Previous Article | Next Article 
The Journal of Neuroscience, September 15, 2002, 22(18):8324-8333
Gustatory Processing in Thoracic Local Circuits of Locusts
Stephen M.
Rogers and
Philip L.
Newland
Centre for Neuroscience, School of Biological Sciences, University
of Southampton, Southampton SO16 7PX, United Kingdom
 |
ABSTRACT |
Recent reviews highlight a longstanding controversy about how
different taste qualities are coded in the CNS. To address this issue,
we have analyzed gustatory coding in the relatively simple and
accessible nervous system of the locust, in which neural responses and
gustatory elicited behavior are readily comparable. The intracellular responses of a population of spiking local interneurons in the metathoracic ganglion that receive monosynaptic inputs from
chemosensory afferents were analyzed in response to stimulation with
droplets of four behaviorally relevant chemicals: sodium chloride,
sucrose, lysine glutamate, and nicotine hydrogen tartrate. There was a significant positive correlation between chemical concentration and
response duration and the number of spikes evoked in 81% of interneurons sampled. The threshold of sensitivity to different chemicals varied but was consistent between all interneurons
tested, being most sensitive to nicotine hydrogen tartrate and least
sensitive to sucrose. Each interneuron responded similarly to specific
chemicals at single concentrations. Interneurons that responded
phasically to one chemical responded similarly to others, whereas
interneurons that responded phasotonically to one stimulus also did so
to others. Hindleg motor neurons also responded in a
concentration-dependent manner to all test chemicals. Therefore, we
found no interneurons or motor neurons that responded only to specific
chemicals. We discuss the responses of the local circuit neurons in
relation to the known chemically evoked behavioral responses of locusts and suggest that the aversiveness of a chemical, rather than its identity, is encoded directly in the local circuits.
Key words:
chemosensory processing; taste; local circuits; spiking
local interneuron; motor neuron; withdrawal reflex; grasshopper
 |
INTRODUCTION |
The sense of taste has a vital role
in the selection of appropriate foods, in the decision to ingest food,
and in regulating dietary intake (Scott and Verhagen, 2000
; Spector,
2000
). All animals must solve the same basic problem of how to
categorize, process, and represent different taste qualities in the
CNS. A number of recent reviews highlight a longstanding controversy of
how different chemicals are coded between two contrasting coding models
(Smith and St John, 1999
; Scott and Giza, 2000
; Smith et al., 2000
).
Across-fiber pattern coding (Pfaffmann, 1959
) contends that individual
chemosensory neurons vary from each other in sensitivity but are
broadly tuned, with each responding to a number of different chemicals
and with the range of sensitivity of any individual neuron overlapping
with that of several others. Chemical identity is decoded by the CNS by
comparing the population response of many neurons. In contrast, the
labeled-line theory asserts that there are distinct neuron classes that
each code for different taste qualities with no overlap in sensitivity
(Pfaffmann, 1974
; Pfaffmann et al., 1976
).
Studies at peripheral and central levels have shown that gustatory
neurons in general lack strong stimulus specificity (Pfaffmann, 1959
),
with central neurons being broadly tuned to different taste stimuli
(Smith and Travers, 1979
; Spector, 2000
). A major difficulty with
understanding precisely how different animals code tastes is that the
behavioral significance of different gustatory qualities in influencing
feeding decisions remains largely unknown. Nor is it clear how and
where gustatory information is further processed in the CNS before
reaching motor centers controlling behavior. In recent years, we have
been analyzing the central pathways responsible for taste processing in
the comparatively simple nervous system of the locust (Newland, 1999
),
in which the taste receptors, or basiconic sensilla, are distributed
over most of the body surface (Chapman, 1982
). At the sensory level,
the consensus has been that across-fiber pattern coding is used
(Chapman, 1995
). We have been able to focus our analyses on
readily accessible taste receptors that project to regions of the CNS
(Newland et al., 2000
) that we know in detail (Burrows, 1996
) and to
which we have developed a model of chemosensory-elicited behavior
(Rogers and Newland, 2000
).
In vertebrates, neurons in the nucleus of the solitary tract
(NST) are broadly tuned to more than one stimulus quality and represent
the initial stage in the central coding and processing of taste signals
(Smith and Travers, 1979
). In insects, spiking local interneurons serve
a similar role, receiving monosynaptic inputs from gustatory afferents
innervating basiconic sensilla on a leg (Newland, 1999
). In turn, these
local interneurons make output connections with leg motor neurons that
activate the leg musculature. Spiking local interneurons and motor
neurons in the thoracic nervous system are readily accessible to
intracellular recording. Here, we analyze their responses to a number
of stimulus qualities ranging from nutrient to toxic in a range of
concentrations and show how they are encoded in local circuits.
 |
MATERIALS AND METHODS |
Adult desert locusts, Schistocerca gregaria
(Forskål), of both sexes were taken from a colony maintained at the
University of Southampton. Animals were secured ventral side uppermost
in modeling clay to prevent movement. The right hindleg was positioned laterally and restrained securely with the anterior surface uppermost and accessible. The mesothoracic and metathoracic ganglia were exposed
by removing a window of cuticle in the ventral thorax and overlying air
sacs. The abdominal connectives were severed, and a small platform,
made from a wax-coated chloridated silver wire, was inserted underneath
the ganglia for support. In most experiments, all peripheral nerves
were cut except nerve 5 of the metathoracic ganglion that contains
axons of sensory neurons innervating receptors on and in the hindleg.
The ganglion sheath was softened by direct application of a protease
(Sigma type XIV) for 45-60 sec, and thereafter the thorax was
continuously superperfused with locust saline at 20-25°C. A more
detailed description of this procedure has been described by Burrows et
al. (1989)
.
Recording. Intracellular recordings were made from
the somata of leg motor neurons and midline spiking local interneurons of local circuits producing and controlling hindleg movements (Fig.
1A) using glass
microelectrodes filled with 2 M potassium acetate
and with direct current resistance of 50-80 M
. Recordings were made
with either an Axoclamp 2A amplifier (Axon Instruments, Foster City,
CA) or an amplifier designed and built at the University of Cambridge
(Cambridge, UK). For motor neuron recordings, a pair of insulated 50 µm copper wires, exposed only at their tips, was implanted in the
tibial extensor muscle of the hindleg and used to stimulate the muscle
to induce antidromic spikes in the fast extensor tibia motor neuron
(FETi). Flexor tibia motor neurons, which occur in three groups, each
consisting of a fast, intermediate, and slow neuron, were identified
according to a number of criteria as detailed by Burrows et al. (1989)
.
These criteria were: the occurrence of short and constant latency
depolarizing potentials (monosynaptic connection) after antidromic
spikes in FETi, relative position of the somata in the metathoracic
ganglion, and spiking rates and tibial movements when depolarizing
current was injected into a flexor motor neuron. Other motor neurons
were identified on the basis of the part of the leg that moved, and the
speed of movement, when depolarizing current was injected into the
neuron. Spiking local interneurons were all from a population with
somata in a ventral midline location, which have GABAergic synaptic
outputs (Siegler and Burrows, 1983
; Burrows and Siegler, 1984
).
Interneurons were characterized according to exteroceptive or
proprioceptive input and by receptive field, as determined by lightly
touching different parts of the leg with a paintbrush (Siegler and
Burrows, 1983
; Burrows and Siegler, 1984
; Burrows, 1985
). Spiking local neurons were injected with hyperpolarizing current just sufficient to
stop spontaneous spike activity before the beginning of
experiments.

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 1.
Spiking local interneurons and hindleg motor
neurons receive convergent mechanosensory and chemosensory inputs.
A, Summary of the basic organization of
chemosensory and mechanosensory processing pathways in local circuits.
Cell types recorded are shown in black.
B, Simultaneous dual recording of a midline spiking
local interneuron and a posterior flexor tibia motor neuron. Gently
deflecting receptors on a hindleg with a paint brush elicited a
sustained depolarization and spikes in an interneuron and depolarizing
potentials in a flexor tibia motor neuron. C, Applying a
droplet of 100 mM NaCl to the leg also elicited a sustained
depolarization and spikes in the same interneuron and a long-lasting
depolarization in the same flexor tibia motor neuron. D,
A droplet of water applied to the same site on the hindleg evoked
briefer depolarizing responses in both neurons. All recordings are from
the same pair of neurons. Arrows indicate onset of droplets.
In this and subsequent figures of intracellular recordings, the
dotted lines represent the membrane potential before
stimulation. Flexor, Flexor tibia motor neuron;
interneuron, spiking local interneuron of a ventral
midline population.
|
|
Test protocol. Chemical stimuli were applied as droplets of
aqueous solutions to taste receptors, or basiconic sensilla, with Pasteur pipettes in a region of the leg identified as having the strongest mechanosensory input onto sampled spiking local interneurons. It has been established previously that the mechanosensory and chemosensory receptive fields are coincident for most spiking local
interneurons (Newland, 1999
). Droplets were applied to the distal
dorsal tibia and tarsus in experiments characterizing the properties of
motor neurons, unless otherwise specified. Single droplets were
extruded onto the target site with the tips of pipettes held ~10 mm
above the target site. There were no detectable differences in the
volume of droplets of different chemical solutions (Rogers and Newland,
2000
). To rule out variability caused by the viscosity of the test
chemical acting on the mechanosensory afferent of a receptor that
provides convergent input onto interneurons (for example, caused by
high concentrations of sucrose), the droplets of chemicals were left on
the leg for 10 sec, after which time all responses ceased. The droplets
were then wiped off. The chemicals used in the study, water, NaCl,
sucrose, nicotine hydrogen tartrate (NHT), and lysine glutamate, were
chosen because they represent a variety of qualities to locusts and
were the same chemicals used in a previous behavioral study by Rogers
and Newland (2000)
. Sucrose and lysine glutamate are representative of
the two classes of macronutrient, carbohydrate and protein, and are
known to actively promote feeding (Simpson and Raubenheimer, 1993
).
Salts are required in small quantities in the diet but become feeding
deterrents at higher concentrations (Simpson, 1994
), whereas NHT is a
potent feeding deterrent, even at low concentrations, and may provoke active avoidance responses (White and Chapman, 1990
).
The concentration ranges used varied for each chemical and were
determined from the data obtained by Rogers and Newland (2000)
. For
each chemical, they spanned a range from concentrations little more
likely to evoke local movements than water to concentrations that
evoked movements in 60-70% of applications to the tarsus. All
chemicals were dissolved in distilled water. The following concentrations were used (in mM): 0.05, 0.5, 2.5, and 5 NHT
(Sigma, St. Louis, MO), pH 4.4-3.1; 25, 50, 75, and 100 NaCl (Fisher
Scientific, Houston, TX), pH 6.3-6.6; 250, 500, 1000, and 2000 sucrose
(BDH Chemicals, Poole, UK), pH 6.4-6.9; and 250, 500, 1000, and 2000 lysine glutamate (Sigma), pH 6.2-6.3.
The number of spikes elicited, the duration of the
depolarization/hyperpolarization, and its peak amplitude in response to chemical stimulation were determined for all neural responses. The
duration of response was calculated as the time from the onset of
depolarization/hyperpolarization to a recovery of two-thirds the peak
amplitude of depolarization/hyperpolarization.
Chemosensory receptors within the basiconic sensilla on a leg adapt
rapidly to repeated stimulation with most chemicals (White and Chapman,
1990
; Newland, 1998
). For this reason, only a single droplet was
applied every 2 min for tests of responsiveness of spiking local
interneurons and every 3 min for tests on motor neurons to avoid
adaptation. The droplet was applied for 5-10 sec and wiped off, and
then a droplet of water was immediately applied and wiped off, after
which the animal was left for the requisite time. Solutions were
applied in ascending concentration series, normally starting with the
most behaviorally ineffective solution. Behavioral effectiveness was
derived from the study by Rogers and Newland (2000)
and is defined as
the frequency of locusts withdrawing their legs from the applied
chemical stimulus. All data used in the results derive from experiments
in which at least one ascending set of response data was gathered,
followed by at least one further droplet from the weakest
concentration. Wherever possible, two or more successive ascending
concentration series were applied to control against underlying
variation in recording quality and any possible long-lasting,
concentration-independent variation in neuronal response.
 |
RESULTS |
Responses of spiking local interneurons to
gustatory stimulation
Local circuits producing and controlling movements of the leg of
locusts have been well studied, and we now know much about their
general organization (Fig. 1A). Spiking local
interneurons from the midline population receive convergent
mechanosensory and chemosensory inputs from receptors on a hindleg
(Fig. 1A). Touching hairs and basiconic sensilla with
a fine brush evoked depolarizations and spikes in spiking local
interneurons (Fig. 1B). The majority of spiking local
interneurons that received exteroceptive inputs also received
chemosensory inputs (see below). For example, a droplet of 100 mM NaCl applied to the hindleg evoked a
long-lasting depolarization and spikes in the same interneuron that
received mechanosensory inputs (Fig. 1C). The duration of the response to droplets containing chemicals was always longer than to
droplets containing water only (Fig. 1C,D).
Activity in the spiking local interneuron was rapidly
followed by activity in a flexor tibia motor neuron, the amplitude of
which paralleled that of inputs to the spiking local interneuron
for both mechanosensory (Fig. 1B) and
chemosensory (Fig. 1C) stimulation.
Concentration-dependent responses
Forty-five spiking local interneurons were tested with one of four
test chemicals, each in a range of concentrations. Droplets of
chemicals were applied to regions of a hindleg that were found to
provide the strongest mechanosensory input to the recorded local
interneuron. We measured the duration, amplitude, and number of spikes
evoked in an interneuron by chemosensory stimulation. Thirty-six of the
interneurons showed a statistically significant increase in the
strength of the response with increasing chemical concentration (Table
1; Figs. 2,
3, and 4).
The response characteristics most frequently correlated with chemical
concentration were the duration of depolarization and the number of
spikes evoked by chemical stimulation (Table 1). Response amplitude,
however, was less reliably correlated with chemical concentration,
reflecting the difficulty in measuring the amplitude of the underlying
depolarization in a spiking neuron and vulnerability to variation in
recording quality over the course of the experiments.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table 1.
Correlation coefficients of chemical concentration and the
duration, amplitude, and spike frequency of response for midline
spiking local interneurons tested with four different chemicals
|
|

View larger version (26K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2.
Responses of midline spiking local
interneurons to chemosensory stimulation. A, Responses
to NaCl. B, Responses to sucrose. C,
Responses to NHT. D, Responses to lysine glutamate.
Recordings from four different spiking local interneurons showing their
responses to repeated applications of increasing concentrations
of the four test chemicals. The greater the chemical concentration, the
greater the response in an interneuron. Chemical droplets were applied
once every 2 min in an ascending concentration series; each application
was followed by water, and the entire sequence was repeated.
|
|

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 3.
Relationship between chemical concentration and
response in interneurons. Summaries of the mean duration of
depolarization evoked in response to a concentration series of four
test chemicals are shown. A, Responses to NaCl.
B, Responses to sucrose. C, Responses to
NHT. D, Responses to lysine glutamate. In general, the
greater the concentration of a test chemical, the greater the duration
of response elicited in an interneuron. Each line
represents data from a different interneuron, with solid
lines indicating significant correlations. Data detailing the
number of droplets applied and the significance of the correlations
between concentration and duration of response are given for each
interneuron in Table 1. Arrows indicate responses to water
alone.
|
|

View larger version (16K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 4.
Relationship between chemical concentration and
interneuron spike number. Summaries of the number of spikes evoked by
different concentrations of the test chemicals applied to the leg are
shown. A, Responses to NaCl. B, Responses
to sucrose. C, Responses to NHT. D,
Responses to lysine glutamate. Each line represents data
from a different interneuron, with solid lines
indicating significant correlations. In general, the greater the
concentration of a chemical, the greater number of spikes evoked in an
interneuron. Arrows indicate responses to water alone.
Neuron identities are the same as in Figure 3 and Table 1.
|
|
Ten of 13 spiking local interneurons tested with droplets of NaCl
showed statistically significant correlations (Spearman's
) between
the concentration of the chemical in the droplet and the duration
(Figs. 2A, 3A) and/or the number of spikes
(Fig. 4A) evoked in response to the stimulation
(Table 1). Another 13 spiking local interneurons were tested with
sucrose, and of these 11 showed significant correlations between
concentration and neural response, either duration and/or the number of
spikes evoked (Table 1; Figs. 2B, 3B,
4B). All eight neurons tested with NHT (Table 1;
Figs. 2C, 3C, 4C) and 7 of 11 neurons
tested with lysine glutamate (Table 1; Figs. 2D,
3D, 4D) had responses that were
significantly correlated with chemical concentration. We found no
neurons exhibiting significantly smaller responses with increasing
concentration for any of the test chemicals. Moreover, there were no
significant correlations between interneuron response and the pH of the
test chemicals.
The responses of individual spiking local interneurons were clearly
dose dependent, but there was considerable variation in their absolute
excitability. This is reflected in the control response to water, in
which the duration of the depolarization after stimulation of the leg
ranged from ~0.1 to 1 sec or from 0.2 to >5 sec for the highest
concentrations of stimulating chemicals (Fig. 3). This variability is
clearly seen in the representative traces of recordings from
interneurons shown in Figure 2. The responses of the interneuron in
Figure 2B were very short to all droplets but
nevertheless increased in amplitude with chemical concentration,
whereas the interneuron in Figure 2D exhibited considerably more prolonged responses. The interneurons shown in Figure
2A and C are typical of interneurons with
response durations intermediate to these two extremes. The chemical
used had no consistent effect on excitability; responses ranging from
extremely rapid to long lasting were found in interneurons tested with
any one of the four chemicals (Fig. 3).
In summary, 81% of spiking local interneurons tested with one of the
four test chemicals showed a significant relationship between chemical
concentration and duration of response, which varied from phasic to phasotonic.
Evidence for the convergence of chemosensory inputs onto spiking
local interneurons
Many studies have shown that the different sensory neurons within
a single basiconic sensillum encode a wide range of different chemicals
(Blaney, 1975
; White and Chapman, 1990
).
Our results show that there is a high probability of any sampled
spiking local interneuron responding in a dose-dependent manner to
increasing concentrations of any of the test chemicals. This suggests
that each of these interneurons may be sensitive to a large number of
different chemical stimuli. It is not clear, however, whether an
interneuron giving long-lasting phasotonic responses to one chemical
concentration series would respond similarly to a different test
chemical or whether it could respond more phasically. If this were so,
different chemical identities could be encoded in the ensemble response
of several different neurons. To test whether individual interneurons
showed different response characteristics to different chemicals,
experiments were performed on spiking local interneurons in which the
leg was tested with single concentrations of three different chemicals
and water. To balance between the need to sample several different
chemicals and to ensure that each chemical could be applied repeatedly
during the course of a single recording, not all of the test chemicals were used. Two solutions, water and 250 mM sucrose, were
chosen because they led to comparatively weak responses and two more, 250 mM NaCl and 5 mM NHT, were chosen because
they evoked relatively strong responses (Figs. 2, 3). Thirteen
interneurons were tested repeatedly with each of these solutions.
Statistically significant differences in response duration were found
in 8 of the 13 interneurons (Kruskal-Wallis tests;
significance taken at p < 0.05)
(Fig.
5A). For each interneuron, the
responses to 250 mM NaCl and 5 mM NHT were stronger than to 250 mM sucrose and water; there were no sugar-best
interneurons (Fig. 5A). As with the previous experiments, there were considerable differences in the absolute excitability of different recorded neurons, but we found that interneurons that
responded phasically to 250 mM NaCl also did so
to 5 mM NHT and similarly when interneurons that
responded phasotonically to one stimulus also did so to the other (Fig.
5A,B). The relative strength of response correlates with the
response expected to particular chemicals based on concentration series
experiments (Fig. 3). Whether the interneurons show a
concentration-dependent response or an apparent sensitivity to
particular chemicals, however, depends entirely on experimental design,
because the actual response of any one of the interneurons depends on
both chemical concentration (Fig. 3) and identity (Fig. 5).

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 5.
Individual spiking local interneurons respond to
stimulation with different chemicals. The response characteristics of
different local interneurons were all similar when tested with
different chemicals at fixed concentrations. Neurons were repeatedly
tested with single concentrations of four different chemicals at 2 min
intervals. A, In experiments where significant
differences in response duration occurred, interneurons always
responded most strongly to 5 mM NHT and 250 mM
NaCl than to 250 mM sucrose and water. Each
symbol/line represents data from a different interneuron.
B, Typical recordings of the responses obtained during
an experiment showing the longer-duration responses to NHT and
NaCl. Five responses to each test chemical are superimposed. Note the
consistency of the responses to each test chemical.
|
|
Additional evidence that individual interneurons respond in a similar
manner to different chemicals of similar behavioral effectiveness is
shown in Figure 6, in which a spiking
local interneuron responded in a similar phasic manner to a
concentration series of both NaCl and sucrose.

View larger version (43K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 6.
Responses of spiking local interneurons to
concentration series of two different chemicals. For both NaCl and
sucrose, increasing the test concentration resulted in an increase in
response duration. Three traces are superimposed for each
chemical concentration. The durations of the response for any test
concentration were similar.
|
|
In summary, the results suggest that spiking local interneurons in the
midline population receive inputs from chemosensory neurons sensitive
to many, if not all, test chemicals, and that the response durations of
these neurons are a function of both chemical concentration and
identity. The data suggest that any individual interneuron will respond
with similar relative duration to an input of similar behavioral
effectiveness (Rogers and Newland, 2000
) regardless of chemical type.
This is illustrated in Figure 6, where 50 mM NaCl and 1000 mM sucrose, both of which elicit withdrawal movements of
the leg in ~50% of cases, evoke similar numbers of spikes in the
interneuron (see Fig. 11).
Responses of leg motor neurons to gustatory stimulation
The responses of flexor tibia motor neurons resembled those of
spiking local interneurons to the same four test chemicals. The
amplitude and duration of responses in flexor tibia neurons after
stimulation of the hind tibia and tarsus with droplets of chemical
increased with concentration for all of the four test chemicals (Figs.
7A-D,
8A-D). The mean
duration of depolarization increased from ~200 msec after stimulation
with water to 600-750 msec after stimulation with 2000 mM sucrose or 250 mM NaCl
(Fig. 8). Flexor motor neurons occur in three distinct groups, each containing slow, intermediate, and fast members (Burrows, 1996
). We
found that responses were similar in motor neurons from all three
groups and for fast and slow neurons within each group. For example,
Figure 9 shows simultaneous responses
from two flexor tibia motor neurons from the posterior and lateral
groups to increasing concentrations of NaCl (Fig. 9A) and
from the fast and slow flexor neurons in the posterior group to three
concentrations of NHT (Fig. 9B). For any particular
recording from a motor neuron, the duration of responses to repeated
application of the same concentration of a test chemical was
consistent.

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 7.
Responses of flexor tibia motor neurons to
chemosensory stimulation. Recording from a single posterior flexor
tibia motor neuron showing responses to repeated applications of
concentration series of each test chemical. A, Responses
to NaCl. B, Responses to sucrose. C,
Responses to NHT. D, Responses to lysine glutamate. The
responses of the flexor tibia motor neuron showed a dose-dependent
relationship with chemical concentration, with higher chemical
concentrations evoking larger responses in the motor neuron. Droplets
of chemical solutions were applied to the dorsal tibia and tarsus in
ascending concentration at 3 min intervals. All recordings are from the
same motor neuron tested with each chemical concentration at least five
times. Three traces at each concentration are superimposed.
|
|

View larger version (11K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 8.
Mean dose-response relationships of flexor tibia
motor neurons. A, Responses to NaCl. B,
Responses to sucrose. C, Responses to NHT.
D, Responses to lysine glutamate. Mean ± SEM
response durations of flexor tibia motor neurons to concentration
series of each of the test chemicals are shown. Response duration
increased with higher concentrations of each test chemical. Data are
from nine recordings each of motor neurons tested with NaCl and
sucrose, six tested with NHT, and four tested with lysine glutamate.
Arrows indicate responses to water alone.
|
|

View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 9.
Chemosensitivity of flexor tibia motor neurons.
All flexor tibia motor neurons tested in the three motor pools
responded in a similar dose-dependent manner. Paired simultaneous
recording of flexor tibia motor neurons showed responses to ascending
concentrations of NaCl and NHT. A, A motor neuron from
each of the lateral and posterior groups responds in a similar manner
to each concentration of NaCl. B, The fast and slow
flexor tibia motor neurons of the posterior group respond in a similar
manner to a concentration series of NHT. Three traces, one at each
concentration, are superimposed. Arrows indicate responses
to the concentrations shown.
|
|
Other motor neurons controlling leg movement also exhibited
dose-dependent responses after stimulation of basiconic sensilla on the
leg with chemical solutions. The fast extensor tibia was depolarized
after applications of droplets to the distal dorsal tibia
(n = 3 animals), the duration and amplitude of which
increased with greater concentrations of NaCl (Fig.
10A). Compared with
flexor tibia motor neurons, however, the depolarizations were both
smaller and of shorter duration. For example, the duration of the
response to 100 mM NaCl lasted for only 166 ± 15.9 msec (mean and SEM) compared with 640 ± 60 msec for the
flexor tibia motor neurons. The slow depressor tarsus motor neuron,
which receives inhibitory inputs from midline spiking local
interneurons, was hyperpolarized after stimulation of the ventral tibia
with droplets containing NaCl (n = 4) (Fig.
10B,C). As with the flexor and extensor motor neurons, the duration of the response increased with increasing NaCl
concentration.

View larger version (22K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 10.
Chemosensory responses of other hindleg motor
neurons. A, Intracellular recording from a FETi showing
superimposed traces of responses of increasing duration to higher
concentrations of NaCl. Three traces at each concentration are
superimposed. B, C, Paired recording of a
lateral flexor tibia and the slow depressor tarsus motor neuron.
Both neurons display longer-duration responses to the higher
concentration of NaCl (C), but in this case, the
depressor tarsus motor neuron is hyperpolarized by the chemosensory
input.
|
|
 |
DISCUSSION |
Both spiking local interneurons and motor neurons receive synaptic
inputs during stimulation with five chemicals that represent nutrient
through to toxic qualities, but there is a consistent variation in the
sensitivity of these neurons to the different chemicals. The duration
of these inputs is significantly correlated with chemical concentration
for neurons tested with any one chemical and is sufficiently large to
give rise to action potentials whose frequencies are also related to
chemical concentration and identity.
Overall, 81% of spiking local interneurons tested with one of the test
chemicals showed a significant correlation between concentration and
response. The high probability of any local interneuron receiving a
chemosensory input from any one of the different test chemicals
suggests that there is a convergence of a large number of taste
qualities onto the same interneurons, either from many sensory neurons
responding to a range of chemical qualities or from fewer, more broadly
tuned sensory neurons. In addition, interneurons that responded
phasically to one chemical responded phasically to all others tested,
whereas interneurons that responded phasotonically to one chemical also
did so to others. Although members of the same population of spiking
local interneurons differed in their somatosensory receptive fields
(Burrows and Siegler, 1984
), they all shared similar relative
sensitivities to different chemical qualities, being very sensitive to
low concentrations of NHT but much less sensitive to sucrose, with
other chemicals ranging in between. The duration of response, or mean
spike number, of spiking local interneurons depended on both chemical
identity and concentration. A neuron tested with an ascending
concentration series of a single chemical displays a clear
dose-dependent response. Conversely, for any single concentration, the
relative strength of response of a neuron to different chemicals is
highly dependent on the chemical presented (Fig.
11).

View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 11.
The response durations of spiking local
interneurons correspond closely with the behavioral effectiveness of
different chemical stimuli at different concentrations. The
filled symbols show the mean ± SEM response
durations (left ordinate) of spiking local interneurons to each of the
test chemical stimuli at different concentrations (abscissa). Data were
normalized so as to give the same mean response to water to minimize
the variability associated with the different phasotonic response
characteristics of individual neurons (Fig. 2). The behavioral
effectiveness (right ordinate), as measured by the frequency of locusts
withdrawing their legs from droplets of chemical stimuli at different
concentrations, are shown by the open symbols (mean ± SEM) (data from Rogers and Newland, 2000 ). There is a Pearson
correlation of 0.91 (p < 0.001;
n = 14) between behavioral effectiveness and
duration of interneuron response.
|
|
Locust chemosensory afferents appear to lack a strict segregation into
distinct classes of chemical sensitivity (Blaney, 1975
; White and
Chapman, 1990
; Chapman et al., 1991
) and show responses typical of
vertebrate gustatory fibers (Sato and Beidler, 1997
) by each responding
to several different chemicals, but in common with other insects, there
is some variation in the range of sensitivity between different sensory
neurons (Dethier 1976
; Schoonhoven et al., 1992
). As many different
afferents converge onto specific interneurons, however (Burrows and
Newland, 1994
; Newland and Burrows, 1994
), it is not surprising that
there appears to be little stimulus specificity at the central level.
Furthermore, our previous anatomical studies have shown that
chemosensory and mechanosensory afferents from basiconic sensilla on a
specific region of the leg all project to the same region of neuropil, to which exteroceptive afferents from tactile hairs also project (Newland, 1991
), with no visible anatomical segregation of afferent projections that could be related to either different modalities or
chemical sensitivities (Newland et al., 2000
). A similar convergence of
different modalities is also evident in the taste pathways of
vertebrates, with some taste-sensitive neurons also responding to
tactile and temperature stimuli (Roper, 1989
; Smith and Frank, 1993
;
Barry, 1999
; Cruz and Green, 2000
).
Spiking local interneurons are broadly tuned to many different chemical
stimuli in a manner consistent with across-fiber pattern coding. Rodent
peripheral taste fibers that converge on brainstem neurons in the NST
are similarly broadly tuned and lack a high degree of stimulus
specificity (Smith and Travers, 1979
; Smith and St John, 1999
).
According to our data, however, there appears to be little evidence for
variation in sensitivity range between interneurons in the population
from which chemical identity could be extracted elsewhere in the CNS, a
key tenet of the cross-fiber patterning hypothesis (Pfaffmann, 1959
).
Conversely, if individual chemical identities were encoded in labeled
lines in the metathoracic ganglion, then we would expect to find
at least some different neuron types specific for particular chemicals.
All of the interneurons we encountered shared a similar broad response
profile, being least sensitive to sucrose but more sensitive to NHT and
NaCl. The seven interneurons we specifically tested with different
chemicals showed some small variability in responses, but none could be described as defining different types.
These results suggest that local circuits of the metathoracic ganglion
may not have separate chemosensory processing pathways for different
chemicals or classes of chemical. How then could this system, broadly
tuned but with all neurons apparently having the same range of
sensitivity, be used to make effective behavioral decisions about
chemicals in the environment? Clearly this kind of coding is
inconsistent with a system that is concerned with establishing chemical
identity, because a similar strength of response in an interneuron can
be evoked by a weak solution of NaCl or a strong solution of sucrose.
Instead, our results suggest that the duration of response to different
chemicals provides a direct measure of a perceived quality, that of
aversiveness, because the relative size of the neuronal response of
spiking local interneurons and motor neurons correlates strongly with behavioral withdrawal responses (Fig. 11). Our previous experiments (Rogers and Newland, 2000
) have shown that different chemicals become
aversive at different concentrations, and that behavioral aversiveness
is a function of both chemical identity and chemical concentration,
both of which are key determinants of the size of the response in
spiking local interneurons and motor neurons. Particular strengths of a
neural response correspond closely with the likelihood of a locust
withdrawing its leg from a chemical solution. Thus, there is a very
close correspondence between behavior and neural response (Pearson
correlation, 0.91; p < 0.001; n = 14).
It does not appear that local circuits of the locust identify particular chemicals, assign behavioral significance to them, and then
cue an appropriate response. They do, however, mediate motor responses
that differentiate between acceptable and unacceptable, and a neural
representation of this appears fully apparent at an early synaptic
stage of chemosensory integration. An advantage of this model system is
that the distance between sensory input and motor output is relatively
small, and hence, it is easier to appreciate the link between behavior
and neural response. Similar observations have been made recently in
vertebrates. For example, studies on the amygdala of rats suggest that
neural responses are not linked with stimulus identity but instead
correlate well with the perceived quality of palatability of a
gustatory stimulus (Scott and Giza, 2000
).
It is readily understandable why locusts should be highly sensitive to
and withdraw their legs from the toxic secondary plant compound NHT,
but their aversion to high concentrations of nutrient chemicals is also
consistent with recent models of the role of taste in dietary
regulation in locusts and other animals (Simpson and Raubenheimer,
1996
, 2000
). These animals do not have an open-ended appetitive desire
for nutrient chemicals, but instead, nutrients have to be consumed in
the correct quantities and relative proportions to achieve a balanced
diet. Under most circumstances, therefore, highly concentrated sources
of single nutrients are not only less desirable than more balanced
blends of different nutrients but may also be actively rejected at the
gustatory sampling stage of feeding (or contact) depending on current
nutritional requirements. This lack of desirability, regardless of
whether it is elicited by a low concentration of NHT or a high
concentration of sucrose, is reflected in the size of the neural
response, which in turn correlates with a high probability of leg
withdrawal. For the locust, similar gustatory neural responses evoke
similar behaviors. Recently, a model with similar features has been
developed for taste processing in vertebrates, in which interactions
between the basic taste qualities provide overarching measures of just two opposing qualities, nutritional suitability or toxicity (Scott and
Giza, 2000
; Scott and Verhagen, 2000
). Our results provide a striking
corollary of this food selection process, but for the insect, the main
criterion is rejection (leg withdrawal) rather than acceptance, with
the consequence that high concentrations of single nutrients presented
to the leg evoke large neural responses that cue withdrawal movements.
Although only a single perceived quality, aversiveness, appears to be
encoded in the metathoracic ganglion, in principle, a number of other
qualities could be simultaneously encoded within a given population of
neurons in other organisms. The detailed processing of gustatory
information may be different in insects and vertebrates, although the
gustatory problems all animals have to solve are similar. Even among
vertebrates, however, gustatory processing varies. For example, the
processing of amino acids in fish appears to be completely different
from the suggested umami taste of mammals (Lindemann, 1996
; Ogawa and
Caprio, 1999
). Our results highlight the importance of knowledge of the
final output of a network, behavior, to understanding the function and utility of gustatory information. Smith and St John (1999)
point out
that it is not sufficient to extrapolate ideas about central coding
from information gained only from the receptor cells, because synaptic
processing throughout the gustatory pathway shapes and modifies
gustatory signals. We believe that the system described here could
provide the basis for a relatively tractable model system in which to
go further and understand how gustatory signals are modified centrally
in response to specific nutritional requirements or states.
 |
FOOTNOTES |
Received April 25, 2002; revised June 26, 2002; accepted July 8, 2002.
This work was supported by an Advanced Fellowship from the
Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (Swindon, UK) (P.L.N.). We thank Dr. Hans Schuppe for numerous discussions about this work and Tom Matheson, David Parker, and Hans Schuppe for
their helpful comments on this manuscript.
Correspondence should be addressed to P. L. Newland, Centre for
Neuroscience, School of Biological Sciences, Biomedical Sciences Building, University of Southampton, Bassett Crescent East, Southampton SO16 7PX, UK. E-mail: pln{at}soton.ac.uk.
S. M. Rogers' present address: Department of Zoology, University
of Cambridge, Downing Street, Cambridge CB2 3EJ, UK.
 |
REFERENCES |
-
Barry MA
(1999)
Recovery of functional response in the nucleus of the solitary tract after peripheral gustatory nerve crush and regeneration.
J Neurophysiol
82:237-247[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Blaney WM
(1975)
Behavioural and electrophysiological studies of taste discrimination by the maxillary palps of larvae of Locusta migratoria (L).
J Exp Biol
62:555-569[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Burrows M
(1985)
The processing of mechanosensory information by spiking local interneurons in the locust.
J Neurophysiol
54:463-478[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Burrows M
(1996)
In: The neurobiology of an insect brain. Oxford: Oxford UP.
-
Burrows M,
Newland PL
(1994)
Convergence of mechanosensory afferents from different classes of exteroceptors onto spiking local interneurons in the locust.
J Neurosci
14:3341-3350[Abstract].
-
Burrows M,
Siegler MVS
(1984)
The morphological diversity and receptive fields of spiking local interneurones in the locust metathoracic ganglion.
J Comp Neurol
224:483-508[ISI][Medline].
-
Burrows M,
Watson AHD,
Brunn DE
(1989)
Physiological and ultrastructural characterization of a central synaptic connection between identified motor neurons in the locust.
Eur J Neurosci
1:111-126[ISI][Medline].
-
Chapman RF
(1982)
Chemoreception: the significance of receptor numbers.
Adv Insect Physiol
16:247-333.
-
Chapman RF
(1995)
Chemosensory regulation of feeding.
In: Regulatory mechanisms in insect feeding (Chapman RF,
De Boer G,
eds), pp 101-136. New York: Chapman and Hall.
-
Chapman RF,
Ascoli-Christensen A,
White PR
(1991)
Sensory coding for feeding deterrence in the grasshopper Schistocerca americana.
J Exp Biol
158:241-259[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Cruz A,
Green BG
(2000)
Thermal stimulation of taste.
Nature
403:889-892[Medline].
-
Dethier VG
(1976)
In: The hungry fly. Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP.
-
Lindemann B
(1996)
Taste reception.
Physiol Rev
76:718-766[Medline].
-
Newland PL
(1991)
Morphology and somatotopic organization of the central projections of afferents from tactile hairs on the hind leg of the locust.
J Comp Neurol
311:1-16[ISI][Medline].
-
Newland PL
(1998)
Avoidance reflexes mediated by contact chemoreceptors on the legs of locusts.
J Comp Physiol [A]
183:313-324.
-
Newland PL
(1999)
Processing of gustatory information by spiking local interneurones in the locust.
J Neurophysiol
82:3149-3159[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Newland PL,
Burrows M
(1994)
Processing of mechanosensory information from gustatory receptors on a hind leg of the locust.
J Comp Physiol [A]
174:399-410[Medline].
-
Newland PL,
Rogers SM,
Gaaboub I,
Matheson T
(2000)
Parallel somatotopic maps of gustatory and mechanosensory neurons in the central nervous system of an insect.
J Comp Neurol
425:82-96[ISI][Medline].
-
Ogawa K,
Caprio J
(1999)
Facial taste responses of the channel catfish to binary mixtures of amino acids.
J Neurophysiol
82:564-569[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Pfaffmann C
(1959)
The afferent code for sensory quality.
Am Psychol
14:226-232.
-
Pfaffmann C
(1974)
Specificity of the sweet receptors of the squirrel monkey.
Chem Sens Flav
1:62-67.
-
Pfaffmann C,
Frank M,
Bartoshuk LM,
Snell TC
(1976)
Coding gustatory information in the squirrel monkey chorda tympani.
In: Progress in psychobiology and physiological psychology, Vol 6 (Sprague JM,
Epstein AN,
eds), pp 1-27. New York: Academic.
-
Rogers SM,
Newland PL
(2000)
Local movements evoked by chemical stimulation of the hind leg in the locust Schistocerca gregaria.
J Exp Biol
203:423-433[Abstract].
-
Roper SD
(1989)
The cell biology of vertebrate taste receptors.
Annu Rev Neurosci
12:329-353[ISI][Medline].
-
Sato T,
Beidler LM
(1997)
Broad tuning of rat taste cells for four basic taste stimuli.
Chem Senses
22:287-293[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Schoonhoven LM,
Blaney WM,
Simmonds MSJ
(1992)
Sensory coding of feeding deterrents in phytophagous insects.
In: Insect-plant interactions, Vol 4 (Bernays EA,
ed), pp 59-79. Boca Raton, FL: CRC.
-
Scott TR,
Giza BK
(2000)
Issues of neural coding: where they stand today.
Physiol Behav
69:65-76[Medline].
-
Scott TR,
Verhagen JV
(2000)
Taste as a factor in the management of nutrition.
Nutrition
16:874-885[ISI][Medline].
-
Siegler MVS,
Burrows M
(1983)
Spiking local interneurons as primary integrators of mechanosensory information in the locust.
J Neurophysiol
50:1281-1295[Abstract/Free Full Text].
-
Simpson SJ
(1994)
Experimental support for a model in which innate taste responses contribute to regulation of salt intake by nymphs of Locusta migratoria.
J Insect Physiol
40:555-559.
-
Simpson SJ,
Raubenheimer D
(1993)
A multi-level analysis of feeding behaviour: the geometry of nutritional decisions.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci
342:381-402.
-
Simpson SJ,
Raubenheimer D
(1996)
Feeding behaviour, sensory physiology and nutrient feedback: a unifying model.
Entomol Exp Appl
80:55-64.
-
Simpson SJ,
Raubenheimer D
(2000)
The hungry locust.
Adv Study Behav
29:1-43.
-
Smith DV,
Frank ME
(1993)
Sensory coding by peripheral fibres.
In: Mechanisms of taste transduction (Simon SA,
Roper SD,
eds), pp 295-338. Boca Raton, FL: CRC.
-
Smith DV,
St John SJ
(1999)
Neural coding of gustatory information.
Curr Opin Neurobiol
9:427-435[ISI][Medline].
-
Smith DV,
Travers JB
(1979)
A metric for the breadth of tuning of gustatory neurons.
Chem Sens Flav
4:215-229.
-
Smith DV,
St John SJ,
Boughter Jr JD
(2000)
Neuronal cell types and taste quality coding.
Physiol Behav
68:77-85.
-
Spector AC
(2000)
Linking gustatory neurobiology to behaviour in vertebrates.
Neurosci Biobehav Rev
24:391-416[ISI][Medline].
-
White PR,
Chapman RF
(1990)
Tarsal chemoreception in the polyphagous grasshopper Schistocerca americana: behavioural assays, sensilla distributions and electrophysiology.
Physiol Entomol
15:105-121.
Copyright © 2002 Society for Neuroscience 0270-6474/02/22188324-10$05.00/0
This article has been cited by other articles:

|
 |

|
 |
 
P. L. Newland and P. Yates
Nitric Oxide Modulates Salt and Sugar Responses via Different Signaling Pathways
Chem Senses,
April 1, 2008;
33(4):
347 - 356.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|

|
 |

|
 |
 
S. M. Rogers, T. Matheson, E. Despland, T. Dodgson, M. Burrows, and S. J. Simpson
Mechanosensory-induced behavioural gregarization in the desert locust Schistocerca gregaria
J. Exp. Biol.,
November 15, 2003;
206(22):
3991 - 4002.
[Abstract]
[Full Text]
[PDF]
|
 |
|