Previous Article | Next Article 
The Journal of Neuroscience, October 15, 2001, 21(20):8129-8135
Primordial Rhythmic Bursting in Embryonic Cochlear Ganglion
Cells
Timothy A.
Jones,
Sherri M.
Jones, and
Kristina C.
Paggett
Department of Surgery, Division of Otolaryngology, University of
Missouri School of Medicine, Columbia, Missouri 65212
 |
ABSTRACT |
This study examined the nature of spontaneous discharge patterns in
cochlear ganglion cells in embryonic day 13 (E13) to early E17 chicken
embryos (stages 39-43). Neural recordings were made with glass
micropipettes. No sound-driven activity was seen for the youngest
embryos (maximum intensity 107 dB sound pressure level). Ganglion cells
were labeled with biotinylated dextran amine in four embryos. In two
animals, primary afferents projected to hair cells in the middle region
along the length of the basilar papilla in which, in one cell, the
terminals occupied a neural transverse position and, in the other, a
more abneural location. Statoacoustic ganglion cells showing no
spontaneous activity were seen for the first time in the chicken. The
proportion of "silent" cells was largest at the youngest stages
(stage 39, 67%). In active cells, mean spontaneous discharge rates
[9.4 ± 10.4 spikes (Sp)/sec; n = 44] were
lower than rates for older embryos (19 ± 17 Sp/sec) (Jones and
Jones, 2000
). Embryos at stages 39-41 evidenced even lower rates
(4.2 ± 5.0 Sp/sec). The most salient feature of spontaneous activity for stages 39-43 was a bursting discharge pattern in >75%
of active neurons (33 of 44). Moreover, in 55% of these cells, there
was a clear, slow, rhythmic bursting pattern. The proportion of cells
showing rhythmic bursting was greatest at the youngest stages (39-42)
and decreased to <30% at stage 43. Rate of bursting ranged from 1 to
54 bursts per minute. The presence of rhythmic bursting in cochlear
ganglion cells at E13-E17 provides an explanation for the existence of
such patterns in central auditory relays. The bursting patterns may
serve as a patterning signal for central synaptic refinements in the
auditory system during development.
Key words:
functional ontogeny; bird; spontaneous activity; embryonic development; primary afferents; chicken; audition; hearing
 |
INTRODUCTION |
Spontaneous rhythmic bursting of
retinal ganglion cells may provide a critical signal for refinements in
developing central binocular processing circuits. Indeed, modifications
of retinal spontaneous afferent discharge patterns can result in
altered synaptic configurations in thalamic and cortical relays (Galli and Maffei, 1988
; Constantine-Paton et al., 1990
; Shatz, 1990
, 1996
;
Meister et al., 1991
; Wong et al., 1993
, 1995
; Mooney et al., 1996
;
Masland, 1997
).
Could development of binaural processing circuits require a patterned
activity similar to rhythmic retinal activity? Unfortunately, little is
known about spontaneous activity derived from the embryonic or neonatal
cochlea. There are a few descriptions of spontaneous discharge patterns
in developing central and peripheral auditory circuits. Low spontaneous
discharge rates were described in the neonatal pigeon (Richter et al.,
1996
) and cat (Romand, 1984
), but bursting patterns were not reported.
Jones and Jones (2000)
recorded single unit activity for primary
afferents of the statoacoustic ganglion in chicken embryos at 19 d
of incubation [embryonic day 19 (E19)]. These investigators
demonstrated lower overall discharge rates for auditory and nonauditory
primary afferents in the embryo as well as longer modes and dead time.
Irregular bursting patterns were observed in ~30% of embryonic
neurons. However, no rhythmic bursting patterns were found except those
occasionally driven by the heartbeat. Lippe (1994
, 1995
) characterized
patterns of central multiunit activity in the region of brainstem relay
nuclei in chicken embryos at ages between 14 and 19 d of
incubation (E14 and E19). In addition to low overall discharge rates,
Lippe described regular bursting patterns reminiscent of early bursting
patterns that were reported for other sensory modalities, especially
the visual system. Furthermore, he described the disappearance of central bursting patterns when cochlear input was eliminated, suggesting that central bursting depended in some way on primary afferents. Gummer and Mark (1994)
also described "patterned neural activity" in brainstem auditory centers of the wallaby neonate. Although suggestive, observations to date provide no definitive evidence for a dominant regular bursting pattern in developing primary
afferents of the cochlea. The present study examined activity patterns
of cochlear ganglion cells at ages younger than E19.
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
Methods for in vivo recordings of the statoacoustic
ganglion in chicken embryos have been published elsewhere (Jones and
Jones, 1995a
,b
, 2000
). Briefly, embryos (Gallus domesticus)
were incubated in commercial incubators at 37.5°C (65% humidity) and
were retrieved from incubators after 15-18 d. Animals were
anesthetized with EquiThesin/saline (1:5; 0.1 ml). EquiThesin was
administered subcutaneously at the neck, along with 1 mg of gallamine
triethiodide. Needle electrodes were used to monitor the
electrocardiogram. The head was secured to a custom platform, and the
scala tympani was exposed using a posterolateral approach. Brain
temperature was monitored and maintained on average at 37.4 ± 1.4°C. Egg temperature was also monitored and ranged between 38 and
40°C.
Beak and toe lengths were measured and used to determine the
developmental stage of each animal. Ages are reported as stages or
corresponding days of incubation as outlined by Hamburger and Hamilton
(1951)
. Stages of development reported herein encompassed 39-43
(E13-E17). The University of Missouri Institutional Animal Care and
Use Committee approved the care and use of the animals described in
this report. Table 1 provides a summary
of developmental stages and equivalent incubation days.
Beveled glass micropipettes, filled with 10% biotinylated dextran
amine (BDA; 3000 molecular weight; Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR) in 0.5 M KCl and 0.05 M Tris, were lowered into scala
tympani in 0.5 µm steps with the tip directed toward the ganglion.
Silver chloride wire electrodes were used for the reference (neck) and ground (extraembryonic fluid). Electrode impedance ranged from 5 to 15 M
and was measured in situ using an electrometer (WPI 767-B; World Precision Instruments, Sarasota, FL).
Electrophysiological activity was amplified (gains ranged from 50 to
500×), filtered (bandpass 100-3000 Hz, or 100-10,000 Hz,
6 dB
points), and recorded on videotape (Vetter 420G). Signals were also
amplified and led to a speaker so that the activity of neurons was
audible. Detailed analysis of spontaneous activity was accomplished
off-line. Activity was digitized (40 or 50 µsec/point) and saved on
diskette. Then, the recording was systematically analyzed to determine
the onset time of each spike occurrence. A voltage threshold criterion
was used to detect spikes initially, and each spike detected was
displayed at high resolution and visually confirmed on screen (Fig.
1). In Figure 1, records from two neurons illustrate the range of signal-to-noise ratios found typically in the
present study.

View larger version (24K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 1.
The primary digitized records (40 µsec per
point) of two neural spike trains are shown here. The records
illustrate the range of signal-to-noise ratios encountered in this
study. The process of expanding traces for high resolution computerized
analysis is shown for neuron 88tm01. Spike detection was accomplished
using an initial voltage threshold criterion. Records were divided into
contiguous data blocks in which for each block, the voltage threshold
could be adjusted to accommodate fluctuations in baseline. The entire
record was examined on screen at high resolution for falsely detected
spikes and for failed detection of spikes. Each action potential was
individually confirmed.
|
|
Fluid was wicked out of the middle ear, and sound stimuli were
delivered using an ER-2 earphone that was sealed at the external auditory meatus. Clicks (0.1 msec; 1.0 V square wave pulses), pure
tones (1.0 V peak to peak; 100-4000 Hz), and pure-tone or noise bursts
(50 msec duration; 5 msec rise-fall times; 50% duty cycle) were used
as stimuli to determine whether individual cells responded to sound.
All stimuli were routed through an attenuator (Med Associates, St.
Albans, Vermont), amplifier (Med Associates), and equalizer (Pioneer,
Long Beach, CA) before output at the earphone. Maximum stimulus
intensity at the output of the earphone was 107 dB sound pressure level
(SPL) (or dB peak equivalent SPL for clicks across the frequencies tested).
Once single primary afferents were isolated, up to 4 min of continuous
spontaneous activity was recorded on analog tape and analyzed off-line.
If the neuron could be sound activated, an estimate of best frequency
was obtained audiovisually (Jones and Jones, 1995a
,b
) using manually
swept pure tones (100-4000 Hz) that were produced by a sine wave
generator (Wavetek, Everett, WA). The tone frequencies producing the
largest audible response were noted and recorded as an estimate of best
frequency. It was possible in some cases to estimate the sound
threshold at best frequency. To do this, stimulus frequency was swept
across the best frequency (from above and below) while the sound level
of the stimulus was adjusted to determine the lowest sound level producing an audible increase in firing.
We use the expression "rhythmic bursting" here to describe
recurring periodic and generally sudden increases in neural discharge rate. When present, bursts of activity are heralded by a flurry of
spikes (at least two in number, but usually many more) separated by
relatively long silent periods that reoccur at somewhat regular intervals. The striking character of ideal regular bursting is easily
recognized. However, in the case of less than ideal rhythmic bursting
patterns or less prevalent long silent periods, (as is the case in late
embryonic periods) it becomes harder to characterize the regularity and
hence the rate of bursting. We addressed this issue in the present
study by evaluating spike trains using autocorrelation and the fast
Fourier transform (FFT). As described in earlier work (Jones and Jones,
2000
), probability density functions (autocorrelation functions, ACFs)
were produced off-line using the strategies outlined by Moller (1970)
.
Bin size was 9 or 30 msec, and 1024 bins were used to form the ACF
array. Autocorrelation functions were calculated and then subjected to
Fourier analysis to identify the fundamental frequency
(f0) of rhythmic components. The spectral
fundamental frequency provided a quantitative estimate of the rhythmic
discharge rate (i.e., burst rate). The FFT spectrum also provided a
means to judge the strength of rhythmicity, or whether rhythmic
bursting was considered present or not.
Spontaneous discharge patterns not showing rhythmic bursting based on
the ACF were also tested for levels of irregular bursting. Irregular
bursting patterns are characterized by bouts of neural activity that
occur at irregular intervals separated by relatively long periods of
silence. To objectively quantify the level of irregular bursting
activity ("burstiness"), we used a numerical "burst factor"
(BF) as described in a previous report (Jones and Jones, 2000
). The BF
has two principal computational components, A and
B. The number A is proportional to the relative
amount of time a cell spends in long silent periods. The more time
spent in long silent periods, the greater the burst factor. Component A was calculated by summing the duration of the longest
silent periods (i.e., the longest spike intervals) and then expressing the sum as a percentage of the entire recording sample. During analysis, spike intervals were sorted to identify the longest silent
periods. It was necessary to determine the number of longest silent
periods to use in generating the sum. This number is designated as
C, and its value is calculated using the equation
C = 5% of the total number of intervals or 4, whichever was largest. Component B provides an adjustment
for the relative amount of activity present during bursts of activity,
such that the greater the contrast between silent and active periods,
the larger the BF. B was defined as the ratio of the mean
spike interval of the longest silent periods (as defined above) divided
by the mean spike interval over the entire sample. B
therefore will tend to be largest when long silent periods are
accompanied by robust active periods having high discharge rates. BF is
the product of the two components, A and B
(BF = A*B), where A = [(total time of the longest C intervals)/(total sample
time)] and B = [(mean interval length of the longest
C intervals)/(total sample time/total number of
intervals)]. The manner in which C was determined here
differed slightly from our earlier study (using a percentage vs a
constant number of 4). The method used here is more general and serves
to accommodate the very long recordings made here. The BF provides a
metric to identify and rank irregular bursting patterns. In previous
work, values for BF ranged between 0 and 10 for embryos. In contrast, BF values in post-hatch animals ranged between 0 and 1. Auditory neurons in post-hatch animals demonstrate no irregular bursting patterns. Instead, spontaneous activity appears as a relatively continuous stochastic process. BF values >1 reflect the presence of
bursting in which the greater the BF, the more pronounced is the
bursting. We arbitrarily set a BF value of 1.1 as cutoff level for
bursting. Neural discharge patterns generating a BF of 1.1 or greater
are categorized as bursting patterns.
After physiological recordings, BDA was ejected from the pipette using
pressure (~300 kPa). One to two hours after the injection, the
cochlea was fixed and processed. Several fixation and processing protocols were used to increase the likelihood of successful label. The
following protocol has thus far been the most successful. The tympanic
membrane was opened, the columella was removed, and the cochlea was
perfused slowly with 3 ml of 4% paraformaldehyde/1% glutaraldehyde in
0.1 M phosphate buffer. Immediately after cochlear perfusion, the embryo was decapitated, the head was hemisected, and an
additional 3-5 ml of fixative was perfused into the opened labyrinth.
The medial wall of the cochlea was also opened, and the head was stored
in fixative overnight. Our experience suggests that initial perfusion
of the cochlea must occur in an intact viable animal. We have not seen
successful label in any case in which cochlear perfusion was initiated
in a physiologically compromised animal (slow or irregular
electrocardiogram or immediately after decapitation).
Dissected cochleas were processed as whole mounts. Processing began
with four rinses in PBS (10 min each). The final PBS rinse contained
1% Triton X-100. Rinses were followed with pretreatment in 0.5%
H2O2 in PBS (20 min to
block endogenous peroxidase) and three additional rinses in PBS (10 min
each). Then, cochleas were soaked overnight in avidin-HRP (Vector
Laboratories, Burlingame, CA):PBS containing 1% Triton X-100 (1:250).
The next day, cochleas were rinsed again with PBS (three times, 10 min
each) and soaked in 0.03% DAB for 20-30 min. At this point, 0.03%
H2O2 was added, one drop
every 1-2 min until desired background stain was achieved (usually an
additional 5-8 min). Processed cochleas were embedded in plastic
(JB-4) and viewed with light microscopy.
 |
RESULTS |
Data used for analysis were obtained from embryos in good
physiological condition (i.e., stable brain temperatures and regular heart rate >250 beats per minute). Studies were terminated, or data
were excluded for embryos that did not meet these criteria because they
were judged to be physiologically compromised. Sixty-one statoacoustic
ganglion cells were isolated for study in 51 embryos. All but 17 of the
neurons were spontaneously active. The 17 "silent" neurons produced
trains of action potentials with current injections ranging from 0.1 to
25 nA.
Discharge rates [spikes (Sp) per second] for spontaneously active
individual ganglion cells are plotted as a function of developmental stage in Figure 2. Rates were based on
recordings with an average duration of ~87 sec, with the lowest rate
based on 8 spikes in 90 sec and the highest rate based on 406 spikes in
10.23 sec. The total number of action potentials per record ranged from
8 to 2184 spikes. The longest continuous record of spontaneous activity was 4 min. To establish a broader context, we have added data from
earlier work for stages 44 and 45 (Jones and Jones, 2000
). The range of
spike discharge rates steadily increased during development. Mean spike
rate increased from 0.27 ± 0.26 Sp/sec (n = 2) at
stage 39 to 16.3 ± 12.5 Sp/sec (n = 7) at stage
43 (Fig. 2, linear regression slope, 4.13 Sp/sec per stage;
p < 0.001; r2 = 0.2; n = 44). Mean values at stages 41 and 42 were
6.2 ± 7.1 Sp/sec (n = 6) and 11.8 ± 11.3 Sp/sec (n = 19), respectively. Average spike rates for
stage 43 approached rates published for stages 44-45 (19 ± 17 Sp/sec, from Jones and Jones, 2000
).

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2.
Discharge rates (spikes per second) for individual
ganglion cells are plotted as a function of developmental stage. Data
for stages 44 and 45 are from earlier work (Jones and Jones, 2000 ).
Spike discharge rates increase steadily during development (regression
slope = 4.13 Sp/sec per stage; p < 0.001;
r2 = 0.2). Discharge rates for
stages 39-43 ranged from 0.09 to 40 Sp/sec, and the overall mean
discharge rate was 9 ± 10 Sp/sec (n = 44).
|
|
Five examples of discharge patterns from stages 39-43 are represented
in Figure 3. These records reflect the
slow rhythmic discharge patterns or bursting found in animals younger
than E18. The frequency of bursting was generally quite low (<1 Hz,
ranging from 0.0167 to 0.9 Hz; mean ± SD = 0.27 ± 0.19; n = 18). Figure 4
illustrates the results of autocorrelation and Fourier analysis on some
of these neurons. Neuron 80tm01 demonstrates modest spike discharge
rates overall (3.9 Sp/sec) and is featured at the top of
Figure 4. The ACF array for 80tm01 reveals a strong periodicity in
firing, whereas the FFT demonstrates a corresponding
f0 of 0.228 Hz. The burst rate in bursts per
minute is calculated as BR = f0 × 60 sec/min, or ~13.4 bursts per minute in this case. A second
rhythmically bursting neuron from Figure 3 is shown in Figure 4
(91tm01). Despite relatively low overall spike rates (0.45 Sp/sec), the
ACF reveals a clear periodicity and a significant FFT fundamental at
f0 = 0.163 Hz or ~9.8 bursts per minute. The neuron at the bottom of Figure 4 (76tm01) is an example in
which rhythmic bursting is absent. No periodicity is apparent in the ACF, and the FFT has no significant peaks. This neuron, although not a
rhythmically bursting cell, was classified as irregularly bursting,
having a BF = 1.99. All neurons of Figure 3 had robust rhythmic
patterns. There were examples of neurons in the present study that
displayed evidence of very weak periodicities, and it was necessary to
adopt an objective conservative criterion distinguishing rhythmic from
nonrhythmic patterns. Activity patterns producing spectral peaks with
magnitudes less than twice baseline levels were classified as
nonrhythmic (irregular bursting). Those producing spectra with a clear
fundamental frequency peak that was two or more times that of the
background levels were judged to be regularly bursting neurons.

View larger version (48K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 3.
Bursting spontaneous discharge patterns. Five
examples of discharge patterns are represented at progressively later
stages of development from stage 39 to 43 (top to
bottom, respectively). Eighteen of the 44 spontaneously
active ganglion cells produced rhythmic bursting patterns. Each
vertical line represents a single action potential.
Total time represented is 60 sec. Over these developmental stages, the
rate of bursting ranged from 1 to 54 bursts per minute. Burst rates for
each neuron were based on the FFT spectrum of the ACF (Fig. 4). Rates
in bursts per minute for neurons shown were 9.78 for 91tm01, 5.88 for
89tm01, 5.88 for 87tm01, 13.68 for 80tm01, and 15.6 for 84tm02. Five
cells that demonstrated regular bursting patterns (all at stages
42-43) also responded to sound.
|
|

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 4.
Autocorrelation functions
(ACF; also referred to as probability density functions)
and their fast Fourier transforms (FFT) are shown
for three representative neurons. The ACF of spike discharge activity
was examined for evidence of periodicities. Neuron 80tm01
(top) shows a robust periodicity, and the FFT spectrum
demonstrates a fundamental frequency
(f0) of 0.228 Hz. A portion of
the spike train for neuron is shown in Figure 3. Similarly, the spike
activity of neuron 91tm01 of Figure 3 was subjected to ACF and FFT
analysis, revealing a clear periodicity at 0.163 Hz, despite the low
spike rate in this case. Neuron 76tm01 exhibited no rhythmic bursting,
and as can be seen in the ACF, there were no periodicities present. FFT
amplitudes are represented in arbitrary units.
|
|
The average rhythmic burst rate (Fig. 5)
increased during stages 39-43. Burst rate increased from 9.8 bursts
per minute at stage 39 to 35 bursts per minute at stage 43 (linear
regression slope, 5.68 bursts per minute per stage; p < 0.01; r2 = 0.3;
n = 18). In many cases, the bursting was quite regular and contrasted markedly with irregular bursting patterns described in
detail for a substantial number of primary afferents in animals older
than E18 (Jones and Jones, 2000
). In all cases, bursting was unrelated
to heart beat. Eighteen of the 44 spontaneously active ganglion cells
produced rhythmic bursting patterns (e.g., Fig. 3). Five of the
rhythmic bursters (all at stages 42-43) responded to sound and had
best frequencies between 500 and 1500 Hz. In three of these neurons,
threshold estimates were observed at 36, 66, and 71 dB SPL. No
significant correlation was found between the manually determined best
frequency and rate of bursting for these five neurons.

View larger version (13K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 5.
Rhythmic discharge rates (bursts per minute) are
plotted as a function of developmental stage (top). Rate
of rhythmic bursting increased on average with increasing developmental
stage. The range of burst rates was 1-54 bursts per minute. The
regression slope for data shown was 5.68 bursts per minute per stage
(p < 0.01;
r2 = 0.3). At stages 40-43,
both rhythmic and irregular bursting patterns were present. Rates
indicated here are for rhythmic bursting only. Bursting patterns are
irregular when present at stages beyond 43. The relative number of
neurons exhibiting rhythmic bursting decreased with increasing stage
(bottom). Circles represent both rhythmic
and nonrhythmic bursting patterns, whereas triangles
represent proportions of rhythmically bursting neurons only. The
fraction of rhythmically bursting cells decreases at later stages. *
indicates that in the case of stage 39, most cells were silent. The two
cells that were active had very low spike rates, and only one had a
sufficient number of spikes to evaluate for bursting patterns. This
cell exhibited rhythmic bursting. The other cell generated only eight
spikes in 90 sec, thus precluding a determination of bursting
status.
|
|
The relative percentage of neurons exhibiting spontaneous bursting
changed as a function of developmental stage. At ages younger than
stage 42, 10 of the 18 active cells demonstrated rhythmic bursting. The
relative number of rhythmically bursting cells decreased with
increasing stage as illustrated in Figure 5 (bottom). There was a mixture of neurons displaying regular and irregular bursting patterns at stages 40-43. The proportion of silent cells also decreased progressively from 67% at stage 39 to zero at stages 44 and
45. Figure 5 illustrates the relative number of irregularly and
regularly bursting neurons at each stage. At stages 44-45, bursting is
evident in ~33% of cells, and the bursting patterns are irregular
(Jones and Jones, 2000
). For the present data, interspike interval
coefficient of variation (CV = SD/mean) was calculated for
bursting and nonbursting neurons. The mean CV of bursting neurons was
significantly higher (2.20 ± 1.12; n = 33; range, 1.17-7.22) than nonbursting cells (0.82 ± 0.34;
n = 10; range, 0.15-1.21). Two of the nonbursting
cells had time interval histograms with a Gaussian shape and CVs much
<0.5. These latter discharge characteristics are normally seen with
neurons innervating the lagena.
Cellular labeling was observed in four embryos. Figure
6 shows the primary afferent terminals
for neuron 87tm01 (stage 40-41) of Figure 3. This neuron was located
50% of the distance from apex to base, it terminated toward the
abneural edge of the papilla (60% of distance from the neural to
abneural edge), it did not respond to sound at levels up to 103 dB SPL,
and it generated the rhythmic discharge pattern shown in Figure 3. A
second bursting neuron recorded from another embryo at stage 40-41
innervated a similar central region of the papilla but had terminals
near the neural edge transversely (10% of distance from neural to
abneural edge). The label in the other two cases filled ganglion cell
bodies but could not be resolved at the final terminals on hair
cells.

View larger version (124K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 6.
Labeled neuron for animal 87tm01. Spontaneous
discharge pattern for this animal is shown in Figure 2.
Top, The neural edge; bottom, the
abneural edge; right, the base; and left,
the apex. Scale bar, 50 µm.
|
|
 |
DISCUSSION |
The majority of embryonic ganglion cells at stages 39-43
(E13-E17) display regular, rhythmic spontaneous bursting patterns. These data provide the first definitive evidence of primordial regular
bursting patterns for primary afferents of the cochlear ganglion. The
rate of bursting increases with age and becomes less regular as
development proceeds. At stages beyond 43, only 33% of statoacoustic
ganglion cells burst, and the bursting pattern is irregular (Jones and
Jones, 2000
). The presence of rhythmic bursting in cochlear ganglion
cells at stages 40-43 provides an explanation for the existence of
such patterns in central auditory relays of embryos (Lippe, 1994
,
1995
). The range of rhythmic bursting rates found in the present study
was somewhat wider than that reported by Lippe for comparable ages.
Here, bursting rates increased significantly with age in ganglion
cells, a finding that could explain a similar increase observed by
Lippe in the brainstem. In contrast to Lippe, we found no relationship
between best frequency and rate of bursting. The fact that we used a
manual audiovisual procedure to estimate best frequency does not likely
account for this difference because Lippe used a similar approach. On
the other hand, we determined a best frequency in a relatively small number of cells, and it may be the case that larger numbers of neurons
are required to resolve the putative relationship. This issue deserves
further study.
Five of the rhythmically bursting cells of the present study responded
to sound, thus identifying them as auditory fibers innervating the
papilla. Two other rhythmically bursting cells did not respond to
sound, but BDA labeling identified their cell bodies and showed them to
innervate the papilla. These data clearly demonstrate that auditory
primary afferents can and do display rhythmic bursting patterns at
stages 39-43. In our view, most of the rhythmically bursting cells are
likely cochlear afferents, including unlabeled cells that did not
respond to sound. This is based primarily on the fact that auditory
primary afferents are by far the most numerous cells in the
statoacoustic ganglion (~8000) (Fischer et al., 1994
), followed in
number by lagenar cells (~2000) and then efferent fibers (<400).
Auditory cells, by virtue of their numbers, are the easiest to isolate
for recording and have large cell bodies in the ganglion. Efferent
fibers are not only relatively few in number but also generally very
small and extremely difficult to isolate. Moreover, there are no
efferent cell bodies in the periphery. Lagenar afferents, although much smaller in number, are of comparable size and have cell bodies in the
peripheral ganglion that occupy somewhat different regions than those
of cochlear cells. We do not have positive evidence that any of the
bursting neurons were lagenar. However, we cannot rule out the
possibility that some of the bursting cells were lagenar primary afferents.
The present study shows that at developmental stages 39-43 in the
chicken embryo, statoacoustic ganglion cells also display slow overall
spontaneous firing rates that are substantially lower than those
published for stages 44-45 (Jones and Jones, 2000
). Discharge rates
for the youngest embryos (stages 39-41) are significantly lower than
rates for older embryos (stages 42-43). Slow discharge rates are
accompanied by higher CVs and longer dead times. Moreover, for stages
39 and 40, a substantial proportion of cells that we encountered were
silent. These findings reveal the immature functional status of the
neuroepithelium several days after the formation of synaptic contacts
between hair cells and primary afferents. Indeed, our youngest embryos
were recorded during the period in which compound responses to intense
sound appear for the first time (above 105 dB SPL; E12-E13) (Saunders
et al., 1973
). In the youngest animals of the present study, the cells
tested were unresponsive to intense tones (as high as 103-107 dB SPL)
at all frequencies. It is clear that there are a limited number of
neurons transmitting information about natural environmental sounds
during this period. Although spontaneous synaptic activity is likely
present, our findings suggest that most natural sounds are well below
the threshold of afferents. From this standpoint, the period between
E13 and E15 (stages 38-40) may be considered "prehearing."
As noted above, in the youngest embryos, many cells appeared to exhibit
no spontaneous activity, and yet long spike trains were readily
produced with nanoampere levels of current injection in each case.
Romand (1984)
also noted silent neurons in very young kittens. The
spontaneous rate of discharge may be so low in these neurons that
periods much longer than several minutes are required to resolve it.
Indeed, the proportion of silent cells increased markedly in animals at
stage 41 and younger; this increase was accompanied by dramatic
decreases in discharge rates generally. In animals at stage 39, it was
difficult to find spontaneously active cells at all. From the
standpoint of developing spontaneous discharge therefore, stages 38-39
may represent periods in which activity in statoacoustic ganglion cells
first emerges.
Structural immaturity may contribute to the high thresholds and
immature activity patterns of stages 38-40. A considerable amount of
information has been published regarding this early period of cochlear
ontogeny in the chicken (Cohen and Fermin, 1978
, 1985
; Ard and Morest,
1984
; Fermin and Cohen, 1984a
,b
; Whitehead and Morest, 1985a
,b
; Cohen
and Cotanche, 1992
; Cohen and Hersing, 1993
; Sokolowski and Cunningham,
1999
). Primary afferent synaptic contacts on hair cells are clearly
present but retain immature characteristics throughout the period. Hair
cells of the avian basilar papilla are organized differently than the
inner and outer hair cells of mammals. However, on the basis of
morphology and innervation patterns, tall and short hair cells of the
avian papilla have been viewed as analogs of mammalian inner and outer
hair cells, respectively. In Aves, primary afferent synapses are
dominant on tall hair cells and these afferents likely provide the
primary input to the brain. In contrast, efferent innervation dominates on short hair cells, and short hair cells may perform functions more
related to the tuning characteristics of the basilar membrane (Manley,
1990
). Although this may be true in the mature cochlea, this
arrangement only gradually appears in the chicken embryo. Early
differentiation of tall and short hair cells begins at stages 37-38
and continues until hair cell types and supporting cells are clearly
distinguished by stage 42. Primary afferents begin to myelinate, and
they manifest an immature distribution of dendrites on the papilla with
nearly equal afferent innervation of tall and short hair cells during
this period. The nascent tectorial membrane changes from a thin sheet
of uncondensed fibrillar material at stages 37 and 38 to an emerging
honeycomb appearance by stage 40. Moreover, the middle ear is
fluid-filled throughout, and ossification of the columella only begins
during this period. Although efferent fibers are present, their
innervation patterns and distributions are quite immature. This period
also precedes the emergence in hair cells of calcium-activated K
channels thought to be critical for sharply tuned auditory selectivity
(Fuchs and Sokolowski, 1990
).
The origin of the cochlear bursting pattern is unknown. The rhythmic
process does not simply reflect slower discharge rates. If that were
the case, then presumably CVs of bursting neurons would not be altered.
Mature spontaneous discharge patterns exhibit a quasi-Poisson spike
interval distribution reflecting a primary stochastic or random
excitatory process (Kiang, 1965
). As a result, spike interval CVs of
mature auditory neurons are very near 1.0. This is true also in embryos
at stages 44 and 45, provided they do not exhibit bursting patterns
(Jones and Jones, 2000
). Bursting represents a deviation in the
stochastic pattern that manifests as a higher CV. Simply slowing the
rate of discharge of an auditory neuron without altering its stochastic
nature will not change the CV. Presumably therefore, bursting reflects
the presence of an excitatory process fundamentally different in its
temporal dynamics than the steady quasi-stochastic process found in
mature animals. Hypothetically, bursting rhythms could be produced
directly by the embryonic afferent neuron itself (Spitzer and Ribera,
1998
), by hair cells, or both. A more indirect role for efferent
neurons also cannot be ruled out. Sokolowski and Cunningham (1999)
have suggested that the presence of slow, broad calcium spikes in hair cells
as early as E12 (Fuchs and Evans, 1990
; Fuchs and Sokolowski, 1990
)
could form the basis for bursting excitatory patterns. However, explicit tests of these hypotheses remain for future studies.
Primordial rhythmic activity has been shown to be of critical import to
the development of normal binocular vision (Shatz, 1996
). The discovery
of similar discharge patterns in the periphery of the auditory system
is remarkable and suggests the possibility that such rhythms could
serve as a patterning signal for the auditory system during
development. Recent ablation studies in the rat (Gabriele and Henkel,
2000
) and altered acoustic environments in mice (Sanes and
Constantine-Paton, 1985
) have provided evidence for some cochlear role
in central refinements. Rhythmic activity patterns in primary
afferents, such as those reported here, could conceivably provide each
ear with a unique activity input signature. This input signature could
guide developmental refinements in central binaural processing circuits
that serve the functions of sound localization and integration.
 |
FOOTNOTES |
Received July 28, 2000; revised July 17, 2001; accepted July 27, 2001.
This research was supported by National Institutes of Health and
National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders Grant
R01 DC02753.
Correspondence should be addressed to Dr. Timothy A. Jones, Department
of Surgery/Otolaryngology, University of Missouri School of Medicine,
Room 202 Allton Building, DC375.00, 301 Business Loop 70W, Columbia, MO
65212. E-mail: JonesT{at}health.missouri.edu.
 |
REFERENCES |
-
Ard MD,
Morest DK
(1984)
Cell death during development of the cochlear and vestibular ganglia of the chick.
Int J Dev Neurosci
2:535-547.
-
Cohen GM,
Cotanche DA
(1992)
Development of the sensory receptors and their innervation in the chick cochlea.
In: Development of auditory and vestibular systems 2 (Romand R,
ed), pp 101-138. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
-
Cohen GM,
Fermin CD
(1978)
The development of hair cells in the embryonic chick's basilar papilla.
Acta Otolaryngol
86:342-358[Medline].
-
Cohen GM,
Fermin CD
(1985)
Development of the embryonic chick's tectorial membrane.
Hear Res
18:29-39[ISI][Medline].
-
Cohen GM,
Hersing W
(1993)
Development of the chick's auditory ossicle, the columella.
Physiologist
36:S75-S76[Medline].
-
Constantine-Paton M,
Cline HT,
Debski E
(1990)
Patterned activity, synaptic convergence, and the NMDA receptor in developing visual pathways.
Annu Rev Neurosci
13:129-154[ISI][Medline].
-
Fermin CD,
Cohen GM
(1984a)
Developmental gradients in the embryonic chick's basilar papilla.
Acta Otolaryngol
97:39-51[Medline].
-
Fermin CD,
Cohen GM
(1984b)
Development of the embryonic chick's statoacoustic ganglion.
Acta Otolaryngol
98:42-52[Medline].
-
Fischer FP,
Eisensamer B,
Manley GA
(1994)
Cochlear and lagenar ganglia of the chicken.
J Morphol
220:71-83[Medline].
-
Fuchs PA,
Evans MG
(1990)
Potassium currents in hair cells isolated from the cochlea of the chick.
J Physiol (Lond)
429:529-551[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Fuchs PA,
Sokolowski BHA
(1990)
The acquisition during development of Ca-activated potassium currents by cochlear hair cells of the chick.
Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci
241:122-126[Medline].
-
Gabriele ML,
Henkel CK
(2000)
Changes in the development of afferent patterns in the inferior colliculus of the rat following unilateral cochlear ablation.
Assoc Res Otolaryngol Abs
625:180.
-
Galli L,
Maffei L
(1988)
Spontaneous impulse activity of rat retinal ganglion cells in prenatal life.
Science
242:90-91[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Gummer AW,
Mark RF
(1994)
Patterned neural activity in brain stem auditory areas of a prehearing mammal, the tammar wallaby Macropus eugenii.
NeuroReport
5:685-688[ISI][Medline].
-
Hamburger V,
Hamilton HL
(1951)
A series of normal stages in the development of the chick embryo.
J Morphol
88:49-92[ISI].
-
Jones SM,
Jones TA
(1995a)
Neural tuning characteristics of auditory primary afferents in the chicken embryo.
Hear Res
82:139-148[ISI][Medline].
-
Jones SM,
Jones TA
(1995b)
The tonotopic map in the embryonic chicken cochlea.
Hear Res
82:149-157[ISI][Medline].
-
Jones TA,
Jones SM
(2000)
Spontaneous activity in the statoacoustic ganglion of the chicken embryo.
J Neurophysiol
83:1452-1468[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Kiang NYS
(1965)
In: Discharge patterns of single fibers in the cat's auditory nerve. Cambridge, MA: MIT.
-
Lippe WR
(1994)
Rhythmic spontaneous activity in the developing avian auditory system.
J Neurosci
14:1486-1495[Abstract].
-
Lippe WR
(1995)
Relationship between frequency of spontaneous bursting and tonotopic position in the developing avian auditory system.
Brain Res
703:205-213[ISI][Medline].
-
Manley GA
(1990)
In: Peripheral hearing mechanisms in reptiles and birds, pp 206-252. Berlin: Springer.
-
Masland RH
(1997)
Maturation of function in the developing rabbit retina.
J Comp Neurol
175:275-286.
-
Meister M,
Wong ROL,
Baylor DA,
Shatz CJ
(1991)
Synchronous bursts of action potentials in ganglion cells of the developing mammalian retina.
Science
252:939-943[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Moller AR
(1970)
The use of correlation analysis in processing neuroelectric data.
Prog Brain Res
33:87-100[Medline].
-
Mooney R,
Penn AA,
Gallego R,
Shatz CJ
(1996)
Thalamic relay of spontaneous retinal activity prior to vision.
Neuron
17:863-874[ISI][Medline].
-
Richter C,
Sauer G,
Hoidis S,
Klinke R
(1996)
Development of activity patterns in auditory nerve fibres of pigeons.
Hear Res
95:77-86[ISI][Medline].
-
Romand R
(1984)
Functional properties of auditory-nerve fibers during postnatal development in the kitten.
Exp Brain Res
56:395-402[ISI][Medline].
-
Sanes DH,
Constantine-Paton M
(1985)
The sharpening of frequency tuning curves requires patterned activity during development in the mouse, Mus musculus.
J Neurosci
5:1152-1166[Abstract].
-
Saunders JC,
Coles RB,
Gates GR
(1973)
The development of auditory evoked responses in the cochlea and cochlear nuclei of the chick.
Brain Res
63:59-74[ISI][Medline].
-
Shatz CJ
(1990)
Impulse activity and the patterning of connections during CNS development.
Neuron
5:745-756[ISI][Medline].
-
Shatz CJ
(1996)
Emergence of order in visual system development.
Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
93:602-608[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Sokolowski BHA,
Cunningham AM
(1999)
Patterns of synaptophysin expression during development of the inner ear in the chick.
J Neurobiol
38:46-64[ISI][Medline].
-
Spitzer NC,
Ribera AB
(1998)
Development of electrical excitability in embryonic neurons: mechanisms and roles.
J Neurobiol
37:190-197[ISI][Medline].
-
Whitehead MC,
Morest DK
(1985a)
The development of innervation patterns in the avian cochlea.
Neuroscience
14:255-276[ISI][Medline].
-
Whitehead MC,
Morest DK
(1985b)
The growth of cochlear fibers and the formation of their synaptic endings in the avian inner ear: a study with the electron microscope.
Neuroscience
14:277-300[ISI][Medline].
-
Wong ROL,
Meister M,
Shatz CJ
(1993)
Transient period of correlated bursting activity during development of the mammalian retina.
Neuron
11:923-938[ISI][Medline].
-
Wong ROL,
Chernjavsky A,
Smith SJ,
Shatz CJ
(1995)
Early functional neural networks in the developing retina.
Nature
374:716-718[Medline].
Copyright © 2001 Society for Neuroscience 0270-6474/01/21208129-07$05.00/0
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
S. Levic, L. Nie, D. Tuteja, M. Harvey, B. H. A. Sokolowski, and E. N. Yamoah
Development and regeneration of hair cells share common functional features
PNAS,
November 27, 2007;
104(48):
19108 - 19113.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
T. A. Jones, P. A. Leake, R. L. Snyder, O. Stakhovskaya, and B. Bonham
Spontaneous Discharge Patterns in Cochlear Spiral Ganglion Cells Before the Onset of Hearing in Cats
J Neurophysiol,
October 1, 2007;
98(4):
1898 - 1908.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
C. Koppl
Spontaneous Generation in Early Sensory Development. Focus on "Spontaneous Discharge Patterns in Cochlear Spiral Ganglion Cells Before the Onset of Hearing in Cats"
J Neurophysiol,
October 1, 2007;
98(4):
1843 - 1844.
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
F. A. Ene, A. Kalmbach, and K. Kandler
Metabotropic Glutamate Receptors in the Lateral Superior Olive Activate TRP-Like Channels: Age- and Experience-Dependent Regulation
J Neurophysiol,
May 1, 2007;
97(5):
3365 - 3375.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
T. A. Jones, S. M. Jones, and K. C. Paggett
Emergence of Hearing in the Chicken Embryo
J Neurophysiol,
July 1, 2006;
96(1):
128 - 141.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
W. J. Moody and M. M. Bosma
Ion Channel Development, Spontaneous Activity, and Activity-Dependent Development in Nerve and Muscle Cells
Physiol Rev,
July 1, 2005;
85(3):
883 - 941.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. Branchereau, J. Chapron, and P. Meyrand
Descending 5-Hydroxytryptamine Raphe Inputs Repress the Expression of Serotonergic Neurons and Slow the Maturation of Inhibitory Systems in Mouse Embryonic Spinal Cord
J. Neurosci.,
April 1, 2002;
22(7):
2598 - 2606.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|