 |
Previous Article | Next Article 
The Journal of Neuroscience, November 1, 1998, 18(21):8770-8779
Presynaptic Induction and Expression of Homosynaptic Depression
at Aplysia Sensorimotor Neuron Synapses
Beth A.
Armitage and
Steven A.
Siegelbaum
Center for Neurobiology and Behavior, Department of Pharmacology,
Columbia University, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, New York, New
York 10032
 |
ABSTRACT |
The cellular mechanisms underlying the induction and expression of
homosynaptic depression at the glutamatergic synapse between Aplysia sensory and motor neurons were studied in
dissociated cell culture. Intracellular microelectrodes were used to
stimulate action potentials in the presynaptic sensory neuron and
record the depolarizing EPSP from the motor neuron. Homosynaptic
depression (HSD) was induced by repeatedly stimulating the sensory
neuron at rates as low as one action potential per minute. Activation of postsynaptic Glu receptors was neither sufficient nor
necessary to induce HSD. Thus, repeated applications of exogenous Glu
did not depress the synaptically evoked EPSP. Moreover, normal HSD was
observed when the sensory neuron was stimulated during a period when
the Glu receptors were blocked with the antagonist DNQX. The induction
of HSD is thus likely to occur within the presynaptic terminal. We
explored the role of presynaptic calcium in the induction of HSD by
injecting the sensory neuron with EGTA, a relatively slow calcium
chelator that does not alter rapid release but effectively buffers the
slow residual calcium transient thought to be important for plasticity.
EGTA had little effect on HSD, indicating that residual Cai
is not involved. HSD does not appear to involve a decrease in
presynaptic calcium influx, because there was no change in the
presynaptic calcium transient, measured by calcium indicator dyes,
during HSD. We conclude that HSD is induced and expressed in the
presynaptic terminal, possibly by a mechanism directly coupled to the
release process.
Key words:
synaptic transmission; synaptic plasticity; Glu
receptors; presynaptic calcium; transmitter release; learning and
memory
 |
INTRODUCTION |
Synaptic plasticity is an important
aspect of neuronal function that underlies certain forms of memory and
learning in both invertebrates and vertebrates (Hawkins et al., 1993 ).
It occurs by both heterosynaptic mechanisms in which one synaptic input modifies the efficacy of a second and by homosynaptic mechanisms that
are intrinsic to a single synapse. Homosynaptic depression (HSD), a
progressive decrease in the amplitude of the postsynaptic potential in
response to successive presynaptic stimuli, is one of the simplest
examples of synaptic plasticity. Compared with other forms of
plasticity that require trains of presynaptic action potentials, such
as long-term potentiation (Bliss and Lomo, 1973 ) and long-term
depression (Dudek and Bear, 1992 ), HSD is intriguing because even a
single presynaptic action potential is sufficient to produce a
long-lasting change in synaptic strength. This may imply that HSD
involves a mechanism that is fundamental to the transmitter release
process itself.
Although HSD has been characterized in a number of systems, its
mechanism of induction and expression are not completely understood. Here, we investigate the properties of HSD at the well characterized synapse between Aplysia mechanoreceptor sensory neurons and
their target motor neurons, in which this form of plasticity is
thought to underlie behavioral habituation (Castellucci et al., 1970 ). At this synapse, HSD is particularly robust and occurs at presynaptic firing rates as low as once every 5 min (Byrne, 1982 ).
Studies using quantal analysis at the sensorimotor neuron synapse in
the abdominal ganglion have shown that HSD is caused by a
decrease in transmitter release, with no postsynaptic change in the
quantal amplitude (Castellucci and Kandel, 1974 ; Eliot et al., 1994 ).
However, the mechanism underlying the decrease in transmitter release
has not been identified. Although a decrease in presynaptic calcium
current caused by prolonged inactivation has been suggested as a
potential mechanism (Klein et al., 1980 ), a modeling study indicated
that depletion of synaptic vesicles may also be required (Gingrich and
Byrne, 1985 ). Indeed, ultrastructural studies indicate that the number
of synaptic vesicles docked at the active zone is decreased after
multiple stimuli (Bailey and Chen, 1988 ). However, the extent of the
decrease is not large enough to account for the decrease in EPSP
amplitude.
Finally, it is not known whether HSD is induced postsynaptically,
similar to long-term potentiation and long-term depression (Bear and
Malenka, 1994 ), or whether presynaptic activity alone is sufficient. In
the simplest model, the site of induction of HSD would be presynaptic,
because the site of expression is presynaptic. However, many forms of
plasticity do not conform to such a simple scheme. For example, the
induction of posttetanic potentiation (PTP) of transmitter release at
the Aplysia sensorimotor neuron synapse has recently been
shown to require postsynaptic depolarization and calcium influx (Bao et
al., 1997 ).
To address the mechanism of expression and induction of HSD, we studied
the monosynaptic connection between a single Aplysia pleural
sensory neuron and postsynaptic L7 motor neuron in dissociated cell
culture. The transmitter at this synapse is most likely Glu (Dale and
Kandel, 1993 ; Trudeau and Castellucci, 1993 ), acting on postsynaptic
receptors similar to vertebrate NMDA receptors (Dale and Kandel, 1993 ).
Our data indicate that both the induction and the expression of HSD
involve presynaptic mechanisms. Furthermore, the depression of
transmitter release occurs downstream of calcium influx.
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
Identified Aplysia pleural sensory neurons and L7 motor
neurons were grown together in cell culture to form synapses as
described previously (Rayport and Schacher, 1986 ). Cells were grown in
a solution containing 50% Leibovitz's L-15 medium and 50% hemolymph. The L-15 medium (Sigma, St. Louis, MO) was supplemented to yield a
solution with the following final salt concentrations (in
mM): 397 NaCl, 9.9 KCl, 11.4 CaCl2, 29 MgCl2, and 29.3 MgSO4, adjusted to pH 7.6 with NaOH. During
experiments, cells were bathed in a solution containing 50% L-15 and
50% artificial seawater (ASW) (in mM): 460 NaCl, 10 KCl,
11 CaCl2, 55 MgCl2, and 10 HEPES, adjusted to pH 7.6 with NaOH).
A gravity-fed multichamber microperfusion system was used to apply most
solutions to the cells, and the reservoirs were enclosed in tin foil to
protect the solutions from light. DNQX (Sigma) was used as a 10 µM solution in L-15-ASW and was applied by
microperfusion. To ensure a rapid solution exchange necessary for fast
and thorough washout of DNQX, the total volume around the cells was
maintained at ~25 µl. The L-type calcium channel antagonist
nitrendipine (a gift from Miles Pharmaceuticals) was applied at a
concentration of 10 µM dissolved in 0.1% EtOH and
L-15-ASW and was applied by microperfusion. Serotonin (Sigma) was
prepared at a concentration of 10 µM in L-15-ASW and was
applied by microperfusion. Glu (Sigma) was dissolved to a concentration
of 10 mM in L-15-ASW and adjusted to pH 7.6. This solution
was pressure-applied through a pipette with an opening 1-5 µm in
diameter, located 10-15 µm from the site of synaptic contact, with a
Picospritzer (General Valve, Fairfield, NJ) set to deliver a 100 msec
pulse at 15 psi.
Electrical recording was performed using intracellular microelectrodes.
When substances were to be injected intracellularly, the electrodes
were pulled to have an initial resistance of 50-70 M when filled
with a 0.5 M NaCl solution and then beveled to 30-40 M .
All other electrodes were pulled to a resistance of 5-15 M and
filled with 3.0 M KCl. Recordings were made using an
Axoclamp-2A amplifier in bridge mode. Action potentials were generated
by passing 2-8 nA depolarizing current for 5 msec into the sensory
neurons. Electrical responses were recorded in analog form on tape. For
some experiments, data were also recorded in digital form directly to
the computer using the pCLAMP (version 5.5 and 6.0.2.; Axon
Instruments, Foster City, CA) acquisition program CLAMPEX. The
amplitude of the postsynaptic response was determined using CLAMPAN
(version 5.5) or CLAMPFIT (version 6.0.2).
For calcium imaging experiments, the presynaptic sensory neuron was
loaded with the free acid form of calcium Green-1 (Molecular Probes,
Eugene, OR) by iontophoresis from an intracellular microelectrode. The
microelectrode was filled with a solution containing 10 mM of the dissolved dye in 0.5 M KCl. Five hundred millisecond
hyperpolarizing current pulses (0.1-0.5 nA) applied at 1 Hz for 10-20
min were used to eject the dye. Based on the intensity of staining, we estimate the final dye concentration to be 50-100
µM.
In some experiments, cells were injected with the calcium buffer EGTA
from an electrode filled with 100 mM or 1 M
K2EGTA. Rhodamine was included in the electrode to
determine when the EGTA had diffused to the region of the presynaptic
terminals and to estimate its concentration there. This process took
20-30 min and resulted in an EGTA concentration that was 1-10% of
that included in the pipette.
Cells were viewed on a Zeiss (Oberkochen, Germany) IM-35 inverted
microscope with an Olympus Optical (Tokyo, Japan) 40×/1.30 NA oil
immersion objective. Illumination was provided by a Xenon arc lamp and
was filtered through a standard FITC filter set. Images were collected
by a Hamamatsu intensified CCD camera and stored in analog form on a
Panasonic TQ-2026F optical memory disk recorder. The storage of video
images to disk was triggered by an electronic signal synchronized with
a current pulse that stimulated action potentials in the presynaptic
sensory neuron. In this way, full frame images, temporally correlated
with presynaptic action potentials, were collected at video rates.
Image analysis was accomplished using the VIDEOPROBE program (ETM
Systems, Irvine, CA). We designated several "areas of
interest" within a cell, and then the program calculated the average
fluorescence intensity of each area in all frames. Regions were
selected based on their location (e.g., presynaptic varicosities that
contacted the primary motor neuron axon), their morphology (local
swellings that were >50% of the neurite diameter), and/or their
calcium responses (uniform increase in intensity that was >5 times the SD of the baseline). For each area of interest, the resting
intensity values from the five frames before the onset of the train
(F) were averaged, as were the intensity
values from the five frames starting at the peak value of the calcium
concentration transient (Fpeak). The relative amplitude of
the calcium transient was then approximated by the ratio
F/F = (Fpeak - F)/F. We did not correct for background
fluorescence before loading with indicator dye, because this was
negligible compared with the dye signal (<10%).
For all statistical analyses of significance, a paired Student's
t test was used. Error values and error bars reflect
SE of the mean.
 |
RESULTS |
Effects of postsynaptic activation on HSD
An initial set of experiments was aimed at elucidating the site of
induction of HSD. As shown in Figure
1A, repeated
stimulation of the presynaptic sensory neuron at a rate of one action
potential per minute induced a cumulative depression in the EPSP
recorded from the motor neuron, which reached a steady-state level
after five to seven presynaptic stimuli, which was ~30% of
the initial EPSP amplitude. To test whether postsynaptic activity alone
is sufficient to induce HSD, we gave repeated pulses (100 msec) of exogenous Glu to induce depolarizing postsynaptic responses of similar
magnitude to the synaptically generated EPSPs (Fig.
1A). To maximize the likelihood that the same
receptors activated in response to sensory neuron stimulation were also
activated by the exogenous Glu, we applied the transmitter to the
region of the motor neuron that was innervated by the sensory neuron,
as determined by imaging of presynaptic terminals. In any given motor neuron, the amplitude of the depolarization in response to exogenous Glu ranged from 0.2 to 3 times the amplitude of the EPSP evoked by
presynaptic stimulation. Unlike the evoked responses, the depolarizing responses to repetitive Glu applications at 1 min intervals showed no
significant change in average amplitude (Fig. 1B).
This suggests that either the induction and/or the expression of HSD
must have a presynaptic component.

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 1.
Glu receptor activation is not sufficient to
induce HSD. A, Effect of Glu at a representative sensory
to motor neuron synapse. A1, HSD in
response to low-frequency presynaptic stimulation. EPSPs were recorded
from a postsynaptic motor neuron in response to intracellular
stimulation of presynaptic action potentials in a sensory neuron.
Responses were elicited at 1 min intervals.
A2, The effect of exogenous Glu
application on synaptically evoked EPSP. The first trace
(bold) shows the first EPSP recorded from a motor neuron
in response to firing an action potential in the presynaptic sensory
neuron. Five brief Glu pulses (100 msec) were then applied from a
puffer pipette to elicit postsynaptic depolarizations
(thin traces) of approximately equal amplitude to
the synaptically evoked EPSP. The final trace
(bold) is a second synaptically evoked EPSP. All
responses were elicited at 1 min intervals. Calibration:
A1, 10 mV, 100 msec;
A2, 10 mV, 250 msec.
B, Summary of mean data for Glu applications. Protocol
is identical to that shown in A. For each synapse
analyzed using presynaptic stimulation, the amplitudes of the EPSPs
evoked during successive presynaptic stimuli were normalized to that of
the first EPSP (triangles,
Control). The amplitudes of depolarizing
responses to exogenous Glu were normalized to the first response to Glu
(small squares, +Glu). In the same
experiments, the EPSP evoked by presynaptic stimulation after the Glu
pulses was normalized to the first evoked EPSP before the Glu pulses
(large squares). The normalized responses were then
averaged among the different cells. Triangles,
n = 4; squares,
n = 5. Error bars indicate
SEM.
|
|
Although postsynaptic receptor activation does not depress the
response to exogenous Glu application, it is possible that it may
depress the EPSP evoked by presynaptic stimulation. To investigate this
possibility, we measured the postsynaptic response to a presynaptic
action potential before and after five repeated applications of
exogenous Glu. The amplitude of the evoked response 1 min after the
last of five Glu applications was not significantly different from the
amplitude of the first evoked response (95 ± 6 vs 100%;
n = 5; p > 0.25) (Fig.
1B). This is in sharp contrast to the result when
five presynaptic action potentials were substituted for the five
exogenous applications of Glu. In this case, a robust depression
occurred in which the amplitude of the last EPSP was significantly
different from that of the initial event (34 ± 8 vs 100%;
n = 4; p < 0.01) (Fig.
1B).
Effects of presynaptic activation on HSD
The above results show that postsynaptic Glu receptor activation
is not sufficient to induce HSD. The next question we addressed was
whether activation of the postsynaptic receptors that underlie the fast
EPSP is necessary for the induction of HSD or whether presynaptic
activity alone is sufficient. We evoked presynaptic action potentials
while the postsynaptic Glu receptors were blocked with DNQX (Fig.
2), an effective antagonist of the Glu
receptors at this synapse (Dale and Kandel, 1993 ). After the
stimulation of a presynaptic action potential to assay the initial
synaptic strength, 10 µM DNQX was applied to the cells
for 10 min. Then, in the continued presence of DNQX, the presynaptic
neuron was triggered to fire an action potential five times at 1 min
intervals. No postsynaptic responses were observed in response to these
stimuli because of the blockade of Glu receptors. To test whether the presynaptic stimuli were still able to elicit depression, even with the
postsynaptic receptors inhibited, DNQX was washed out of the bath for
10 min. The synaptic strength was retested with a second series of five
presynaptic stimuli at 1 min intervals (n = 5). The
evoked EPSP recorded after washout of DNQX was substantially depressed
compared with the first EPSP (Fig. 2). EPSPs generated in response to
subsequent presynaptic action potentials did not show any additional
depression, suggesting that the eight presynaptic stimuli in the
presence of DNQX were sufficient to elicit a steady-state level
of depression. Preliminary experiments with control cells indicated
that the five action potentials in the first stimulation series were
not always sufficient to achieve a steady state of depression.
Therefore, in most subsequent experiments, trains of eight action
potentials were used (Fig. 3).

View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2.
Effect of blockade of postsynaptic Glu receptors
on induction of HSD. EPSPs were recorded from a postsynaptic motor
neuron (top traces) in response to intracellular
stimulation of action potentials in a presynaptic sensory neuron once
per minute (bottom traces). After the first stimulus, 10 µM DNQX (filled bar) was applied by
microperfusion. After the fifth stimulus, presynaptic stimulation was
halted, and DNQX was washed out for a period of 10 min. Presynaptic
stimulation was then resumed.
|
|

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 3.
Activation of ionotropic
Glu receptors is not required for induction of HSD. Mean data shown for
induction of HSD during three experimental protocols to test the
effects of DNQX. The first protocol is similar to that shown in Figure
2 (triangles). The presynaptic cell was first stimulated
to evoke an EPSP (left point, 0 min). Cells were then
exposed to 10 µM DNQX for 10 min (bottom
bar). In the continued presence of DNQX, eight additional
presynaptic stimuli were applied at a rate of one per minute
(middle points, 11-18 min). The DNQX was then washed
from the bath for 10 min, and eight more presynaptic stimuli were
applied (right points, 28-35 min). The second protocol
was identical to the first, except that the cells were not exposed to
DNQX (squares). In the third protocol, cells were
exposed to DNQX as in the first protocol, except that the first group
of eight presynaptic stimuli during DNQX were omitted
(circles). For each cell, EPSP amplitudes were
normalized to the first EPSP, and then the normalized values in each
group were averaged. n = 5 for each protocol.
|
|
To compare the extent of depression when the presynaptic cell alone was
activated to that observed when activity occurred in both cells, a
group of control cells received an identical presynaptic stimulation
protocol but without DNQX application (Fig. 3). The amplitudes of all
EPSPs in a given cell were normalized to the initial response to allow
comparisons among cells. There was virtually no difference in the
extent of HSD between the DNQX-treated cells and the control cells, as
determined by the average normalized amplitude of the EPSPs in response
to the second series of presynaptic stimuli (n = 5).
A trivial explanation for the decreased EPSP amplitude after the
presynaptic stimuli in the presence of DNQX is that the postsynaptic receptors had not fully recovered from blockade, so that the
postsynaptic response remained partially inhibited, independent of any
HSD. To rule out this possibility, a second control experiment was performed in which a group of cells was treated identically to the
DNQX-treated cells (as above) but without the first series of
presynaptic action potentials (n = 5). For these cells,
the response to the first stimulus of the second series of action potentials showed no significant decrease as a result of the DNQX treatment when compared with the initial EPSP, demonstrating that 10 min was sufficient for complete washout of DNQX (Fig. 3). From these
experiments, we conclude that presynaptic stimulation alone is
sufficient to induce robust HSD independent of postsynaptic receptor
activation.
Induction of HSD is not mediated by residual
presynaptic Cai
Because HSD appears to be both induced and expressed
presynaptically, we next investigated the potential role that
presynaptic Ca influx plays in the induction of HSD, given the
important role of Cai in other forms of synaptic
plasticity. Because a rise in Cai triggers transmitter
release, it was necessary to dissociate any slow modulatory effect of
increased Cai that may underlie HSD from the rapid
transient Cai increase that mediates transmitter release.
To accomplish this, we injected the slow calcium buffer EGTA into the
presynaptic cell. At the squid giant synapse, EGTA has been shown to be
relatively ineffective in altering fast transmitter release, presumably
because the kinetics of Ca binding to the buffer are too slow to affect
the large rapid Cai transient near the membrane (Smith et
al., 1984 ; Adler et al., 1991 ). In contrast, EGTA does serve as an
effective buffer for slow changes in Cai that occur on the
time scale of milliseconds to minutes, blocking some forms of synaptic
plasticity without altering release per se (Swandulla et al., 1991 ;
Regehr et al., 1994 ).
We used two different concentrations of EGTA in the microelectrodes,
100 and 1 M, which should result in 1-10 or 10-100
mM concentrations of EGTA, respectively, at the axon
terminals. This estimate was based on a comparison of rhodamine
fluorescence in the electrodes and terminals. Rhodamine has a similar
size (577 MW) to EGTA (380 MW), distributes uniformly throughout the
cytoplasm, and has a fluorescence intensity sufficient to allow rapid
measurement at low light levels, thereby minimizing photodamage.
Experimental support that EGTA actually reached the synaptic terminals
at sufficient concentrations to buffer calcium effectively was provided
by the observation that EGTA injection inhibited synaptic transmission.
Thus, when the synapse was tested once before loading with EGTA and
then stimulated 30 min later, the EPSP was decreased to 80 and 36% of
its initial amplitude with electrodes containing 100 and 1 M EGTA, respectively. The 30 min interval between
preloading and postloading stimuli is too long to produce any
significant HSD. Thus, the decrease in synaptic strength most likely
reflects altered Cai buffering by EGTA. Apparently, fast
release at the Aplysia sensorimotor neuron synapse is more sensitive to EGTA than the squid giant synapse.
Despite the decrease in synaptic transmission, marked HSD persisted in
response to a series of presynaptic action potentials in experiments
using electrodes containing either 100 or 1 M EGTA. The
magnitude and time course of the HSD was not substantially different
from the HSD under control conditions. After eight presynaptic stimuli,
the EPSP was decreased on average to 43% of its initial amplitude in
control cells (n = 3), to 40% of its initial amplitude in cells injected with 100 mM EGTA (n = 2),
and to 51% of its initial amplitude in a cell injected with 1 M EGTA (n = 1) (Fig. 4). Thus, HSD does not appear to depend
on a residual increase in Cai (although we cannot rule out
the possibility that there was some residual Cai transient
that was not altered by the EGTA).

View larger version (12K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 4.
Presynaptic injection of EGTA does not inhibit
induction of HSD. Peak EPSP amplitudes from four motor neurons are
plotted in response to successive stimulation of the sensory neurons.
EPSP amplitudes are normalized to that of the first EPSP. In two cells,
the presynaptic microelectrode contained 100 mM EGTA
(diamonds), and in a third cell, the microelectrode
contained 1 M EGTA (triangles). In a control
cell, the presynaptic electrode did not contain EGTA
(squares). The presynaptic cell was stimulated at 20 sec
intervals. Before these measurements were obtained, solution was
ejected from the presynaptic electrode using 500 msec pressure
pulses.
|
|
HSD is not associated with altered calcium transients in
presynaptic terminals
We next investigated the expression of HSD by testing the
hypothesis that the decrease in transmitter release is a result of
inhibition of voltage-dependent calcium influx (Klein et al., 1980 ).
The presynaptic neuron was filled with the fluorescent calcium
indicator dye calcium Green-1 and imaged during a series of action
potentials used to evoke release and elicit HSD. These experiments were
performed in the presence of 10 µM nitrendipine to block
the dihydropyridine-sensitive Ca channels present in the presynaptic
terminals. This was necessary to ensure that we selectively measured Ca
influx through the dihydropyridine-insensitive Ca channels, the type
that mediate transmitter release at this synapse (Edmonds et al.,
1990 ).
Two possible mechanisms for HSD that depend on changes in Ca influx
were investigated. The first involves a progressive decrease in calcium
influx into presynaptic terminals in response to successive stimuli. To
address this possibility, we evaluated the Cai signals in
presynaptic varicosities, local swellings of the thin axonal branches
of the sensory neuron that have been shown to contain active zones
(Glanzman et al., 1989 ), during the induction of HSD. Figure
5 shows that the Cai
transient recorded in a single varicosity elicited by six successive
action potentials delivered at 20 sec intervals did not decrease,
despite a marked HSD.

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 5.
Ca influx in a single presynaptic varicosity does
not change during induction of HSD. Cai transients, plotted
as F/F, were imaged from a single
presynaptic varicosity in response to stimulation of six presynaptic
action potentials at 20 sec intervals. The peak EPSP amplitude recorded
from the postsynaptic motor neuron in response to the same presynaptic
stimulus is given below each calcium transient. Time is
shown in 1 sec intervals.
|
|
We obtained images of Cai using the
F/F ratio at the peak of the Cai
transient during each of the six action potentials. Although the
Cai image obtained during a single action potential was
somewhat noisy, we could clearly resolve localized increases in
Cai. Comparison of Cai images during the first
and sixth action potential showed no marked differences (Fig.
6).

View larger version (K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 6.
Spatial distribution of Cai influx
does not change during HSD. Pseudocolor images of the peak calcium
response ( F/F) in a presynaptic
sensory neuron elicited by a single action potential.
Red indicates high calcium concentration;
blue indicates low calcium concentration.
A shows the Cai response to the first
stimulus, that in B to the sixth stimulus, during a
series of six action potentials, elicited at 20 sec intervals.
|
|
The presynaptic Cai transient was measured in a total of 38 varicosities from nine sensory cells while the EPSP was simultaneously recorded from the postsynaptic motor neuron. Whereas the EPSP produced
in the motor neuron elicited by successive action potentials during the
train showed a progressive depression, there was virtually no change in
the mean size of the Cai transient elicited by successive action potentials (Fig. 7). The average
amplitude of the calcium transient in response to the sixth stimulus
was 107 ± 6% (n = 38) of the Cai
transient amplitude in response to the first stimulus (100%;
p > 0.1). In contrast, the average EPSP in these same
cells in response to the sixth stimulus decreased to 37 ± 4%
(n = 9) of its size relative to the first stimulus
(100%; p < 0.0005). Therefore, despite the
substantial decrease in transmitter release during HSD, there is no
change in calcium influx in the presynaptic boutons.

View larger version (9K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 7.
Mean data for Cai transient amplitude
during HSD. The mean peak amplitude of the presynaptic Cai
transient ( F/F;
circles) and the associated mean peak EPSP amplitude
(squares) are plotted during successive presynaptic
stimuli. A presynaptic action potential was elicited once every 20 sec.
The average calcium transient in response to a given stimulus was
calculated by first measuring the calcium transient in four to five
individual varicosities per experiment. For each varicosity, the
amplitude of the transient was then normalized to that of the first
stimulus. These normalized values were then averaged for all the
varicosities (n = 38) from all cells
(n = 9). For each postsynaptic cell, the EPSP
amplitudes were normalized to that of the first EPSP, and then the
normalized values from all cells (n = 9) were
averaged. Error bars indicate SEM.
|
|
Although we observed no change in the average Cai transient
in these experiments, we considered a second possible mechanism for HSD
that involves a decrease in Ca influx that could be obscured by this
averaging. Thus, if HSD were caused by a failure of the action
potential to invade a subset of presynaptic boutons, the Cai transient averaged among all boutons might not change
dramatically (for example, if the Cai transient were to
increase in boutons that remained excitable). To investigate this
possibility, we followed the behavior of a large number of individual
varicosities in response to the six action potentials triggered at 20 sec intervals (Fig. 8). Among
varicosities that showed a Cai transient in response to the
first action potential, there was never an instance in which a
subsequent action potential failed to elicit a measurable change in
calcium concentration. In only 3 of 38 varicosities did the transient
fall below 50% of its initial value (Fig. 8). In addition, in sites in
which there was a decrease in calcium transient amplitude, there were
only two instances in which this decrease was maintained throughout the
train of action potentials (subsequent responses being equal to or less
than previous responses). In all the other cases, the amplitude of the
Cai transient fluctuated up and down during the action
potential train. Therefore, the number of presynaptic boutons
responding to an action potential remained relatively constant and
cannot explain the accompanying decrease in transmitter release caused
by HSD.

View larger version (107K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 8.
Multiple stimuli activate a constant number of
varicosities. Calcium responses in individual varicosities from
presynaptic sensory neurons were measured in response to successive
action potentials used to induce HSD (n = 38). For
each varicosity, the amplitude of the calcium transient in response to
each successive action potential,
F(i)/F, was normalized to that of the
first action potential, F(1)/F,
yielding the ratio f(i)/f(1). Normalized
Cai transients during six successive action potentials are
plotted as a function of action potential number
(i). Each varicosity is represented by a separate
line. Action potentials were stimulated once every 20 sec.
|
|
 |
DISCUSSION |
The induction of HSD is presynaptic
The above results suggest that the induction of HSD is
presynaptic. Thus, when the postsynaptic cell was stimulated by
exogenous Glu, no depression resulted. A trivial explanation for this
failure to induce HSD is that Glu is not the endogenous transmitter.
Although definitive proof is lacking, two lines of evidence support Glu as the sensory neuron transmitter (Dale and Kandel, 1993 ; Trudeau and
Castellucci, 1993 ). First, the biophysical properties of the postsynaptic response to the native transmitter closely resemble the
response to exogenous Glu (Dale and Kandel, 1993 ). Both show a reversal
potential close to 0 mV, and both display a flattened I-V
curve at negative voltages in the presence of external Mg. After Mg
removal, the I-V curve becomes linear. Second, some
of the known Glu receptor antagonists, including CNQX and DNQX, block the responses to endogenous transmitter and to exogenously applied Glu
to similar extents. Therefore, it is likely that even if Glu is not the
endogenous transmitter, it induces a postsynaptic response that very
closely mimics the endogenous response. A second explanation for the
failure of exogenous Glu to induce HSD is that the agonist activated
extrasynaptic receptors but failed to activate synaptic receptors,
which mediate HSD. However, cross-desensitization experiments show that
exogenous Glu can primarily block the EPSP elicited by presynaptic
stimulation, indicative of an efficient activation of synaptic
receptors by the exogenous Glu (S. Schacher, personal communication).
As a second approach to investigate the site of induction of HSD, we
stimulated the presynaptic cell in the presence of DNQX to block the
postsynaptic response. Under these conditions, the synapse became
depressed to the same extent to that which occurred with stimulation in
the absence of DNQX. Although the simplest interpretation of the above
two results is that the induction of HSD is presynaptic, there are two
schemes consistent with a role for the postsynaptic cell. In the first
scheme, induction of HSD would result from the co-release of a
substance with Glu from presynaptic terminals. This would explain why
Glu application did not induce HSD and why depression occurred in the
presence of Glu receptor antagonists. One candidate cotransmitter is
the sensory neuron peptide sensorin (Brunet et al., 1991 ), which may be
present in small clear synaptic vesicles, as indicated by staining of
varicosities with indirect immunocytochemistry (Santarelli et al.,
1996 ). Application of exogenous sensorin elicits a hyperpolarizing response in certain postsynaptic cells (Brunet et al., 1991 ), although
the physiological role of this peptide is currently unknown. Because
DNQX completely inhibits the EPSP (Fig. 2), such substances probably do
not directly gate postsynaptic ion channels. However, they could act
through a modulatory second messenger-dependent postsynaptic action. In
the second scheme, activation of DNQX-insensitive postsynaptic
metabotropic Glu receptors would be necessary, but not sufficient, to
induce HSD. For example, combined presynaptic activity and postsynaptic
metabotropic Glu receptor stimulation may be required. Although we
cannot rule out the above two hypotheses, we have not found any
evidence for a slow modulatory component to the postsynaptic response
in the presence of DNQX, as might be expected. Given the presynaptic
site of expression of HSD, we favor the simple view that its induction
is also presynaptic.
Residual calcium is not the induction event
There are three principal components of presynaptic activity that
could induce HSD: (1) calcium influx, (2) transmitter release acting on
presynaptic receptors, and (3) vesicle fusion.
The calcium influx during an action potential could trigger a second
messenger pathway that modulates transmitter release. When calcium
first enters the cell, it exists momentarily within domains of high
concentration localized just under the membrane, which are required to
trigger exocytosis of synaptic vesicles. The calcium then rapidly
diffuses down its steep concentration gradient to the surrounding
cytoplasm, producing a relatively small longer-lasting elevation in
Cai concentration. This residual Cai has been
implicated in other forms of synaptic plasticity, most notably PTP
(Swandulla et al., 1991 ; Regehr et al., 1994 ; Fischer et al., 1997 ). In
imaging experiments of the sensory neurons, the decay of the residual
Cai transient had a time constant of ~2 sec (Fig. 5). To
test the role of this residual Cai transient, the calcium
buffer EGTA was injected into the presynaptic cell. The failure of EGTA
to inhibit HSD is probably not attributable to a lack of effect on
calcium buffering, because the EGTA injections diminished evoked
release, which is relatively resistant to EGTA, in a dose-dependent
manner. Thus, HSD is not likely to depend on the slow residual
Cai transient, although HSD might be mediated by the more
rapid Cai transient.
A second possible mechanism for HSD depends on a presynaptic feedback
mechanism in which one or more transmitters act on presynaptic receptors to induce HSD. Activation of presynaptic Glu receptors alone
is not sufficient to induce HSD, because application of exogenous Glu
to the synaptic region did not change the synaptic strength. However,
induction may require simultaneous receptor binding and presynaptic
activity and/or binding of a cotransmitter (e.g., sensorin) to its
presynaptic receptor.
The third possibility is that induction of HSD could result from the
fusion event itself and not directly depend on an effect of any
substances that are released. It is now known that there are numerous
proteins on the vesicle surface, on the plasma membrane, and in the
cytoplasm, which interact to regulate vesicle fusion (Sudhof, 1995 ). It
is possible that the fusion event itself alters one or more of these
proteins such that the probability of fusion occurring in response to
the next stimulus is decreased. Such an alteration could involve a
conformational change that occurs as a result of calcium binding or
protein-protein interactions, or it could be a posttranslational
modification, such as phosphorylation. Investigation of such hypotheses
will await a more complete understanding of the process of fusion
itself.
The expression of HSD is not caused by decreased
calcium influx
Quantal analysis demonstrated that the expression of HSD is
presynaptic (Castellucci and Kandel, 1974 ), involving either a decrease
in the number of vesicles available for release, a decrease in the
probability of release, and/or a decrease in the number of functional
release sites. Two previous studies addressed the depletion hypothesis.
In the first, EM images of synaptic terminals were obtained after a
long series of stimuli (Bailey and Chen, 1988 ). It was found that
although the total number of vesicles was unchanged, there was a
decrease in those vesicles directly apposed to the membrane. However,
this decrease was not large enough to account for the decrease in
postsynaptic response measured in the same synapses. The second study
used spontaneous release as an indication of available vesicles (Eliot,
1991 ; Eliot et al., 1994 ). Although a high-frequency train was capable
of transiently decreasing the frequency of spontaneous miniature EPSPs,
(indicating that depletion may have occurred), there was no prolonged
decrease in spontaneous release rate associated with HSD. Therefore,
although depletion of the pool of available vesicles may account, in
part, for a decrease in transmitter release under certain
circumstances, HSD is likely to involve also a decrease in the
probability of release and/or a change in the number of functional
release sites. The fact that presynaptic EGTA injections did not alter
the time course or extent of HSD despite a decrease in the absolute
magnitude of the EPSP (see Fig. 4) also argues against a primary role
of vesicle depletion.
One potential mechanism for the depression of Ca-evoked transmitter
release is via a decrease of Ca influx associated with a
presynaptic action potential. It has been shown that the voltage-gated calcium current measured in the sensory cell body undergoes a use-dependent decrease caused by cumulative inactivation during trains
of action potentials that induce HSD (Klein et al., 1980 ). Although
this decrease in Ca current is a prime candidate for contributing to
HSD, it has been argued that the magnitude of the expected decrease in
Ca influx is too small to account quantitatively for the change in EPSP
amplitude (Gingrich and Byrne, 1985 ). One problem with such conclusions
is that they are based on calcium current measurements in the cell
body, which may differ from the behavior of the calcium current in the
presynaptic terminal that triggers release.
Using fluorescence microscopy, we directly measured the calcium
transient in response to single presynaptic action potentials in
regions of the presynaptic cell that are likely to correspond to the
presynaptic terminals (Glanzman et al., 1989 ). These studies were
performed in the presence of nitrendipine, which allowed us to
selectively measure Ca influx via the
dihydropyridine-insensitive Ca channels: the type that mediates
release from the sensory neurons (Edmonds et al., 1990 ; Eliot et al.,
1993 ). During stimulation protocols that produced marked HSD, we found
no change in either the average peak amplitude of the Cai
transient or in the number of terminals that were activated by
successive stimuli, as judged by the presence of a Cai
transient. The criteria used for identifying a presynaptic terminal,
presynaptic axonal varicosities in contact with the postsynaptic cell
(Glanzman et al., 1989 ), were not definitive and therefore some release
sites may have been missed, whereas other regions may have been
incorrectly identified as release sites. However, it is unlikely that
this bias led to the selective exclusion of those sites that were
altered in response to repetitive stimulation. Thus, we conclude that
the decrease in release occurs at some step downstream of Ca
influx.
Our results thus indicate that both the induction and expression of HSD
may be an integral part of the release process itself. With an
expanding knowledge of the fusion process and of the molecular components of the release apparatus, it may soon be possible to test
the role of specific presynaptic proteins. In particular, future
studies of genetically modified animals offer the promise of
identifying specific proteins involved in homosynaptic depression.
 |
FOOTNOTES |
Received March 20, 1998; revised Aug. 10, 1998; accepted Aug. 10, 1998.
This work was partly supported by National Institute of Mental Health
Grant P50-MH50733. We thank Huan Yao for expert technical assistance in
preparing the Aplysia cultures and Eric Kandel and Bob Hawkins for
critical reading of this manuscript.
Correspondence should be addressed to Steven A. Siegelbaum, Center for
Neurobiology and Behavior, Columbia University, 722 W. 168 Street, New
York, NY 10032.
 |
REFERENCES |
-
Adler EM,
Augustine GJ,
Duffy SN,
Charlton MP
(1991)
Alien intracellular calcium chelators attenuate neurotransmitter release at the squid giant synapse.
J Neurosci
11:1496-1507[Abstract].
-
Bailey CH,
Chen M
(1988)
Morphological basis of short-term habituation in Aplysia.
J Neurosci
8:2452-2459[Abstract].
-
Bao JX,
Kandel ER,
Hawkins RD
(1997)
Involvement of pre- and postsynaptic mechanisms in posttetanic potentiation at Aplysia synapses.
Science
275:969-973[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Bear MF,
Malenka RC
(1994)
Synaptic plasticity: LTP and LTD.
Curr Opin Neurobiol
3:389-399.
-
Bliss TV,
Lomo T
(1973)
Long-lasting potentiation of synaptic transmission in the dentate area of the anaesthetized rabbit following stimulation of the perforant path.
J Physiol (Lond)
232:331-356[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Brunet JF,
Shapiro E,
Foster SA,
Kandel ER,
Iino Y
(1991)
Identification of a peptide specific for Aplysia sensory neurons by PCR-based differential screening.
Science
252:856-859[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Byrne JH
(1982)
Analysis of synaptic depression contributing to habituation of gill-withdrawal reflex in Aplysia californica.
J Neurophysiol
48:431-438[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Castellucci V,
Pinsker H,
Kupfermann I,
Kandel ER
(1970)
Neuronal mechanisms of habituation and dishabituation of the gill-withdrawal reflex in Aplysia.
Science
167:1745-1748[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Castellucci VF,
Kandel ER
(1974)
A quantal analysis of the synaptic depression underlying habituation of the gill-withdrawal reflex in Aplysia.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
71:5004-5008[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Dale N,
Kandel ER
(1993)
L-Glutamate may be the fast excitatory transmitter of Aplysia sensory neurons.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
90:7163-7167[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Dudek SM,
Bear MF
(1992)
Homosynaptic long-term depression in area CA1 of hippocampus and effects of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor blockade.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
89:4363-4367[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Edmonds B,
Klein M,
Dale N,
Kandel ER
(1990)
Contributions of two types of calcium channels to synaptic transmission and plasticity.
Science
250:1142-1147[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Eliot LS (1991) Presynaptic modulation of Aplysia
sensory-to-motor neuron synapses in culture. PhD thesis, Columbia
University.
-
Eliot LS,
Kandel ER,
Siegelbaum SA,
Blumenfeld H
(1993)
Imaging terminals of Aplysia sensory neurons demonstrates role of enhanced Ca2+ influx in presynaptic facilitation.
Nature
361:634-637[Medline].
-
Eliot LS,
Kandel ER,
Hawkins RD
(1994)
Modulation of spontaneous transmitter release during depression and posttetanic potentiation of Aplysia sensory-motor neuron synapses isolated in culture.
J Neurosci
14:3280-3292[Abstract].
-
Fischer TM,
Zucker RS,
Carew TJ
(1997)
Activity-dependent potentiation of synaptic transmission from L30 inhibitory interneurons of Aplysia depends on residual presynaptic Ca2+ but not on postsynaptic Ca2+.
J Neurophysiol
78:2061-2071[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Gingrich KJ,
Byrne JH
(1985)
Simulation of synaptic depression, posttetanic potentiation, and presynaptic facilitation of synaptic potentials from sensory neurons mediating gill-withdrawal reflex in Aplysia.
J Neurophysiol
53:652-669[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Glanzman DL,
Kandel ER,
Schacher S
(1989)
Identified target motor neuron regulates neurite outgrowth and synapse formation of Aplysia sensory neurons in vitro.
Neuron
3:441-450[ISI][Medline].
-
Hawkins RD,
Kandel ER,
Siegelbaum SA
(1993)
Learning to modulate transmitter release: themes and variations in synaptic plasticity.
Annu Rev Neurosci
16:625-665[ISI][Medline].
-
Klein M,
Shapiro E,
Kandel ER
(1980)
Synaptic plasticity and the modulation of the Ca2+ current.
J Exp Biol
89:117-157[Free Full Text].
-
Rayport SG,
Schacher S
(1986)
Synaptic plasticity in vitro: cell culture of identified. Aplysia neurons mediating short-term habituation and sensitization.
J Neurosci
6:759-763[Abstract].
-
Regehr WG,
Delaney KR,
Tank DW
(1994)
The role of presynaptic calcium in short-term enhancement at the hippocampal mossy fiber synapse.
J Neurosci
14:523-537[Abstract].
-
Santarelli L,
Montarolo P,
Schacher S
(1996)
Neuropeptide localization in varicosities of Aplysia sensory neurons is regulated by target and neuromodulators evoking long-term synaptic plasticity.
J Neurobiol
31:297-308[ISI][Medline].
-
Smith PD,
Liesegang GW,
Berger RL,
Czerlinski KG,
Pjoldolsky RJ
(1984)
A stopped-flow investigation of calcium ion binding by ethylene glycol bis(beta-aminoethyl ether)-N,N'-tetraacetic acid.
Anal Biochem
143:188-195[ISI][Medline].
-
Sudhof TC
(1995)
The synaptic vesicle cycle: a cascade of protein-protein interactions.
Nature
375:645-653[Medline].
-
Swandulla D,
Hans M,
Zipser K,
Augustine GJ
(1991)
Role of residual calcium in synaptic depression and posttetanic potentiation: fast and slow calcium signaling in nerve terminals.
Neuron
7:915-926[ISI][Medline].
-
Trudeau LE,
Castellucci VF
(1993)
Excitatory amino acid neurotransmission at sensory-motor and interneuronal synapses of Aplysia californica.
J Neurophysiol
70:1221-1230[Abstract/Free Full Text].
Copyright © 1998 Society for Neuroscience 0270-6474/98/18218770-10$05.00/0
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
D. Fioravante, R.-Y. Liu, A. K. Netek, L. J. Cleary, and J. H. Byrne
Synapsin Regulates Basal Synaptic Strength, Synaptic Depression, and Serotonin-Induced Facilitation of Sensorimotor Synapses in Aplysia
J Neurophysiol,
December 1, 2007;
98(6):
3568 - 3580.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
G. Houeland, A. Nakhost, W. S. Sossin, and V. F. Castellucci
PKC Modulation of Transmitter Release by SNAP-25 at Sensory-to-Motor Synapses in Aplysia
J Neurophysiol,
January 1, 2007;
97(1):
134 - 143.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. Lovell and L. L. Moroz
The largest growth cones in the animal kingdom: an illustrated guide to the dynamics of Aplysia neuronal growth in cell culture
Integr. Comp. Biol.,
December 1, 2006;
46(6):
847 - 870.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
Y.-J. Sung, F. Wu, S. Schacher, and R. T. Ambron
Synaptogenesis regulates axotomy-induced activation of c-Jun-activator protein-1 transcription.
J. Neurosci.,
June 14, 2006;
26(24):
6439 - 6449.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
D. L. Glanzman
The Cellular Mechanisms of Learning in Aplysia: Of Blind Men and Elephants
Biol. Bull.,
June 1, 2006;
210(3):
271 - 279.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
Y. Wu, F. Kawasaki, and R. W. Ordway
Properties of Short-Term Synaptic Depression at Larval Neuromuscular Synapses in Wild-Type and Temperature-Sensitive Paralytic Mutants of Drosophila
J Neurophysiol,
May 1, 2005;
93(5):
2396 - 2405.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
O. Khabour, J. Levenson, L. C. Lyons, L. S. Kategaya, J. Chin, J. H. Byrne, and A. Eskin
Coregulation of Glutamate Uptake and Long-Term Sensitization in Aplysia
J. Neurosci.,
October 6, 2004;
24(40):
8829 - 8837.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
Y. Ezzeddine and D. L. Glanzman
Prolonged Habituation of the Gill-Withdrawal Reflex in Aplysia Depends on Protein Synthesis, Protein Phosphatase Activity, and Postsynaptic Glutamate Receptors
J. Neurosci.,
October 22, 2003;
23(29):
9585 - 9594.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
J. K. Rose, K. R. Kaun, S. H. Chen, and C. H. Rankin
GLR-1, a Non-NMDA Glutamate Receptor Homolog, Is Critical for Long-Term Memory in Caenorhabditis elegans
J. Neurosci.,
October 22, 2003;
23(29):
9595 - 9599.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
E. G. Antzoulatos, L. J. Cleary, A. Eskin, D. A. Baxter, and J. H. Byrne
Desensitization of Postsynaptic Glutamate Receptors Contributes to High-Frequency Homosynaptic Depression of Aplysia Sensorimotor Connections
Learn. Mem.,
September 1, 2003;
10(5):
309 - 313.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
Y. Zhao and M. Klein
Modulation of the Readily Releasable Pool of Transmitter and of Excitation-Secretion Coupling by Activity and by Serotonin at Aplysia Sensorimotor Synapses in Culture
J. Neurosci.,
December 15, 2002;
22(24):
10671 - 10679.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
T. D. Gover, X.-Y. Jiang, and T. W. Abrams
Persistent, Exocytosis-Independent Silencing of Release Sites Underlies Homosynaptic Depression at Sensory Synapses in Aplysia
J. Neurosci.,
March 1, 2002;
22(5):
1942 - 1955.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
A. S. Bristol, T. M. Fischer, and T. J. Carew
Combined Effects of Intrinsic Facilitation and Modulatory Inhibition of Identified Interneurons in the Siphon Withdrawal Circuitry of Aplysia
J. Neurosci.,
November 15, 2001;
21(22):
8990 - 9000.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|
|