Neural representations during sleep: From sensory processing to memory traces
Introduction
Although the concept of representation has been questioned, in particular by cognitive psychologists (O’Regan & Noe, 2001) and neurophilosophers (Maturana and Varela, 1987, Thompson and Varela, 2001), in the field of neurosciences the notion of neural representation has become so popular over the last thirty years that it has now come into common use (see reviews by Andersen et al., 1997, Knudsen and Brainard, 1995, Logothetis, 1998, Maunsell, 1995, Phillips, 1993, Roland and Gulyas, 1994, Singer, 1998). This is not surprizing: albeit may be naive, it is traditionally considered that brain’s function is to integrate features of the external world and to build internal representations so as to generate a “model” of the world enabling complex sensory–motor interactions and cognitive functions. However, the notion of neural representation is not univocal. From one article to another, there is a very large diversity in the level and complexity of what is represented, as well as in the type of neural code supposed to underlie the neural representations. Beyond the classical topographic representations of the sensory epithelium described at the cortical (Cowey and Ellis, 1969, Kaas et al., 1979, Merzenich et al., 1975) and subcortical (Covey and Casseday, 1986, Malpeli and Baker, 1975, Merzenich and Reid, 1974) levels, neural representation ranges from simply a neuronal signal that has a content and performs a function (deCharms & Zador, 2000), to a response pattern obtained over a cortical area at presentation of a natural stimulus (Wang, Merzenich, Beitel, & Schreiner, 1995), and to widely distributed neuronal assemblies whose firing rate is synchronized across various brain areas in the millisecond scale (Engel, Fries, & Singer, 2001). The smallest common denominator to all these views is the idea that a neural representation contains information. The questions addressed in the present paper are thus: Do neuronal signals emitted during sleep carry information? Have they a content? Have they any functional relevance?
Addressing these questions may surprise given that loss of consciousness, loss of sensory awareness, and unresponsiveness to stimuli from the external world are among the major features defining sleep. However, sleep does not bring a little death. The neuroscience community no longer conceives of the sleeping brain as simply dormant, fully disconnected from the environment and completely quiescent. In particular, the relations between sleep and cognition have attracted considerable interest in the last decade, as attested by the recent spate of publications on that topic. In the field of sleep and cognition, now called “the cognitive neuroscience of sleep” (Hobson & Pace-Schott, 2002), it is explicitly or implicitly assumed that neural representations can be activated or can be spontaneously active and eventually modified during sleep. The present review presents some aspects of that literature, posing as many questions as it answers. Starting with the issue of sensory representations in the first two sections, we will progress by evaluating whether learned representations are accessible and can be expressed during sleep, to finally address, in the last section, the question of the dynamics of memory representations during sleep. Despite partial overlaps, the review does not cover the fields of “information processing during sleep” (see Atienza et al., 2001, Bonnet, 1982, Coenen and Drinkenburg, 2002), nor that of “sleep and memory” (see Maquet, Smith, & Stickgold, 2003b, as well as Gais and Born, 2004a, Rauchs et al., 2005, Walker and Stickgold, 2006). Lastly, though dreaming is the clearest evidence of the activation of internal representations during sleep, the special field of “dreams” is not tackled at all. Dreaming has long been the object of a neurobiological approach (Hobson & McCarley, 1977), but linking the subjective mental experiences of dreams with any neural representation is a challenge that is far from being achieved, if ever (see Fagioli, 2002, Hobson et al., 2000, Nielsen, 2000, Nielsen, 2004, Revonsuo, 2000, Schwartz and Maquet, 2002, Solms, 2000).
Classically, two states of sleep are distinguished, paradoxical sleep (PS; also known as rapid-eye movement sleep or REM sleep) and slow-wave sleep (SWS; also referred to as non-REM sleep). In animals, the terms SWS and non-REM sleep are synonymous, and the former is generally used. In humans, the two terms are not synonymous; non-REM sleep is subdivided into a continuum of four stages reflecting the depth of sleep: sleep onset period (stage 1), light sleep (stage 2), and SWS (stages 3 and 4). Because many of the reported data are from animal studies, the term SWS is used here in its more global acceptance (i.e., the whole non-REM sleep).
Contrary to waking and PS which are both associated with fast rhythms of brain electrical activity, SWS is characterized by large-amplitude, low-frequency (<15 Hz) oscillations reflecting a massive synchronization of neuronal activities in thalamocortical networks. Spindles, delta waves, and slow oscillation are the three brain rhythms defining SWS. The neuronal patterns prevailing in thalamocortical systems, a burst-silence mode during SWS versus a sustained single-spike activity during waking and PS, are under the control of generalized modulatory systems originating in the brainstem, the hypothalamus, and the basal forebrain (review in Jones, 2005, Pace-Schott and Hobson, 2002, Steriade, 2003, Steriade and McCarley, 1990). But none of the natural states of vigilance is uniform. It is well known that within the waking state, the level of arousal modulates sensory responses (e.g., Foote et al., 1991, Hubel et al., 1959, Morrow and Casey, 1992), and that attentional processes strongly influence sensory processing, either facilitating responses to target stimuli or suppressing responses to non-target stimuli (review in Desimone & Duncan, 1995). Qualitatively different epochs, and thereby differences in sensory processing, also exist within a given sleep state. This is the case of the epochs with or without ocular saccades in PS (e.g., Baust et al., 1964, Cairns et al., 2003). This is also the case of the depolarizing and hyperpolarizing phases of the slow oscillation in SWS (Massimini, Rosanova, & Mariotti, 2003). Indeed, during SWS, the membrane potential of cortical neurons oscillates between depolarized and hyperpolarized levels with a periodicity of about 1 s. This cyclic alternation is reflected in the electroencephalogram (EEG) by a slow (<1 Hz) oscillation: cortical neurons are depolarized and fire spikes during depth-negative EEG waves, while they are hyperpolarized during depth-positive EEG waves (Steriade et al., 2000, Timofeev et al., 2001). Lastly, some factors independent of the sleep process per se modulate sensory processing during sleep: to take only one example in human, differences in stimulus processing were observed between the first and second part of the night for the same sleep stage (Plihal, Weaver, Mölle, Fehm, & Born, 1996).
Section snippets
Sensory representations during sleep: Neuronal activity in sleeping animals
From which literature can it be inferred that sensory representations are or are not maintained during sleep? If we except the animal studies which, in the 1960s, examined how evoked potentials along sensory pathways varied with the sleep-wake states (for review of that literature, see Coenen, 1995, Hall and Borbély, 1970, Velluti, 1997; see also Meeren, van Cappellen van Walsum, van Luijtelaar, & Coenen, 2001), two sets of data are available: single unit electrophysiological recordings in
Sensory integration during sleep: Event-related brain potentials and functional neuroimaging in sleeping humans
Event-related brain potentials (ERPs) have been widely used to assess the extent of information processing during sleep in humans. We only present a small facet of that literature; for a more complete vision, see the following reviews (Atienza et al., 2001, Atienza et al., 2002, Bastuji and García-Larrea, 1999, Bastuji et al., 2002, Campbell et al., 1992, Cote, 2002).
In general, the earlier the component of the evoked potentials, the more it is affected by the physical characteristics of the
Representation of significant stimuli: Expression during sleep of learning-induced neuronal plasticity
The ability of sleeping subjects to discriminate between relevant and irrelevant auditory stimuli is general knowledge, based on numerous anecdotal observations and experimental evidence (review in Bonnet, 1982). We are all familiar with such phenomena as mothers waking up to their baby’s cry but not to irrelevant sounds, even when louder. Sleeping mothers are even able to discriminate their own baby’s cry from the cries of other babies: on the first three postnatal nights at the hospital, 58%
Dynamics of memory representations during sleep
The idea that sleep has a beneficial effect on memory formation is not new (Heine, 1914, Jenkins and Dallenbach, 1924), and it has received strong experimental support from an important stream of research that started at the end of the 1960s (review in Bloch et al., 1979, Ekstrand et al., 1977, Fishbein and Gutwein, 1977, Hennevin and Leconte, 1977, McGrath and Cohen, 1978, Pearlman, 1979, Smith, 1985; for more recent reviews see Giuditta et al., 1995, Hennevin et al., 1995, Smith, 1995). At
Conclusions
From the single cell to human behavior, studies converged and their results agreed to support the notion that neural representations, or at least parts of neural representations, can be in an active form during sleep. First, environmental stimuli do penetrate the sleeping organism: Although impoverished, the messages sent by sensory neurons provide information about the external world which is accurate enough to allow detection of behaviorally relevant stimuli; event-related brain potentials in
References (345)
- et al.
Implicit oculomotor sequence learning in humans: time course of offline processing
Brain Research
(2006) - et al.
Influence of anesthesia on spontaneous activity and receptive field size of single units in rat Sm1 neocortex
Experimental Neurology
(1988) - et al.
Complex sound processing during human REM sleep by recovering information from long-term memory as revealed by the mismatch negativity (MMN)
Brain Research
(2001) - et al.
Mismatch negativity (MMN): an objective measure of sensory memory and long-lasting memories during sleep
International Journal of Psychophysiology
(2002) - et al.
Auditory information processing during human sleep as revealed by event-related brain potentials
Clinical Neurophysiology
(2001) - et al.
The mismatch negativity component reveals the sensory memory during REM sleep in humans
Neuroscience Letters
(1997) - et al.
Precise timing accounts for posttraining sleep-dependent enhancements of the auditory mismatch negativity
NeuroImage
(2005) - et al.
Classical conditioning induces CS-specific receptive field plasticity in the auditory cortex of the guinea pig
Brain Research
(1990) - et al.
Evoked potential components unique to non-REM sleep: Relationship to evoked K-complexes and vertex sharp waves
International Journal of Psychophysiology
(2002) - et al.
Evoked potentials as a tool for the investigation of human sleep
Sleep Medicine Reviews
(1999)
Semantic analysis of auditory input during sleep: studies with event-related potentials
International Journal of Psychophysiology
Reliability and information transmission in spiking neurons
Trends in Neurosciences
Synaptic plasticity in the hippocampus is modulated by behavioral state
Brain Research
Intracerebral event-related potentials to subthreshold target stimuli
Clinical Neurophysiology
Auditory event-related potentials to semantic priming during sleep
Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology
Gauging sensory representations in the brain
Trends in Neurosciences
Two-stage model of memory trace formation: a role for noisy brain states
Neuroscience
Is the amygdala a locus of conditioned fear? Some questions and caveats
Neuron
Eye movement-related modulation of trigeminal neuron activity during active sleep and wakefulness
Brain Research
A link between perceptual learning, adaptation and sleep
Vision Research
Neuronal activities underlying the electroencephalogram and evoked potentials of sleeping and waking: Implications for information processing
Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews
Animal models for information processing during sleep
International Journal of Psychophysiology
Probing awareness during sleep with the auditory odd-ball paradigm
International Journal of Psychophysiology
P300 to high intensity stimuli during REM sleep
Clinical Neurophysiology
The cortical representation of the retina in squirrel and rhesus monkeys and its relation to visual acuity
Experimental Neurology
Altered processing of acoustic stimuli during sleep: Reduced auditory activation and visual deactivation detected by a combined fMRI/EEG study
NeuroImage
Functional imaging of the sleeping brain: review of findings and implications for the study of insomnia
Sleep Medicine Reviews
Learning-induced physiological plasticity in the thalamo-cortical sensory systems: evaluation of receptive field plasticity, map changes and their potential mechanisms
Progress in Neurobiology
The effect of sleep on human long-term memory
Interfering with theories of sleep and memory: sleep, declarative memory, and associative interference
Current Biology
Mental activity during sleep
Sleep Medicine Reviews
Why we think plasticity underlying Pavlovian fear conditioning occurs in the basolateral amygdala
Neuron
Paradoxical sleep and memory storage processes
Behavioral Biology
Electrophysiological evidence for the involvement of the locus coeruleus in alerting, orienting, and attending
Progress in Brain Research
Spatiotemporal firing patterns in the frontal cortex of behaving monkeys
Journal of Neurophysiology
Detecting spatiotemporal firing patterns among simultaneously recorded single neurons
Journal of Neurophysiology
Dynamics of neuronal firing correlation: modulation of effective connectivity
Journal of Neurophysiology
Dependence of cortical plasticity on correlated activity of single neurons and on behavioral context
Science
Multimodal representation of space in the posterior parietal cortex and its use in planning movements
Annual Review of Neuroscience
A latent consolidation phase in auditory identification learning: time in the awake state is sufficient
Learning and Memory
Decay time of the auditory sensory memory trace during wakefulness and REM sleep
Psychophysiology
Posttraining sleep enhances automaticity in perceptual discrimination
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience
Brain processing of stimulus deviance during slow-wave and paradoxical sleep: a study of human auditory evoked responses using the oddball paradigm
Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology
Changes in the auditory input in wakefulness and during the synchronized and desynchronized stages of sleep
Archives Italiennes de Biologie
Discrimination and conditioning during sleep as indicated by the electroencephalogram
Science
Seuils d’excitabilité réticulaire et sommeil profond chez le chat
Journal de Physiologie (Paris)
Patterns of spontaneous unitary discharge in thalamic ventro-basal complex during wakefulness and sleep
Experimental Brain Research
Relationship between paradoxical sleep and memory processes
Performance during sleep
Information theory and neural coding
Nature Neuroscience
Cited by (94)
What is sleep exactly? Global and local modulations of sleep oscillations all around the clock
2023, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsSimple statistical regularities presented during sleep are detected but not retained
2022, NeuropsychologiaSleep and its regulation: An emerging pathogenic and treatment frontier in Alzheimer's disease
2021, Progress in NeurobiologyCitation Excerpt :However, there is only preliminary and conflicting evidence for acute effects of sleep on Aβ levels in humans. For symptomatic AD patients, sleep (and SWS in particular) is important to target with interventions in view of the extensive literature demonstrating the important role of sleep for attention, executive control, and declarative and non-declarative memory (Hennevin et al., 2007; McCoy and Strecker, 2011; Oudiette and Paller, 2013; Rasch and Born, 2013; Scullin and Bliwise, 2015), and that specific sleep stages are critical for hippocampal- and non-hippocampal-dependent memory functions and neuroplasticity (Havekes et al., 2016; Kent and Mistlberger, 2017; Kreutzmann et al., 2015). SWS disruption has even been proposed as a critical pathway by which Aβ disrupts hippocampal-dependent memory consolidation (Mander et al., 2015).
Dream engineering: Simulating worlds through sensory stimulation
2020, Consciousness and CognitionThe vigilant sleeper: neural mechanisms of sensory (de)coupling during sleep
2020, Current Opinion in Physiology