Volume 17, Number 12,
Issue of June 15, 1997
pp. 4904-4913
Copyright ©1997 Society for Neuroscience
Time Course of Cortical Activations in Implicit and Explicit
Recall
Received Oct. 17, 1996; revised April 3, 1997; accepted April 8, 1997.
Rajendra D. Badgaiyan and
Michael I. Posner
Institute of Cognitive and Decision Sciences, University of Oregon,
Eugene, Oregon 97403
The distinction between implicit and explicit retrieval of learned
material is central to recent thinking about the neural systems
underlying memory. Word stem completion is one task in which subjects
can be instructed either to make a deliberate recall (explicit
instruction) or to be told to complete the stem with any appropriate
word (implicit instruction). Positron emission tomography (PET) studies
have indicated that during implicit retrieval, there is reduced blood
flow in right posterior areas, whereas some tasks of explicit retrieval
involve frontal and hippocampal activation. However, there is no
information about the timing of these activations or how implicit and
explicit retrieval might be related.
We used word stem completion tasks similar to those used in the PET
studies, but used high-density electrical recording designed to allow
localization of the regions involved in the tasks and to provide
temporal information. We found reduced activity for primed words in
right posterior cortex corresponding to previous PET results. The
reduction occurred within the first 200 msec after input, suggesting
early interaction with the information stored in this area. Similar
reductions observed during explicit recall of the previously presented
words indicate that priming is similar under implicit and explicit
conditions. In addition, when priming was not an adequate basis for
response, then frontal areas were active. Retrieval of unprimed words
under implicit instruction elicited right frontal activation, whereas
explicit retrieval activated frontal areas bilaterally. Left frontal
and hippocampal activations appear to occur only when the retrieval involved use of the words from the list studied previously.
Key words:
priming;
word stem completion;
implicit memory;
explicit
memory;
hippocampus;
frontal cortex;
parietal cortex;
temporal
cortex