before bleaching (solid line),
immediately after bleaching (dotted line), and after
repetitive nerve stimulation (10 Hz for 5 min) (dashed
line). Bleaching reduced the brightness by ~40% (shaded
region). Subsequent nerve stimulation produced complete destaining
of the partially bleached region. In most experiments, the rate of
destaining in the bleached region was slower than normal, as reported
previously for overillumination using a mercury lamp for illumination
(Betz et al., 1992).
Restaining and destaining in bleached regions
We performed two additional tests for laser-induced photodamage.
Typical results are shown in Figure 8. First, restaining
of bleached regions was successful (Fig. 8A,3).
Second, destaining of those restained areas also was successful
(4). These tests showed that exocytotic, endocytotic, and
vesicle recycling machinery was intact qualitatively after the laser
illumination.
Fig. 8.
Photobleached regions exhibit normal functional
properties, including restaining and destaining with FM1-43.
A, Images of a normal terminal (1) that was
bleached (2, arrowhead), restained with FM1-43
(3), and then destained by nerve stimulation (30 Hz for 5 min) (4). The restaining and destaining of the previously
bleached region were indistinguishable from control regions. Scale bar,
10 µm. B, Brightness profiles of the images in Figure
8A.
[View Larger Version of this Image (43K GIF file)]
DISCUSSION
In top views of both resting and stimulated nerve terminals,
little or no recovery from photobleaching occurred, suggesting that
synaptic vesicles are virtually immobile in resting terminals and that
their lateral movements are restricted sharply as they make their way
to the presynaptic membrane during repetitive nerve stimulation. These
conclusions rest on the assumption that laser photodamage was
negligible. In frog motor nerve terminals stained with FM1-43,
overillumination can cause immobilization of synaptic vesicles,
blocking activity-dependent destaining of the terminals (Betz et al.,
1992a ). This made it crucial to determine whether the observed lack of
recovery from photobleaching was attributable simply to photodamage. We
performed four different tests to study this problem, and the results,
taken together, suggest that photodamage is not the correct explanation
for the lack of recovery from photobleaching.
The protein phosphatase inhibitor okadaic acid provided one test for
photodamage. After FM1-43-stained preparations had been exposed to
okadaic acid, recovery from photobleaching was brisk, beginning
immediately and sometimes going to completion within several minutes.
In previous work (Betz and Henkel, 1994 ), we showed that okadaic acid
unmasks a vesicle translocation mechanism in nerve terminals. The
present results show clearly that laser photobleaching did not
interfere with these movements. We do not know whether the same
mechanism moves synaptic vesicles to the presynaptic membrane during
ordinary nerve activity; it is conceivable that a different mechanism,
more sensitive to laser illumination, might exist. Nevertheless, the
persistence after photobleaching of the okadaic acid effect shows that
the laser did not produce generalized nonspecific damage to the
cytoplasm.
Three additional tests demonstrated that photobleaching did not
destroy the cytoplasmic machinery necessary for carrying out the
complex tasks of exocytosis and vesicle recycling. First, after a
``light'' amount of bleaching, the remaining dye still could be
released in an activity-dependent fashion, although the rate of
destaining was somewhat reduced compared with controls. This showed
that exocytosis was at least qualitatively intact after photobleaching.
Second, bleached regions could be restained with FM1-43. Third,
bleached, reloaded terminals could be destained completely by nerve
stimulation. Collectively, these experiments show that the machinery
necessary for vesicle mobilization, exocytosis, endocytosis, and
recycling was qualitatively intact in bleached regions. We cannot,
however, rule out the possibility that the laser selectively destroyed
a mechanism specifically designed for the lateral movement of vesicles
within vesicle clusters. It seems more reasonable to conclude that,
although photobleaching may have produced a partial reduction in the
rate of vesicle movements, it did not block them altogether. We, thus,
sought other explanations for the lack of recovery from
photobleaching.
One possibility is that during repetitive nerve stimulation,
dye-filled vesicles did in fact move into bleached regions, but then
quickly underwent exocytosis, losing their dye, thereby producing only
a transient, undetected recovery from photobleaching. To test this, we
monitored bleached regions after stimulation had ended, when
exocytosis, but probably not mobilization, had been arrested, and we
still saw no significant photobleach recovery. In addition, we repeated
photobleach experiments on preparations poisoned with botulinum toxin
(which blocks exocytosis and, therefore, dimming of fluorescence, but
not vesicle mobilization), with the same result. Thus, it seems that
the results reflect a true failure of vesicles to move laterally within
vesicle clusters.
This conclusion seems, at first consideration, to contradict previous
results. For example, recycled vesicles appear to mix randomly with
preexisting vesicles, as measured by horseradish peroxidase (for
review, see Heuser, 1989 ) or FM1-43 uptake and distribution (Betz and
Bewick, 1992 ). Such mixing occurs at an earlier phase of the vesicle
cycle, namely, the period between endocytosis and reappearance of
vesicles in the cluster. It is possible that the mechanism responsible
for generating nascent vesicles can somehow ``inject'' them randomly
into a cluster of otherwise immobilized vesicles. Also, observations of
side views of nerve terminals before and after partial destaining
suggested that some fluorescent spots dimmed uniformly during nerve
stimulation, as if vesicles were mixing freely within a cluster (Betz
et al., 1992b ). However, directed or constrained vesicle movements were
not ruled out by those observations; bidirectional movements of
vesicles confined to pathways oriented perpendicular to the presynaptic
membrane could produce results consistent with both studies. In the
present work, we attempted to resolve this question by bleaching
portions of dye spots viewed from the side, rather than from the top,
but we were not successful, owing to their small size when viewed from
the side.
How might synaptic vesicles be held even as they move to the
presynaptic membrane? Perhaps the simplest explanation is that each
vesicle is tethered to its neighbors and is simply pulled forward as
its cohorts undergo exocytosis and collapse into the presynaptic
membrane. Alternatively, the theory of action of synapsin I (for
review, see DeCamilli et al., 1990 ), a protein that binds synaptic
vesicles in resting terminals (Landis et al., 1988 ; Hirokawa et al.,
1989 ), but dissociates from vesicles after being phosphorylated
appropriately (Valtorta et al., 1992 ; Greengard et al., 1993 ), would
require that some constraining force persist or be added after a
vesicle is freed from synapsin I. The identity of this constraint is
unknown. Some studies suggest a role for actin in vesicle binding in
nerve terminals (Hirokawa et al., 1989 ; Benfenati et al., 1992 ;
Valtorta et al., 1992 ), whereas others are not wholly consistent with
such a role (Landis et al., 1988 ; Nakata and Hirokawa, 1992 ). In
chromaffin cells, actin is postulated to be a barrier to mobilization
and docking of granules (Aunis and Bader, 1988 ; Sontag et al., 1988 ;
Vitale et al., 1995 ). In the present work, CD did not affect recovery
from photobleaching, suggesting at least that changes in actin
polymerization (Cooper, 1987 ) are not involved in the movement of
synaptic vesicles to the presynaptic membrane in frog motor nerve
terminals.
FOOTNOTES
Received Feb. 5, 1996; revised March 8, 1996; accepted March 12, 1996.
This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Research
Grants NS23466 to W.J.B. and R.M.A.P.R., NS10207 to W.J.B., and NS22153
to L.L.S.; an MDA research grant to W.J.B.; USDOA contracts
DAMD1795C-0048 and -5004 to L.L.S.; and a Human Frontier Science
Fellowship to A.W.H. Steve Fadul provided unfailing assistance in all
phases of these experiments. We thank Dr. M. Sheetz (Durham) for his
encouragement in the early stages of this work, and Dr. W. Almers
(Heidelberg) for insightful comments during the course of the work and
for helpful suggestions on the manuscript.
Correspondence should be addressed to W.J. Betz, Department of
Physiology, University of Colorado Medical School, Denver, CO
80262.
REFERENCES
-
Aunis D,
Bader MF
(1988)
The cytoskeleton as a barrier to
exocytosis in secretory cells.
J Exp Biol
139:253-266 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Axelrod D,
Koppel DE,
Schlessinger J,
Elson E,
Webb WW
(1976)
Mobility measurement by analysis of fluorescence
photobleaching recovery kinetics.
Biophys J
16:1055-1069 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Benfenati F,
Valtorta F,
Chieregatti E,
Greengard P
(1992)
Interaction of free and synaptic vesicle-bound
synapsin I with F-actin.
Neuron
8:377-386 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Betz WJ,
Bewick GS
(1992)
Optical analysis of synaptic
vesicle recycling at the frog neuromuscular junction.
Science
255:200-203 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Betz WJ,
Bewick GS
(1993)
Optical monitoring of transmitter
release and synaptic vesicle recycling at the frog neuromuscular
junction.
J Physiol (Lond)
460:287-309 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Betz WJ, Henkel AW (1994) Okadaic acid disrupts clusters of
synaptic vesicles in frog motor nerve terminals J Cell Biol
124:843-854.
-
Betz WJ,
Mao F,
Bewick GS
(1992a)
Activity-dependent
fluorescent staining and destaining of living vertebrate motor nerve
terminals.
J Neurosci
12:363-375 .
[Abstract]
-
Betz WJ,
Bewick GS,
Ridge RMAP
(1992b)
Intracellular
movements of fluorescently labeled synaptic vesicles in frog motor
nerve terminals during nerve stimulation.
Neuron
9:805-813 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Betz WJ,
Ridge RMAP,
Bewick GS
(1993)
Comparison of FM1-43
staining patterns and electrophysiological measures of transmitter
release at the frog neuromuscular junction.
J Physiol (Paris)
87:193-201.
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Bewick GS,
Betz WJ
(1994)
Illumination partly reverses the
postsynaptic blockade of the frog neuromuscular junction by the styryl
pyridinium dye RH414.
Proc R Soc Lond [Biol]
258:201-207 .
[Medline]
-
Cooper JA
(1987)
Effects of cytochalasin and phalloidin on
actin.
J Cell Biol
105:1473-1478 .
[Free Full Text]
-
DeCamilli P,
Benfenati F,
Valtorta F,
Greengard P
(1990)
The
synapsins.
Annu Rev Cell Biol
6:433-460.
[Web of Science]
-
Greengard P,
Valtorta F,
Czernik AJ,
Benfenati F
(1993)
Synaptic vesicle phosphoproteins and regulation of
synaptic function.
Science
259:780-785 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Haystead TAJ,
Sim ATR,
Carling D,
Honnor RC,
Tsukitani R,
Cohen P,
Hardie DG
(1989)
Effects of the tumour promoter okadaic
acid on intracellular protein phosphorylation and metabolism.
Nature
337:78-81.
[Medline]
-
Henkel AW,
Betz WJ
(1995)
Monitoring of black widow spider
venom (BWSV) induced exo- and endocytosis in living frog motor nerve
terminals with FM1-43.
Neuropharmacology
34:1397-1406 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Henkel AW,
Lübke J,
Betz WJ
(1996)
FM1-43
ultrastructural localization in and release from frog motor nerve
terminals.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
93:1918-1923.
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Heuser J
(1989)
Review of electron microscopic evidence
favouring vesicle exocytosis as the structural basis for quantal
release during synaptic transmission.
Q J Exp Physiol
74:1051-1069 .
[Free Full Text]
-
Hirokawa N,
Sobue K,
Kanda K,
Harada A,
Yorifuji H
(1989)
The
cytoskeletal architecture of the presynaptic terminal and molecular
structure of synapsin.
Int J Cell Biol
108:111-126.
-
Jacobson K,
Zhang F,
Tsay TT
(1991)
Fluorescence recovery
after photobleaching techniques to measure translational mobility in
microscopic samples.
Scanning Microsci
5:357-362.
-
Landis DMD,
Hall AK,
Weinstein LA,
Reese TS
(1988)
The
organiza-tion of cytoplasm at the presynaptic active zone of a central
nervous system synapse.
Neuron
1:201-209.
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Montecucco C,
Schiavo G
(1994)
Mechanism of action of tetanus
and botulinum neurotoxins.
Mol Microbiol
13:1-8 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Nakata T,
Hirokawa N
(1992)
Organization of cortical
cytoskeleton of cultured chromaffin cells and involvement in secretion
as revealed by quickfreeze, deep-etching, and double-label
immunoelectron microscopy.
J Neurosci
12:2186-2197 .
[Abstract]
-
Ribchester RR,
Betz WJ
(1994)
Optical measurements of
activity-dependent membrane recycling in motor nerve terminals of
mammalian skeletal muscle.
Proc R Soc Lond [Biol]
255:61-66 .
[Medline]
-
Simpson LL
(1989)
Botulinum neurotoxin and tetanus toxin.
.
-
Simpson LL,
Dasgupta BR
(1983)
Botulinum neurotoxin type E:
studies on the mechanism of action and on structure-activity
relationships.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther
224:135-140 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Simpson LL,
Schmidt JJ,
Middlebrook JL
(1988)
Isolation and
characterization of the botuinum neurotoxins.
Methods Enzymol
165:76-85 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Sontag JM,
Aunis D,
Bader MF
(1988)
Peripheral actin
filaments control calcium-mediated catecholamine release from
streptolysin-O-permeabilized chromaffin cells.
Eur J Cell Biol
46:316-326 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Terakawa S,
Manivannan S,
Kumakura K
(1993)
Evidence
against the swelling hypothesis for initiation of exocytosis in
terminals of chromaffin cell processes.
J Physiol (Paris)
87:209-213.
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Valtorta F,
Greengard P,
Fesce R,
Chieregatti E,
Benfenati F
(1992)
Effects of the neuronal phosphoprotein synapsin I on
actin polymerization.
J Biol Chem
267:11281-11299 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Vitale ML,
Seward EP,
Trifaro J-M
(1995)
Chromaffin
cell cortical actin network dynamics control the size of the
release-ready vesicle pool and the initial rate of exocytosis.
Neuron
14:353-363 .
[Web of Science][Medline]
-
Wade MH,
Trosko JE,
Schindler MA
(1986)
A fluorescence
photobleaching assay of gap junction-mediated communication between
human cells.
Science
232:525-528 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
J. M. Brittain, A. D. Piekarz, Y. Wang, T. Kondo, T. R. Cummins, and R. Khanna
An Atypical Role for Collapsin Response Mediator Protein 2 (CRMP-2) in Neurotransmitter Release via Interaction with Presynaptic Voltage-gated Calcium Channels
J. Biol. Chem.,
November 6, 2009;
284(45):
31375 - 31390.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
V. Westphal, S. O. Rizzoli, M. A. Lauterbach, D. Kamin, R. Jahn, and S. W. Hell
Video-Rate Far-Field Optical Nanoscopy Dissects Synaptic Vesicle Movement
Science,
April 11, 2008;
320(5873):
246 - 249.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
L. LoGiudice, P. Sterling, and G. Matthews
Mobility and Turnover of Vesicles at the Synaptic Ribbon
J. Neurosci.,
March 19, 2008;
28(12):
3150 - 3158.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. A. Gaffield and W. J. Betz
Synaptic Vesicle Mobility in Mouse Motor Nerve Terminals with and without Synapsin
J. Neurosci.,
December 12, 2007;
27(50):
13691 - 13700.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. Nunes, N. Haines, V. Kuppuswamy, D. J. Fleet, and B. A. Stewart
Synaptic Vesicle Mobility and Presynaptic F-Actin Are Disrupted in a N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive Factor Allele of Drosophila
Mol. Biol. Cell,
November 1, 2006;
17(11):
4709 - 4719.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
D. L. Fortin, V. M. Nemani, S. M. Voglmaier, M. D. Anthony, T. A. Ryan, and R. H. Edwards
Neural Activity Controls the Synaptic Accumulation of {alpha}-Synuclein
J. Neurosci.,
November 23, 2005;
25(47):
10913 - 10921.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
E. A. Lemke and J. Klingauf
Single Synaptic Vesicle Tracking in Individual Hippocampal Boutons at Rest and during Synaptic Activity
J. Neurosci.,
November 23, 2005;
25(47):
11034 - 11044.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. A. Silverman, S. Johnson, D. Gurkins, M. Farmer, J. E. Lochner, P. Rosa, and B. A. Scalettar
Mechanisms of Transport and Exocytosis of Dense-Core Granules Containing Tissue Plasminogen Activator in Developing Hippocampal Neurons
J. Neurosci.,
March 23, 2005;
25(12):
3095 - 3106.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
Y.-F. Xu, D. Autio, M. B. Rheuben, and W. D. Atchison
Impairment of Synaptic Vesicle Exocytosis and Recycling During Neuromuscular Weakness Produced in Mice by 2,4-Dithiobiuret
J Neurophysiol,
December 1, 2002;
88(6):
3243 - 3258.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. A. Rizzo, M. A. Magnuson, P. F. Drain, and D. W. Piston
A Functional Link between Glucokinase Binding to Insulin Granules and Conformational Alterations in Response to Glucose and Insulin
J. Biol. Chem.,
September 6, 2002;
277(37):
34168 - 34175.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. Congar and L.-E. Trudeau
Perturbation of synaptic vesicle delivery during neurotransmitter release triggered independently of calcium influx
J. Physiol.,
August 1, 2002;
542(3):
779 - 793.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
A. Dunaevsky and E. A. Connor
F-Actin Is Concentrated in Nonrelease Domains at Frog Neuromuscular Junctions
J. Neurosci.,
August 15, 2000;
20(16):
6007 - 6012.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
B. Reid, C. R. Slater, and G. S. Bewick
Synaptic Vesicle Dynamics in Rat Fast and Slow Motor Nerve Terminals
J. Neurosci.,
April 1, 1999;
19(7):
2511 - 2521.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
A. de Paiva, F. A. Meunier, J. Molgo, K. R. Aoki, and J. O. Dolly
Functional repair of motor endplates after botulinum neurotoxin type A poisoning: Biphasic switch of synaptic activity between nerve sprouts and their parent terminals
PNAS,
March 16, 1999;
96(6):
3200 - 3205.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. A. Quigley, M. Msghina, C. K. Govind, and H. L. Atwood
Visible Evidence for Differences in Synaptic Effectiveness With Activity-Dependent Vesicular Uptake and Release of FM1-43
J Neurophysiol,
January 1, 1999;
81(1):
356 - 370.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
R. Prekeris and D. M. Terrian
Brain Myosin V Is a Synaptic Vesicle-associated Motor Protein: Evidence for a Ca2+-dependent Interaction with the Synaptobrevin-Synaptophysin Complex
J. Cell Biol.,
June 30, 1997;
137(7):
1589 - 1601.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
K. Kraszewski, L. Daniell, O. Mundigl, and P. De Camilli
Mobility of Synaptic Vesicles in Nerve Endings Monitored by Recovery from Photobleaching of Synaptic Vesicle-Associated Fluorescence
J. Neurosci.,
October 1, 1996;
16(19):
5905 - 5913.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|
|

|