 |
Previous Article | Next Article 
Volume 16, Number 18,
Issue of September 15, 1996
pp. 5749-5761
Copyright ©1996 Society for Neuroscience
Development of an Identified Spinal Commissural Interneuron
Population in an Amniote: Neurons of the Avian Hofmann Nuclei
Anne Lill Eide1 and
Joel C. Glover2
1 Department of Physiology, and
2 Department of Anatomy, Institute of Basic Medical
Sciences, University of Oslo, 0317 Oslo, Norway
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
MATERIALS AND METHODS
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
FOOTNOTES
REFERENCES
ABSTRACT
The commissural interneurons of the Hofmann nuclei (HN) of the
avian spinal cord (The axonal projections of the Hofmann nuclei in the
spinal cord of the late stage chicken embryo, Anat Embryol (Berl), A. L. Eide, 1996 , Vol 193, pp 543-557) provide a unique opportunity to
describe the development of an identified spinal commissural axon
projection and its terminal collaterals in an amniote vertebrate. Here,
we use the lipophilic tracer DiI to label these and other commissural
projections anterogradely and retrogradely from the time the HN neurons
are born. [3H]thymidine birthdating shows that the final
mitoses of HN neurons occur at stages 21-24 [developmental day (d)
4]. By direct comparison, this follows the generation of motoneurons
and of large, dorsally located commissural interneurons. The first HN
neurons reach the ventrolateral margin of the spinal cord by d6 by a
radial migration through the ventral horn. Radial migration occurs
after the extension of HN axons across the midline. Thus, HN neurons
are determined to be commissural interneurons before attaining their
definitive locations. The HN neurons subsequently aggregate into
segmentally iterated clusters at the ventrolateral margin of the spinal
cord by d8. Also by d8 their longitudinal axons attain mature extent in
the ventral funiculus of the contralateral side and begin to sprout
collaterals. The collaterals are directed predominantly toward the
medial aspect of the ventral horn at all stages, forming by d12 a dense
thicket of terminals that thins out over several segments to each side
of the HN of origin. The initial direction of collateral outgrowth is
largely appropriate for the mature termination pattern of the HN.
Terminal arbors, however, are less focused at early developmental
stages than at later stages.
Key words:
birthdating;
spinal interneuron;
neuronal migration;
axon
outgrowth;
collateral sprouting;
spinal cord;
chicken embryo
INTRODUCTION
Spinal interneurons are responsible in large part
for the integrated function of the spinal cord. Many project
intersegmentally to link different axial levels of the cord, and many
of these decussate to effect bilateral coordination. These
interneuronal connections engender many complex motor patterns with a
spinal autonomy (Fukson et al., 1980 ; Grillner, 1981 ; Berkenblit et
al., 1989 ; Stein, 1989 ; Bizzi et al., 1991 ; Mussa-Ivaldi et al., 1994 )
that was appreciated early in the history of neurophysiology and even
led to the concept of a spinal ``soul'' (Pflüger, 1853 ).
Despite the cardinal role of spinal interneurons in organizing spinal
function, relatively little is known about their connectivity,
especially in amniotes. This necessarily hampers the study of the
development of spinal interneurons, a subject that has received
increasing attention in recent years. Existing descriptions of the
development of spinal interneurons in amniotes are fragmentary, based
mostly on retrograde axonal tracing or immunohistochemistry for
cytoskeletal or membrane proteins (for review, see Yaginuma et al.,
1994 ). Such techniques do not facilitate the selective study of
specific identified interneuron populations, and they have not provided
any information about the development of termination patterns. More
complete and selective descriptions are available for the primary
spinal interneurons of certain anamniotes (Dale et al., 1987 ; Roberts
et al., 1987 , 1988 ; Kuwada et al., 1990a ,b). Although some aspects of
spinal interneuronal development in anamniotes can probably be
generalized to amniotes (Colamarino and Tessier-Lavigne, 1995 ), a
comprehensive description of the development of a specific spinal
interneuron type in an amniote embryo would provide an important
standard for future studies of spinal cord development.
We have recently shown that the paragriseal Hofmann nuclei (HN) of the
avian spinal cord contain commissural interneurons whose spatial
isolation makes them especially amenable to anatomical and
physiological analysis (Eide, 1996 ). Paragriseal neurons are found in
the spinal cords of all vertebrates, but their anatomy and function
have remained obscure (for review, see Eide, 1996 ). The HN comprise a
specific subpopulation of paragriseal neurons that are organized into
segmentally iterated aggregations located along the ventrolateral edge
of the spinal white matter, between the outlets of the ventral roots.
Eide (1996) has shown that the commissural projections from HN neurons
extend over several segments and provide terminal collaterals to a
ventromedial region of the gray matter corresponding roughly to lamina
VIII. Potential targets of the HN neurons thus include lamina VIII
commissural interneurons that are presynaptic to motoneurons (Harrison
et al., 1986 ; Jankowska and Noga, 1990 ) and the medial dendrites of
motoneurons. Afferent input to the HN neurons was shown to derive from
a separate population of commissural interneurons lying just lateral to
the central canal at lumbar levels (Eide, 1996 ). These features
implicate the HN neurons as integral components of a spinal
interneuronal network.
Here we examine the development of the HN neurons in the chicken embryo
with particular reference to their birth, migration, axonal
projections, and termination patterns.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
White Italian chicken embryos were incubated in a forced-draft
incubator at 37°C until the desired stage, at which time they were
either used for neuronal birthdating or killed for axonal tracing.
Staging was according to Hamburger and Hamilton (1951) . In this paper,
we refer both to developmental stage and to day of development (d),
which designates an integral multiple of 24 hr of development from the
start of incubation.
The HN are located between two consecutive ventral roots. Their
segmental location is designated with reference to the roots. For
example, HN-LS5/6 refers to the HN located between the roots of
lumbosacral segments (LS) 5 and 6.
Birthdating by autoradiography. Thirty-two embryos at
successive stages of development from stage 15 to stage 30 (d2-d6)
were exposed by opening a window in the egg.
Methyl-[3H]thymidine (20-45 µCi; Amersham-TRK686,
specific activity 83 Ci/mmol) in a volume of 40-90 µl of saline was
applied to each embryo through the window with a microliter
syringe.
At d14-d16, by which time the HN are easily identified, the embryos
were removed from the egg, anesthetized by cooling in oxygenated PBS,
pH 7.4, and killed by decapitation. The preparations were fixed
overnight in 4% formaldehyde in 0.1 phosphate buffer. A
hemisection of the cord including HN-LS5/6 was cut out for further
analysis. The tissue was equilibrated in 15% sucrose in phosphate
buffer, mounted in Tissue-Tek O.C.T. compound (Chemi-Teknik, Oslo,
Norway), frozen at 20°, sectioned transversely at 10 µm on a
cryostat, and mounted onto gelatin-coated glass slides. The sections
were treated with 1 ethanolamine for 10 min to eliminate
free aldehyde groups that can react with film emulsion and increase
background. They were then dehydrated and rehydrated through a series
of ethanol (50%-70%-96%-96%-70%-H2O) and air dried.
Kodak NTB2 emulsion (diluted 1:1 in distilled water) was applied by the
method of Kopriwa and LeBlond (1962) . The emulsion was exposed for
20 d at 4°C, developed in Kodak D19, and counterstained with
thionin.
This application method has been shown to give cumulative labeling, as
the [3H]thymidine evidently remains available throughout
the duration of neurogenesis, although this is dependent on the stage
of application (Langman and Haden, 1970 ; Hollyday and Hamburger, 1977 ;
McConnell and Sechrist, 1980 ). In embryos younger than 48 hr of
development, thymidine is apparently metabolized within a few hours
such that single or closely spaced multiple applications elicit
pulse-labeling during one mitotic cycle (Martin and Langman, 1965 ). In
our experiments, the long-term availability of the applied thymidine
was confirmed by the persistent labeling of cells in the ventricular
zone and the labeling of nearly all cells using the earliest
applications (Hollyday and Hamburger, 1977 ).
The assessment of birthdate using cumulative labeling is based on the
presumption that any neuron that is not labeled has been born before
the application of [3H]thymidine. The generation of a
neuron population is thus chronicled by determining the stage(s) at
which labeling ceases.
The sections were examined in the light microscope. Only cells that
contained a distinct nucleus in the plane of section were scored.
Labeled cells contained grains of developed photoemulsion over the
nucleus and were easy to identify. In each preparation, the proportion
of labeled to unlabeled HN neurons was established. Motoneurons and
large interneurons in the dorsal horn were also scored to correlate the
birthdates of the different populations.
DiI tracing. A total of 65 embryos at successive
developmental stages from d3 to d14 were killed for axonal tracing
experiments (Table 1). The spinal cord from thoracic
segment (Th) 4 to LS14 was dissected out in cold oxygenated PBS, the
ventral and dorsal cartilage (or bone at late stages) was removed, and
the dura was slit open. The preparations were fixed in cold 4%
formaldehyde in phosphate buffer and kept refrigerated in this solution
for 1 d to several months before tracer was applied. Variation in
time of storage before tracer application did not influence the
results.
Table 1.
Number of preparations used for DiI-labeling experiments at
each development stage
| Day of
development |
Number |
|
| d3 |
1 |
| d4 |
5 |
| d5 |
10 |
| d6 |
6 |
| d7 |
13 |
| d8 |
7 |
| d9 |
2 |
| d10 |
7 |
| d11 |
1 |
| d12 |
6 |
| d13 |
0 |
| d14 |
7 |
| Total |
65 |
|
The lipophilic tracer
1,1 -dioctadecyl-3,3,3 ,3 -tetramethylindocarbocyanine
perchlorate (DiI; Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) was used as a
tracer substance. DiI partitions into the lipid bilayer of cellular
membranes and diffuses passively along axons (Honig and Hume, 1986 ),
also in fixed tissue (Godement et al., 1987 ). Fixed preparations were
rinsed with phosphate buffer, drained, and daubed dry with tissue
paper. DiI was then applied either in the form of dry crystals on the
tip of a needle or with a micropipette as a saturated solution in 100%
ethanol. The preparations were left in fixative at 37°C for diffusion
to take place. The diffusion time was chosen according to developmental
stage and type of preparation and varied from 4 hr to 150 d.
Because DiI diffuses throughout the neuronal membrane, both anterograde
and retrograde labeling inevitably occur in all neurons that intersect
the application site. For anterograde labeling of the HN neurons, DiI
was generally applied to HN-LS5/6 or, before the overt appearance
of the HN, to the spinal cord at the same level. For retrograde
labeling of the HN neurons, DiI was applied unilaterally to the spinal
cord either in the middle lumbosacral region or rostral to the
lumbosacral region. The various application paradigms and
representative examples of anterograde labeling are illustrated in
Figure 1.
Fig. 1.
The different DiI application paradigms.
A-D illustrate schematically the sites of DiI
application (indicated by arrowheads and/or
dots). E and F show
representative examples of anterograde labeling from a single HN at d8.
A, Anterograde tracing of the entire commissural
projection from the level corresponding to a single HN in preparations
from d4 to d8. DiI is applied to one side of the spinal cord between
two ventral roots. The spinal cord is split along the midline except
for between the two roots. This restricts the anterograde labeling to
those axons crossing within this region. It also eliminates retrograde
labeling of commissural interneurons on the contralateral side at all
other levels. B, Retrograde tracing of commissural
interneurons in preparations from d4 to d14. DiI is applied to the
ventral and ventrolateral funiculi on one side midway between two
ventral roots. The spinal cord is split along the midline at the same
level. This eliminates anterograde labeling of commissural axons
originating from the injected side. It also restricts retrograde
labeling to commissural axons originating from the contralateral side
of more rostral and caudal levels. This reveals the distribution of the
commissural interneurons, including HN neurons, on the contralateral
side, the longitudinal axons of which traverse the injected level.
C, Selective anterograde tracing of the HN projection.
DiI is applied selectively to one HN. The spinal cord is split along
the midline except for the region in which the axons from the injected
HN cross. This eliminates retrograde labeling of contralateral
commissural interneurons rostral and caudal to the split and allows the
HN axons and collaterals to be viewed in isolation. D,
Retrograde tracing of the entire HN population. DiI is applied to one
side of the spinal cord over many segments. This reveals the
longitudinal disposition of the HN somata during the formation of the
HN. E, Ventral view of a whole-mount spinal cord at d8
in which DiI has been applied to a single HN. The HN axons are visible
along their commissural and longitudinal trajectories.
F, Transverse section through a similar preparation
showing the HN axon trajectory directed radially toward the ventral
pole of the central canal and then crossing in the ventral commissure.
Note that labeling extends all the way to the ventricular surface. This
represents the ventricular attachments of radial glia that extend to
the HN, not ventricular attachments of the HN neurons themselves (see
text). Scale bars: 500 µm in E and 200 µm in
F.
[View Larger Version of this Image (72K GIF file)]
Labeled preparations were first examined in whole mount. They were then
rinsed in phosphate buffer overnight, embedded in 17% gelatin in
phosphate buffer, and sectioned transversely at 50-100 µm on a
Vibratome (Campden Instruments LTD, 752 Vibroslice). To
maintain the integrity of the labeling, it was necessary to keep the
sections wet at all times; even a few minutes of drying disrupted the
stain. To attach the wet sections to a glass slide for microscopic
examination, the gelatin edges of the sections were melted onto the
slide with a hot needle. The sections were covered with 4%
formaldehyde, coverslipped, and could then be stored in slide jars
containing 1-2% formaldehyde at 4°C for many months. Contamination
of the surface of the section occurred over time, presumably because
labeled and unlabeled membranes are disrupted and come into contact
there. Thus, microscopic examination of the sections was performed
during the first 1-3 d after sectioning.
Fluorescence microscopy. Whole-mount preparations and
transverse sections were examined under a Leitz Ortholux II
epifluorescence microscope outfitted with a rhodamine filter.
RESULTS
This study covers a developmental period characterized by
tremendous growth and morphometric change in the spinal cord. Figure
2 provides an anatomical framework for the comparison of
results obtained at different stages. The HN can be discerned as
protrusions along the lateral edge of the lumbar spinal cord from d8.
This is the earliest time at which the HN neurons can be anterogradely
labeled selectively.
Fig. 2.
The development of the HN in the context of the
morphometric changes occurring in the spinal cord during the
developmental period studied. For each developmental stage, we show:
(1) a drawing of a ventral view of the lumbar region of the spinal cord
(the series of drawings is at the same scale to illustrate relative
size); (2) a photomicrograph of a ventral view of one side of the
spinal cord showing the disposition of the HN (first distinctly visible
from d8); and (3) a photomicrograph of a transverse section through the
lumbar spinal cord at the level of an HN (arrows). Scale
bars: 2 mm in all drawings, 500 µm in the left photomicrographs, and
200 µm in the right photomicrographs.
[View Larger Version of this Image (73K GIF file)]
Birthdating
The mitoses that generate the HN neurons occur between stages 21 and 24. In embryos exposed to [3H]thymidine before stage
21, all HN neurons were labeled, whereas in those exposed after stage
24 (d4), none was labeled. Two preparations at stage 23 contained,
respectively, 80 and 50% labeled HN neurons.
Two other neuron types could be identified readily in transverse
sections and compared with the HN neurons with respect to time of
generation: namely, the motoneurons of the lateral motor column and
large commissural interneurons located between laminae II and III and
at the boundary between the intermediate zone and the dorsal horn (Fig.
3) (Eide and Glover, 1996 ). At the stages when HN
neurons were labeled with [3H]thymidine, the vast
majority of each of these other neuron types was unlabeled, indicating
that they are born before the HN neurons (Fig. 3). The birthdates we
obtained here for the motoneurons are in accord with the observations
of Hollyday and Hamburger (1977) .
Fig. 3.
[3H]thymidine birthdating of HN
neurons and other neuron populations. A,
Autoradiographic transverse section from the spinal cord of a d15
embryo labeled with [3H]thymidine at stage 23 (early d4).
Circles enclose the regions shown in B,
C, and F. B, Intermingled
labeled and unlabeled HN neurons; the latter were born before
[3H]thymidine application. C, All
motoneurons in the lateral motor column are unlabeled, demonstrating
that this neuron population is born before the HN cells.
D, Retrograde labeling of a large dorsal commissural
interneuron at d7. E, Retrograde labeling of a large
dorsal commissural interneuron at d15. F, Large dorsal
interneurons of the same size, shape, and location as in
E are unlabeled (arrow), demonstrating
that this neuron population is born before the HN neurons. Scale bars:
500 µm in A, 50 µm in B,
C, E, and F, and 200 µm in
D.
[View Larger Version of this Image (112K GIF file)]
HN neuron migration and aggregation
When DiI was injected into the ventral funiculus on one side of
the lumbar spinal cord, interneurons projecting ipsilaterally were
labeled retrogradely on the same side, and commissural interneurons
were labeled retrogradely on the opposite side. The pattern of
commissural interneuron labeling changed over time and will be
discussed in more detail below. Here we draw attention to a feature of
the labeling that bears specifically on the migration of the HN
neurons.
In the immediate vicinity of a unilateral DiI injection, all cells,
including neurons and radial glia, were labeled simply because of
nonspecific spread. But at levels rostral or caudal to the injected
region on the same side, or at any level on the contralateral side,
only interneurons whose axons projected to or through the injected
region became labeled. This is shown in Figure
4A, in a section taken caudal to the
injected region on d7. The labeling of commissural interneurons has
been limited to those crossing rostral and caudal to the injected
region by the midline split, as shown in Figure 4D. The
domains of the lateral motor columns are outlined by labeled
interneurons and their dendrites (both sides), as well as by labeled
ventral axon tracts (injected side). The labeled processes radiating
through the lateral motor column toward the lateral margin of the
spinal cord on the side contralateral to the injection are the
retrogradely labeled axons of the HN neurons, which were consistently
seen only on the contralateral side (Fig. 4A).
Elongated somata with radial orientation and devoid of dendrites were
clearly associated with these axons on d6 (Fig. 4B,C), but
no longer by d8. Our interpretation is that the HN somata have already
extended a commissural axon by this stage of their development, but are
still in the process of migrating laterally by nuclear translocation.
The temporal sequence of events thus appears to be as follows: HN
neurons, after undergoing their terminal mitoses in the ventral
ventricular zone by d4, extend migratory leading processes through the
lateral motor column to the pial surface, parallel to radial glia, and
begin to migrate by nuclear translocation. By d6, while still migrating
radially, they have extended commissural axons across the midline. By
d8, their radial migration brings them to their definitive locations at
the ventrolateral margin of the spinal cord.
Fig. 4.
Lateral migration of HN neurons. Transverse
sections through the ventral spinal cord showing the distribution of
retrogradely labeled commissural interneurons at d7 (A)
and d6 (B, C) after DiI application to the right side as
shown in D. A, The labeling pattern is
different on the injected (right) and contralateral
(left) sides immediately caudal to the level of
injection. Radial processes extending through the lateral motor column
are present only on the side contralateral to the injection and
represent the retrogradely labeled axons of the HN neurons.
B and C show examples of somata (presumed
HN somata) associated with these axons. D summarizes
schematically the distribution of axons and cell bodies labeled by this
DiI application procedure. The small black ellipses
represent interneurons, HN neurons on the left side and an
ipsilaterally projecting interneuron on the right, the
latter lying lateral to longitudinal axons. Hatching
indicates the DiI application site, and arrowheads
indicate the location of the sections shown in A-C.
Scale bars, 100 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (70K GIF file)]
In addition to the radially oriented leading processes of the HN
neurons, radial glia (which are not labeled in Fig. 4)
extend through the lateral motor column. At d8, selective application
of DiI to the HN typically labeled not only the HN commissural axons
but also fibers that extended to the ventricular surface (Fig.
1F). These ventricular attachments were not labeled
when the HN axons were traced retrogradely from the contralateral side.
Thus, they cannot be ventricular attachments of the HN neurons
themselves. Rather, they must be the ventricular attachments of radial
glia cells that extend from the ventricular surface to the HN.
Evidently these cells are eliminated or retract from the ventricular
surface after d8, because application of DiI to the HN at later stages
did not label any ventricular attachments.
After their radial migration, the HN underwent a longitudinal
aggregation. At d7, the HN neuron population appeared as a fairly
continuous column along the ventrolateral margin (Fig.
5). By d8, the column was clearly segmented into
clusters that gradually coalesced to form the definitive protruding HN
(Fig. 5). Support for a segmental aggregation of an initially
unsegmented column of HN neurons comes from the relationship between
soma and axon distributions in late stage embryos, as described by Eide
(1996) . Although the HN neuron somata are clearly segmentally
clustered, their commissural axons are evenly distributed along the
length of the spinal cord. The most likely explanation is that radial
migration of HN somata and commissural axon extension occurs evenly
along the entire length of the lumbar cord, leaving a record of the
initial unsegmented distribution as the HN neurons aggregate into
segmental clusters.
Fig. 5.
The longitudinal aggregation of HN neurons.
Ventral views of the spinal cord at the indicated developmental stages.
All HN neurons have been retrogradely labeled as shown in Figure
1D. Scale bars, 500 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (69K GIF file)]
The commissural interneuron population as a whole
The first commissural axons in the lumbar spinal cord of the
chicken embryo cross the midline at about d3, and then turn either
rostrally or caudally in the contralateral ventral funiculus (Yaginuma
et al., 1991 ). At the earliest stage we examined, stage 23 (d4), the
first few commissural axons had already crossed the ventral midline
(see below). From then on there was a successive recruitment of
commissural axons as shown by the increasing number of retrogradely
labeled neurons contralateral to the DiI application. This retrograde
tracing did not label the HN neurons selectively, but also labeled
other commissural interneurons (Fig. 6). Some of these
could be distinguished before the radial migration of the HN neurons
through the lateral motor column. The commissural interneurons labeled
retrogradely at d5 were located predominantly dorsal to the lateral
motor column. Their axons projected first laterally to the lateral
margin, where they extended ventrally, skirting the medial aspect of
the nascent lateral motor column before striking across the midline
through the most ventral region of the floor plate (Fig. 6). Occasional
commissural interneuron somata labeled at d5 were located in the
ventricular zone (Fig. 6). By d6, the number of retrogradely labeled
commissural interneurons had increased, and many were located medial to
the lateral motor column (Fig. 6). With continued development, the
commissural interneuron population increased further in number, with a
distribution skewed toward the ventral half of the spinal cord by d8
(Fig. 6). The number of labeled commissural interneurons fell with
distance from the injected segment (Fig. 6). Characteristically large
dorsally located commissural interneurons were among those with the
longest longitudinal projections.
Fig. 6.
Retrograde labeling of the entire commissural
interneuron population located between LS5 and LS6 at the indicated
developmental stages (DiI application as in Fig. 1B).
Each row of plates shows the pattern of labeling at the same indicated
stage, with distance rostrad increasing from left to
right over a distance of about two to three segments.
Scale bars, 100 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (113K GIF file)]
Development of longitudinal projections
The extension of longitudinal axons after bifurcation of the
commissural axon population was examined using three different
experimental approaches. In the first, used from d4 to d7.5, we labeled
anterogradely all commissural axons crossing at a specific
level by applying DiI to the ventral region of one side of the spinal
cord (Fig. 7). The ventral commissure was split rostral
and caudal to the DiI application site to restrict labeling to the
commissural axons crossing at the level of application (Fig.
1A). In this case, it was impossible to distinguish
labeled HN axons from other labeled axons. In the second, used from
d5.5 to d8, we labeled retrogradely all commissural axons
that had turned or bifurcated to extend through a given spinal level by
applying DiI to the ventral funiculus on one side of the spinal cord
(Fig. 1B). In this case, from d7 onward, we could determine
selectively the longitudinal extent of the HN axons by virtue of the
retrograde labeling of their distinctly localized and easily identified
somata (see Fig. 5). In the third, used from d8 on, we selectively
labeled the axons of the HN neurons anterogradely by
applying DiI to the HN itself (Fig. 1C). Projection
distances were quantitated in at least three preparations from each
developmental day, starting at d4 (stage 23) (Fig.
8).
Fig. 7.
The progressive longitudinal growth of axonal
projections from commissural interneurons. Ventral views of the spinal
cord at the indicated developmental stages. At d8, a single HN is
labeled selectively; at earlier stages, the entire commissural axon
population is labeled. Scale bars: 100 µm (d4.5), 500 µm (all
subsequent stages).
[View Larger Version of this Image (117K GIF file)]
Fig. 8.
The progressive longitudinal growth of axonal
projections from the entire commissural interneuron population located
between LS5 and LS6 (points and solid
lines) or from HN-LS5/6 (dashed lines). Axon
extent is expressed in terms of segmental reach (A) and
absolute length (B) at the indicated developmental
stages. Points represent maximum extents observed in
single preparations, whereas the solid lines represent
averages of these. Points are only shown for the early stages when
maximum extents are more variable. For the entire commissural axon
population, average extents are derived from three, seven, and four
preparations at d4, d5, and d6, respectively. For the HN commissural
axon population, average extents are derived from three preparations at
each of d8 and d14.
[View Larger Version of this Image (15K GIF file)]
By d4, a few commissural axons extended directly across the ventral
midline, some of them then turned either rostrally or caudally or
bifurcated near the ventrolateral margin and extended longitudinally up
to a distance of about one segment in one or both directions (Figs. 7,
8). By d5, the number of commissural axons had increased dramatically
and had spurted 4 to 7 segments, or ~1.5 mm, in each direction (Figs.
7, 8). By d6, the axons had extended about another millimeter in each
direction, although this was equivalent to only about two additional
segments because of the concomitant longitudinal growth of the spinal
cord (Figs. 7, 8). Throughout this period, the rostral and caudal
projection distances were roughly symmetrical about the segment of
origin.
At d7 and later, we could not determine the full longitudinal extent of
the entire commissural axon population because the DiI labeling faded
out before reaching the axon termini. This means that some commissural
axons must extend many segments in each direction already at an early
stage of spinal cord development. By contrast, we could determine the
full reach of the HN axons at all stages because these were always
strongly labeled throughout their extent.
At d8, the earliest time at which the HN axon population could be
labeled selectively (Figs. 7, 8), the HN axons had extended about four
segments in each direction. This is approximately equivalent to the
mature HN projection (Eide, 1996 ), but was less than the segmental
extent attained by the entire commissural axon population by d6. Of
course, in terms of absolute distance, the HN axons must continue to
elongate by intercalary growth even after d8 to maintain their
segmental reach in the face of continued lengthening of the spinal cord
(Fig. 8B) (Eide and Glover, 1995 ).
Development of collateral branches
When we labeled anterogradely all commissural axons
crossing at a given level, the process of collateral sprouting could be
followed in transverse sections rostral and caudal to the DiI
application (Fig. 9). The first collaterals appeared at
d7, i.e., approximately 3 d after the first commissural axons had
begun to extend longitudinally in the ventral funiculus. Initially, the
collaterals were straight unbranched neurites oriented at various
angles into the gray matter in the transverse plane. Later, the angle
made by the collaterals in the transverse plane generally depended on
the mediolateral positions of the parent longitudinal axons;
collaterals originating from more medial axons projected more dorsad,
whereas those originating from more lateral axons projected more mediad
(not shown). The collaterals were thus oriented approximately parallel
to radial glia. By d9, the collaterals had initiated secondary
branching (not shown).
Fig. 9.
Early development of axon collaterals from the
entire commissural interneuron population located between LS5 and LS6.
Transverse sections through the contralateral side of the spinal cord.
The commissural axon population has bifurcated to extend longitudinally
in the ventral and ventrolateral white matter at d5 (A)
and d6 (B), but collaterals first appear at d7
(C, arrow). By d8 (D,
E), only a few unbranched collaterals have been
elaborated. All sections are from the region just rostral to the DiI
application site (DiI applied as in Fig. 1A). Scale
bars, 100 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (73K GIF file)]
When we first selectively labeled the HN axons anterogradely at d8,
only a very few collaterals were present, and these were slightly less
mature than the collaterals labeled from the entire commissural
projection at d8. This indicates that the HN axons lag the earliest
commissural axons slightly in the establishment of collaterals.
Moreover, it shows that the entire process of HN collateral sprouting
can be followed by selectively labeling the definitive HN, starting at
d8.
The first HN collateral sprouts appeared along much of the longitudinal
extent covered by the HN axons on d8 (Fig. 10). With
further development, collaterals gradually increased in number, most
rapidly at proximal positions. Secondary branching was initiated
between d10 and d12 (Fig. 10). The collaterals gradually became more
elaborate, and by d14 the HN collateral arbors contacted much of the
ventromedial gray matter (Fig. 10). Most collaterals were oriented
toward the medial region of the ventral horn throughout this process, a
feature especially prominent in collaterals arising distally, where the
parent longitudinal axons have acquired more lateral positions. The
termination pattern at d14 is similar to, but less focused than, the
heavy termination in lamina VIII seen at d18 (Eide, 1996 ).
Fig. 10.
The development of axon collaterals from a single
HN-LS5/6 at successively greater distances rostral to the HN (DiI
application as in Fig. 1C). Each row of plates shows the
pattern of labeling at the same indicated stage, with distance rostrad
increasing from left to right over a distance of about four segments.
Note the change in the mediolateral location of the longitudinal axons
with increasing distance and the corresponding change in angle of
collateral ingrowth. Scale bars, 100 µm.
[View Larger Version of this Image (155K GIF file)]
DISCUSSION
We have described the development of commissural neurons in the
avian spinal cord, with special emphasis on the Hofmann nuclei major
located at the ventrolateral margin of the spinal cord. The HN neurons
exhibit many of the general properties of commissural spinal
interneurons, and thus provide a good model for the study of
commissural interneuron development in amniotes (Eide, 1996 ). Their
axons follow the typical commissural interneuron trajectory, crossing
the midline at the level of the soma and extending longitudinally in
the ventrolateral white matter with a gradual shift to more lateral
positions from proximal to distal. They also have specific termination
and connectivity patterns that distinguish them from other commissural
interneurons. They are generated within a relatively narrow window of
developmental time, differentiate nearly synchronously, and eventually
become anatomically isolated. These features have facilitated the first
selective description of the differentiation of an identified
population of spinal commissural interneurons, from birth through the
formation of axon projections and terminal arbors.
Birth and radial migration
The HN neurons are born between stages 21 and 24, starting about a
half day after the very first interneurons are born in the lumbar
spinal cord (Hollyday and Hamburger, 1977 ; McConnell and Sechrist,
1980 ). The earliest born interneurons have positions similar to those
of the dorsally located commissural interneurons shown in Figure 3,
D and E. They are likely to correspond to the
dorsal-lateral border cells described by Oppenheim et al. (1988) and
are likely to be among the dorsally located interneurons that pioneer
the commissural pathway in the spinal cord (Yaginuma et al., 1990 ).
Hence, some specific types of spinal interneurons are born and
differentiate in the lumbar spinal cord before the first HN neurons are
born. By contrast, some specific types of spinal interneurons, such as
sensory interneurons in lamina II, are clearly born after the HN
neurons (Eide and Glover, 1996 ). This suggests that different types of
spinal interneurons have specific generation times, much as different
laminar populations of neurons in cortex, retina, optic tectum, and
other structures have specific generation times (for review, see
Jacobson, 1991 ).
By analogy to the mammalian cortex (McConnell, 1992 ), the generation of
different subtypes of spinal interneurons at different times could be
related to the determination of migratory destination. In particular,
the radial migration of the HN neurons, through the existing column of
motoneurons and to the ventrolateral surface of the spinal cord, is a
feature that distinguishes the HN neurons from other commissural
interneurons.
Although we have not witnessed the migration of HN neurons from their
birth sites in the ventricular zone, their radial trajectories in the
ventral neural tube suggest that they are born in the ventral part of
the ventricular zone (see Fig. 2). A ventral origin of the HN neurons
stands in contrast to the apparent dorsal origin of at least some other
commissural interneurons (Oppenheim et al., 1988 ; Leber and Sanes,
1995 ) (Fig. 6). Our impression from material such as that presented in
Figure 6 (middle top) is that commissural interneurons can
in fact originate from virtually any dorsoventral level of the
ventricular zone. This would seem to rule out progenitor position along
this axis as a potential determinant of the commissural interneuron
phenotype.
Somatic motoneurons also originate from the ventral ventricular zone
and migrate laterally in advance of the HN neurons, establishing the
lateral motor column through which the HN neurons migrate. Evidently,
motoneuron and HN neuron lineages have diverged before the birth of the
motoneurons. After labeling motoneuron progenitors with a retroviral
lineage tracer at stages 11-18 (d2-d3), Leber et al. (1990) obtained
55 clones that contained both motoneurons and other cell types, but
only one of these contained HN neurons. Thus, separate progenitors for
motoneurons and HN neurons must coexist by these stages in the ventral
region of the ventricular zone.
Commissural axon outgrowth
The radially migrating HN neurons can first be labeled
retrogradely from the contralateral side starting at approximately d6.
Other commissural interneuron types located medial and dorsal to the
motoneuron column evidently are the source of the first commissural
axons we have observed with anterograde labeling. Oppenheim et al.
(1988) describe five categories of intersegmentally projecting spinal
interneurons in d2.5-d6 chicken embryos, with different locations in
the transverse plane. Each category includes, but is not homogeneously
composed of, commissural interneurons. In general, our descriptions of
the disposition of commissural interneurons are similar. Not
surprisingly, Oppenheim et al. (1988) make no mention of the HN
neurons, because these have not yet reached their definitive locations
and cannot be selectively identified by d6. But their
``ventral-horn'' category, located within the ventral horn or along
its medial border, might include HN neurons during their radial
migration.
The HN neurons can be labeled retrogradely from the contralateral side
of the spinal cord before reaching their definitive positions. Thus,
they appear to be determined as commissural neurons before or during
migration and not by virtue of their eventual location at the
ventrolateral margin of the neural tube. In this regard, the HN neurons
are similar to spinal motoneurons. Before reaching their definitive
migratory positions, motoneurons express specific combinations of
transcription factors of the LIM homeobox gene family (Tsuchida et al.,
1994 ). The combinatorial expression pattern of these transcription
factors predicts the final positions and peripheral axon pathways, and
thus functional classes, of the motoneurons (Tsuchida et al., 1994 ).
The implication is that a specific combination of transcription factors
triggers the expression of a specific set of the membrane proteins that
steer migration and axon pathfinding. Only one LIM transcription
factor, Lim-1, is known to be expressed by the HN neurons,
but is also expressed by motoneurons and other spinal
interneurons and hence does not define the HN neurons as a distinct
class (Tsuchida et al., 1994 ). Because other LIM transcription factors
reportedly define distinct subsets of spinal interneurons (Tsuchida et
al., 1994 ), it seems plausible that commissural interneurons are
differentiated into anatomical and functional subclasses based on
transcription factor expression, an issue to which the anatomically
isolated HN neurons provide convenient access.
In general, commissural axon outgrowth in the spinal cord follows a
circumferential trajectory that is believed to be steered by contact
guidance cues, followed by attraction to and interaction with the floor
plate (Colamarino and Tessier-Levigne, 1995). The site of axonogenesis
for interneurons located dorsal to the motor column is from the leading
(pial) process of the commissural interneuron, because contact with the
circumferential pathway is made near the pial surface (see Fig. 6). But
ventrally, where the HN neurons are generated, the circumferential
pathway lies not at the pial surface, but rather medial to the lateral
motor column. Because HN neurons eventually migrate past this point,
their axons could derive either from the leading (pial) process or the
trailing (ventricular) process, depending on the timing of axonogenesis
and migration. This illustrates a potential diversity in the way
commissural interneurons interact with their pathways.
Termination pattern
To our knowledge, this is the first description of the development
of termination pattern by spinal interneurons in an amniote. Several
features warrant mention. (1) Collateral sprouting does not begin until
the full segmental range of the longitudinal axons is established. Such
delayed sprouting has been observed in other axon systems (O'Leary et
al., 1990 ), including large diameter primary sensory afferents (Davis
et al., 1989 ; Eide and Glover, 1995 ) and descending axons (Glover and
Eide, 1992 ) in the spinal cord of the chicken embryo. Collaterals
sprout from these different spinal axon populations at approximately
the same time, at d7-d8, suggesting a general signal within the spinal
cord that induces collateral sprouting in all axons concomitantly. On
the other hand, the HN axons seem to lag slightly the earliest
developing commissural axons with respect to collateral sprouting,
suggesting that a certain level of axon maturation is required before
collateral sprouting. (2) Collateral sprouting occurs simultaneously
along the length of the HN axon population. This might represent a
developmental strategy that ensures that all HN collaterals interact
with the same environmental cues within the gray matter during
sprouting and terminal arborization. Because the spinal cord changes
dramatically both in form and cellular composition after d8 (Eide and
Glover, 1995 ), temporal discordance in the sprouting of collaterals
along the length of the axons could lead to strikingly different
patterns of connectivity along this length. (3) The position of the
longitudinal axon shifts laterally within the ventrolateral white
matter, such that proximal and distal collaterals issue from different
positions along the perimeter. Despite this, the majority of
collaterals along the entire length of the HN projection are directed
roughly toward the central canal (see Fig. 10), bringing them into the
medial region of the ventral horn. This behavior suggests a chemotropic
attraction of HN collaterals by diffusible factors originating from the
ventromedial gray matter. On the other hand, collateral angles are also
roughly correlated with the angular postures of radial glia within the
ventral spinal cord, suggesting a potential contact guidance function
for these.
FOOTNOTES
Received March 21, 1996; revised June 27, 1996; accepted July 2, 1996.
This work was supported by grants from the Norwegian Medical Research
Council and the Nansen Foundation.
Correspondence should be addressed to Anne Lill Eide, Department of
Physiology, Institute of Basic Medical Sciences, P.B. 1103 Blindern,
University of Oslo, 0317 Oslo, Norway.
REFERENCES
-
Berkenblit MB,
Feldman AG,
Fukson OI
(1989)
Wiping reflex
in the frog: movement patterns, receptive fields, and blends.
In: Visuomotor coordination: amphibians, comparisons, models and robots
(Ewert, J-P,
Arbib, MA,
eds)
, p. 615. New York: Plenum.
-
Bizzi E,
Mussa-Ivaldi FA,
Giszter S
(1991)
Computations
underlying the execution of movement: a biological perspective.
Science
253:287-291 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Colamarino SA,
Tessier-Lavigne M
(1995)
The role of the floor
plate in axon guidance.
Annu Rev Neurosci
18:497-529 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Dale N,
Roberts A,
Ottersen OP,
Storm-Mathisen J
(1987)
The
morphology and distribution of ``Kolmer-Agduhr cells,'' a class of
cerebrospinal-fluid-contacting neurons revealed in the frog embryo
spinal cord by GABA immunocytochemistry.
Proc R Soc Lond [Biol]
232:193-203 .
[Medline]
-
Davis B,
Frank E,
Johnson F,
Scott S
(1989)
Development of
central projections of lumbosacral sensory neurons in the chick.
J Comp Neurol
279:556-566 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Eide AL
(1996)
The axonal projections of the Hofmann nuclei
in the spinal cord of the late stage chicken embryo.
Anat Embryol (Berl)
193:543-557.
[Medline]
-
Eide AL,
Glover J
(1995)
Development of the longitudinal
projection pattern of lumbar primary sensory afferents in the chicken
embryo.
J Comp Neurol
353:247-259 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Eide AL, Glover J (1996) The developmental dynamics of
functionally specific primary sensory afferent projections in the
chicken embryo. Anat Embryol (Berl), in press.
-
Fukson OI,
Berkenblit MB,
Feldman AG
(1980)
The spinal frog
takes into account the scheme of its body during the wiping reflex.
Science
209:1261-1263 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Glover JC,
Eide AL
(1992)
Temporal progression of descending
axons in the chicken embryo spinal cord.
Soc Neurosci Abstr
18:218.
-
Godement P,
Vanselow J,
Thanos S,
Bonhoeffer F
(1987)
A study
in developing visual systems with a new method of staining neurons and
their processes in fixed tissue.
Development
101:697-713 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Grillner S (1981) Control of locomotion in bipeds, tetrapods,
and fish. In: Handbook of physiology, Sect 1, The nervous system, Vol
2, Motor control (Brooks VB, ed), pp 1179-1236. Bethesda: American
Physiological Society.
-
Hamburger V,
Hamilton H
(1951)
A series of normal stages in
the development of the chick embryo.
J Morphol
88:49-92.
[ISI]
-
Harrison PJ,
Jankowska E,
Zytnicki D
(1986)
Lamina VIII
interneurones interposed in crossed reflex pathways in the cat.
J Physiol (Lond)
371:147-166 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Hollyday M,
Hamburger V
(1977)
An autoradiographic study of
the formation of the lateral motor column in the chick embryo.
Brain Res
132:197-208 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Honig MG,
Hume R
(1986)
Fluorescent carbocyanine dyes allow
living neurons of identified origin to be studied in long term
cultures.
J Cell Biol
103:171-187 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Jacobson M
(1991)
Developmental neurobiology.
.
-
Jankowska E,
Noga BR
(1990)
Contralaterally projecting lamina
VIII interneurons in middle lumbar segments in the cat.
Brain Res
535:327-330 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Kopriwa B,
LeBlond CP
(1962)
Improvements in the coating
technique of radioautography.
J Histochem Cytochem
10:269-284.
[Abstract]
-
Kuwada JY,
Bernhardt RR,
Chitnis AB
(1990a)
Pathfinding by
identified growth cones in the spinal cord of zebrafish embryos.
J Neurosci
10:1299-1308 .
[Abstract]
-
Kuwada JY,
Bernhardt RR,
Nguyen N
(1990b)
Development of
spinal neurons and tracts in the zebrafish embryo.
J Comp Neurol
302:617-628 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Langman J,
Haden CC
(1970)
Formation and migration of
neuroblasts in the spinal cord of the chick embryo.
J Comp Neurol
138:419-432 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Leber SM,
Sanes JR
(1995)
Migratory paths of neurons and glia
in the embryonic chick spinal cord.
J Neurosci
15:1236-1248 .
[Abstract]
-
Leber SM,
Breedlove SM,
Sanes JR
(1990)
Lineage, arrangement,
and death of clonally related motoneurons in chick spinal cord.
J Neurosci
10:2451-2462 .
[Abstract]
-
Martin A,
Langman J
(1965)
The development of the spinal cord
examined by autoradiography.
J Embryol Exp Morphol
14:25-35 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
McConnell JA,
Sechrist JW
(1980)
Identification of early
neurons in the brainstem and spinal cord. I. An autoradiographic study
in the chick.
J Comp Neurol
192:769-783 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
McConnell SK
(1992)
The determination of neuronal identity in
the mammalian cerebral cortex.
In: Determinants of neuronal identity
(Shankland, M,
Macagno, ER,
eds)
, p. 391. San Diego: Academic.
-
Mussa-Ivaldi FA,
Giszter SF,
Bizzi E
(1994)
Linear
combinations of primitives in vertebrate motor control.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
91:7534-7538 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
O'Leary DD,
Bicknese AR,
De Carlos JA,
Heffner CD,
Koester SE,
Kutka LJ,
Terashima T
(1990)
Target selection by cortical axons:
alternative mechanisms to establish axonal connections in the
developing brain.
Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol
55:453-468.
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Oppenheim RW,
Shneiderman A,
Shimizu I,
Yaginuma H
(1988)
Onset and development of intersegmental projections
in the chick embryo spinal cord.
J Comp Neurol
275:159-180 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Pflüger E
(1853)
Die sensorischen Functionen des
Rückenmarks der Wirbeltiere.
.
-
Roberts A,
Dale N,
Ottersen OP,
Storm-Mathisen J
(1987)
The
early development of neurons with GABA immunoreactivity in the CNS of
Xenopus laevis embryos.
J Comp Neurol
261:435-449 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Roberts A,
Dale N,
Ottersen OP,
Storm-Mathisen J
(1988)
Development and characterization of commissural
interneurones in the spinal cord of Xenopus laevis embryos
revealed by antibodies to glycine.
Development
103:447-461 .
[Abstract]
-
Stein PSG
(1989)
Spinal cord circuits for motor pattern
selection in the turtle.
Ann NY Acad Sci
563:1-10.
[ISI]
-
Tsuchida T,
Ensini M,
Morton SB,
Baldassare M,
Edlund T,
Jessell TM,
Pfaff SL
(1994)
Topographic organization of embryonic motor
neurons defined by expression of LIM homeobox genes.
Cell
79:957-970 .
[ISI][Medline]
-
Yaginuma H,
Shiga T,
Homma S,
Ishihara R,
Oppenheim RW
(1990)
Identification of early developing axon projections
from spinal interneurons in the chick embryo with a neuron specific
beta-tubulin antibody: evidence for a new ``pioneer'' pathway in the
spinal cord.
Development
108:705-716 .
[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Yaginuma A,
Homma S,
Künzi R,
Oppenheim RW
(1991)
Pathfinding by growth cones of commissural
interneurons in the chick embryo spinal cord: a light and electron
microscopic study.
J Comp Neurol
304:78-102.
[ISI][Medline]
-
Yaginuma H,
Shiga T,
Oppenheim RW
(1994)
Early developmental
patterns and mechanisms of axonal guidance of spinal interneurons in
the chick embryo spinal cord.
Prog Neurobiol
44:249-278 .
[ISI][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. Wenner, M. J. O'Donovan, and M. P. Matise
Topographical and Physiological Characterization of Interneurons That Express Engrailed-1 in the Embryonic Chick Spinal Cord
J Neurophysiol,
November 1, 2000;
84(5):
2651 - 2657.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
J. C. Glover
Development of Specific Connectivity Between Premotor Neurons and Motoneurons in the Brain Stem and Spinal Cord
Physiol Rev,
April 1, 2000;
80(2):
615 - 647.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
M. P. Matise and A. L. Joyner
Expression Patterns of Developmental Control Genes in Normal and Engrailed-1 Mutant Mouse Spinal Cord Reveal Early Diversity in Developing Interneurons
J. Neurosci.,
October 15, 1997;
17(20):
7805 - 7816.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|
|