Consciousness and epilepsy: why are complex-partial seizures complex?
Introduction
Consciousness has been an exceeding difficult concept to define for researchers, clinicians, and philosophers alike. This is likely because consciousness is a complex phenomenon which encompasses various different processes. Plum and Posner (1980) have suggested that it is important to distinguish between the level of consciousness and the content of consciousness. The content of consciousness can be described as the substrate on which consciousness acts, and is composed of all other neural systems hierarchically organized into parallel sensory and motor systems that receive inputs, generate outputs, and perform internal processing on multiple levels (Blumenfeld, 2002). In turn, the level of consciousness also has multiple components, which can be summarized as the maintenance of three distinct but related processes: (i) the awake, alert state; (ii) attention; and (iii) awareness of self and environment (Blumenfeld (2002), Blumenfeld (2009)). To study the neurobiological mechanisms of the awake, alert state necessary for consciousness, previous investigators have utilized various models such as sleep, coma, deep anesthesia, brain lesions, and epilepsy.
Generalized seizure disorders in humans, such as absence (petite mal) and tonic-clonic (grand mal) epilepsy, involve a pathological pattern of synchronous neuronal discharges in extensive networks throughout the brain, resulting in a loss of consciousness (Blumenfeld, 2005). Absence seizures are a form of generalized epilepsy in children characterized by rhythmic 3–4 Hz “spike-wave” discharges on electroencephalogram (EEG) produced by pathophysiological corticothalamic interactions (Avoli and Gloor, 1982; Blumenfeld and McCormick, 2000). These events are associated with brief 5–10 s episodes of unresponsiveness that have significant effects on a child's attentional abilities both during and between events (Levav et al., 2002; Mirsky and Van Buren, 1965). Conversely, generalized tonic-clonic seizures are characterized by fast excitatory discharges synchronously affecting neuronal networks in numerous brain regions, producing several minutes of unconsciousness and abnormal convulsive activity of widespread muscle groups (Blumenfeld et al., 2009; Morrell, 1993; Zifkin and Dravet, 2007).
It is perhaps not surprising that generalized seizures, involving extensive dysfunction of cortical and subcortical brain regions, cause significant impairments of consciousness. In temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), however, seizures often originate from focal structures within the mesial temporal lobe, and frequently do not secondarily generalize or propagate to distal cortical areas. Yet, despite confinement of epileptic discharges to the temporal lobe and related limbic structures, seizures in TLE often cause a loss of consciousness. Understanding the mechanisms of impaired consciousness and cortical dysfunction during temporal lobe seizures has important clinical implications, as impaired consciousness causes motor vehicle accidents, drownings, poor work and school performance, and social stigmatization resulting in a major negative impact on patient quality of life (Drazkowski, 2007; Jacoby et al., 2005; Kobau et al., 2008; Sperling, 2004). In addition, previous investigations of TLE patients have found neocortical deficits including gray matter atrophy (Bonilha et al., 2006) and hypometabolism between seizures (Diehl et al., 2003; Nelissen et al., 2006), which may be related to neuropsychological sequelae and chronic cognitive impairments frequently suffered by these individuals (Helmstaedter and Kockelmann, 2006; Hermann et al., 1997; Laurent and Arzimanoglou, 2006). An appreciation of the long-range network effects of temporal lobe seizures on the neocortex may lead to a better grasp of epileptic mechanisms and a further understanding of the brain region interactions that underlie the conscious state. In this review, we will summarize previous investigations of TLE in humans and animal models, discuss what they suggest about the mechanisms of impaired consciousness during temporal lobe seizures, and advocate directions to further our understanding of this important problem.
Section snippets
The network inhibition hypothesis in TLE
Epilepsy is a debilitating neurological disorder that affects approximately 1% of the population in developed countries such as the United States (Devinsky, 2004). TLE is one of the most common epileptic disorders, characterized by seizures that frequently originate in limbic structures of the medial temporal lobe, such as the hippocampus and the amygdala (Engel, 1987; Williamson et al., 1993). As the temporal lobe is the most common site of origin of focal epileptic discharges, it has been
Behavioral semiology of temporal lobe seizures
While simple-partial temporal lobe seizures are frequently characterized by autonomic and/or psychic symptoms and epigastric sensations, complex-partial seizures of the temporal lobe often begin with an inhibition of purposeful motor activity and elicitation of automatic behavioral manifestations that are associated with unresponsiveness (ILAE, 1989). These automaton-like behaviors, termed “automatisms,” are typically manifested as repetitive orofacial movements such as lip-smacking, chewing,
EEG correlates of impaired consciousness in human TLE
Limbic seizures originate from mesial temporal structures on either the left or right side of the brain. Lateralization of behavioral signs such as automatisms can provide insight into the side of seizure onset, albeit with some inconsistency (Saint-Hilaire and Lee, 2000). It has also been proposed that lateralization or bilaterality of temporal lobe seizures may be the predominant feature predicting either loss or preservation of consciousness ictally. Some have hypothesized that the left
Neuroimaging insights into impaired consciousness in human TLE
Why do complex-partial temporal lobe seizures cause unconsciousness even though EEG recordings typically show seizure activity confined to temporal cortex? As discussed previously, partial seizures in TLE often cause other functional deficits beyond those expected from local limbic impairment, such as repetitive automaton-like movements (Loddenkemper and Kotagal, 2005), dystonic posturing of the limbs (Marks and Laxer, 1998), and neuroendocrine changes (Bauer, 2001; Quigg et al., 2002). It has
Network effects of temporal lobe seizures in animal models
While human studies of neurological disease possess the greatest validity, animal models of TLE activity allow controlled mechanistic studies which can be valuable in understanding both network effects and behavioral manifestations associated with complex-partial seizures. Behavioral correlates of electrographic temporal lobe seizures have been extensively studied in rodent models of TLE. For instance, the classic scale created by Ronald Racine (1972) allows investigators to rate behavioral
The network inhibition hypothesis revisited
As proposed in our network inhibition hypothesis (Fig. 1), it is possible that ictal aberration of normal activity in subcortical arousal systems may contribute to unconsciousness during complex-partial temporal lobe seizures. Some attention has been directed toward the importance of thalamocortical interactions in this phenomenon, but the intense lateral septal involvement during partial limbic seizures in rats has led us to also consider a possible role for the septum in eliciting ictal
Future directions
The human and animal studies of TLE summarized here provide characterization and preliminary insight into the mechanistic underpinnings of impaired consciousness and ictal neocortical slow rhythms during complex-partial temporal lobe seizures. However, much remains unknown about how focal seizure activity in the temporal lobe leads to a loss of consciousness ictally, and additional investigations — including studies in animal models within which mechanistic interventions are feasible — are
Conclusions: the consciousness system and TLE
In the mid-20th century, Wilder Penfield and Herbert Jasper hypothesized that the brainstem and diencephalon play critical roles in integrating brain activity across both cerebral hemispheres (Jasper, 1991; Penfield, 1958). It was observed that most epileptic patients suffered little to no impairment of consciousness after wide resection of cerebral cortical structures or the corpus callosum, although applying pressure to the brainstem resulted in immediate and reversible loss of consciousness (
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by NIH R01 NS049307 (HB) and F30 NS59074 (DJE), a Donaghue Foundation Investigator Award (HB), and by the Betsy and Jonathan Blattmachr family.
References (179)
- et al.
Anatomical origins of the classical receptive field and modulatory surround field of single neurons in macaque visual cortical area V1
Progress in Brain Research
(2002) - et al.
Pathology and pathophysiology of the amygdala in epileptogenesis and epilepsy
Epilepsy Research
(2008) - et al.
Interaction of cortex and thalamus in spike and wave discharges of feline generalized penicillin epilepsy
Experimental Neurology
(1982) Propagation of human complex-partial seizures: A correlation analysis
Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology
(1991)- et al.
Extrinsic and intrinsic properties underlying oscillation and synchrony in limbic cortex
Progress in Neurobiology
(1993) - et al.
Anatomical mapping of brain stimulation reward sites in the anterior hypothalamic area: Special attention to the stria medullaris
Brain Research
(1989) - et al.
Gray matter atrophy associated with duration of temporal lobe epilepsy
NeuroImage
(2006) Peri-ictal behavioral and cognitive changes
Epilepsy and Behavior
(2002)- et al.
Septal lesions impair the acquisition of a cued place navigation task: Attentional or memory deficit?
Neurobiology of Learning and Memory
(1998) - et al.
Hippocampal-orbitofrontal connectivity in human: An electrical stimulation study
Clinical Neurophysiology
(2005)
Unilateral thalamic hypometabolism in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy
Journal of the Formosan Medical Association
Influence of lateral septum and amygdala stimulation on the excitability of hypothalamic supraoptic neurons. An electrophysiological study in the rat
Brain Research
Use of cortical circuits during focal penicillin seizures: An autoradiographic study with [14C]deoxyglucose
Brain Research
New facets of the neuropathology and molecular profile of human temporal lobe epilepsy
Epilepsy and Behavior
Excitotoxic lesions of the pedunculopontine tegmental nucleus of the rat. II. Examination of eating and drinking, rotation, and reaching and grasping following unilateral ibotenate or quinolinate lesions
Brain Research
Lateralization of temporal lobe foci: Depth versus subdural electrodes
Clinical Neurophysiology
Analysis of mesial temporal seizure onset and propagation using the directed transfer function method
Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology
Thalamic diffusion and volumetry in temporal lobe epilepsy with and without mesial temporal sclerosis
Epilepsy Research
Lateralizing value of behavioral arrest in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy
Epilepsy and Behavior
Epilepsy and social identity: The stigma of a chronic neurological disorder
Lancet Neurology
Current evaluation of the concepts of centrencephalic and cortico-reticular seizures
Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology
Ictal oroalimentary automatisms with preserved consciousness: Implications for the pathophysiology of automatisms and relevance to the international classification of seizures
Epilepsia
Cerebral dominance for consciousness
Archives of Neurology
SPECT in the presurgical evaluation of patients with temporal lobe epilepsy — A preliminary report
Acta Neurochirurgica Supplementum
Partial cognitive seizures
Neuropsychiatry, Neuropsychology, and Behavioral Neurology
Impaired consciousness during temporal lobe seizures is related to increased long-distance cortical-subcortical synchronization
Brain
Pathological findings in epilepsy
Projections of neurons of the hypothalamic locomotor region to brain stem and spinal cord structures in the cat
Neirofiziologiia
Anatomical origin of deja vu and vivid ‘memories’ in human temporal lobe epilepsy
Brain
Spontaneous epileptic rats show changes in sleep architecture and hypothalamic pathology
Epilepsia
Interactions between hormones and epilepsy in female patients
Epilepsia
Enhancement of behavioral and electroencephalographic indices of waking following stimulation of noradrenergic beta-receptors within the medial septal region of the basal forebrain
Journal of Neuroscience
The midline thalamus: Alterations and a potential role in limbic epilepsy
Epilepsia
Multiple roles of midline dorsal thalamic nuclei in induction and spread of limbic seizures
Epilepsia
Extrinsic modulation of medial septal cell discharges by the ascending brainstem hippocampal synchronizing pathway
Hippocampus
Patient awareness of seizures
Neurology
Neuroanatomy through clinical cases
Consciousness and epilepsy: Why are patients with absence seizures absent?
Progress in Brain Research
Epilepsy and consciousness
Corticothalamic inputs control the pattern of activity generated in thalamocortical networks
The Journal of Neuroscience
Positive and negative network correlations in temporal lobe epilepsy
Cerebral Cortex
Ictal neocortical slowing in temporal lobe epilepsy
Neurology
Neocortical and thalamic spread of amygdala kindled seizures
Epilepsia
Why do seizures cause loss of consciousness?
The Neuroscientist
Cortical and subcortical networks in human secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures
Brain
Single-photon tomographic determination of regional cerebral blood flow in epilepsy
American Journal of Neuroradiology
Behaviour-related effects of nicotine on slow EEG waves in basal nucleus-lesioned rats
Naunyn-Schmiedeberg's Archives of Pharmacology
Spatial gradients and inhibitory summation in the rat whisker barrel system
Journal of Neurophysiology
Nucleus basalis and thalamic control of neocortical activity in the freely moving rat
The Journal of Neuroscience
Anatomy and pathology of the septal region
Neuroimaging Clinics of North America
Cited by (94)
Molecular mechanisms of sex differences in epilepsy
2023, Principles of Gender-Specific Medicine: Sex and Gender-Specific Biology in the Postgenomic EraFocal seizures producing loss of wakefulness without ictal asystole: Does temporal lobe syncope exist?
2022, Epilepsy ResearchCitation Excerpt :There are possible functional mechanisms underlying alteration of wakefulness during a focal seizure. Indeed, focal seizures, especially of temporal lobe origin, are likely to cause an alteration of the arousal system, which could lead to a drop in vigilance during seizures (Englot et al., 2017; Englot and Blumenfeld, 2009; González et al., 2019). This mechanism, proposed as contributing to the impairment of awareness, may ultimately be more involved in a wakefulness disorder.
Spectral and network characterization of focal seizure types and phases
2022, Computer Methods and Programs in BiomedicineMethodological aspects of studying the mechanisms of consciousness
2022, Behavioural Brain Research