Previous studies indicated that Aplysia sensory neurons (SNs) compete when reestablishing synapses with a motor cell target (L7) in vitro. The competition is characterized by a cell number-dependent decrease in the efficacy of each connection, an increase in the elimination of SN varicosities, a reduction in the formation of new SN varicosities, and the segregation of varicosities of each SN to restricted portions of the target axons. The changes do not require spike activity, since both the SNs and L7 do not fire spontaneously. Here, we examined whether adding activity to SNs during the early stages of synapse formation with stimuli known to evoke facilitatory responses in stable SN-L7 connections--tetanic stimulation or increase in intracellular cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP)--would modulate the intrinsic segregatory process. Tetanic stimulation to one SN increased synapse efficacy and the number of varicosities of the stimulated SNs while reducing the functional changes by the nonstimulated SNs in the same cultures. An increase in the stability of preexisting varicosities contributed to the overall increase in varicosities evoked by tetanus. The functional changes evoked by tetanus were not expressed when the same tetanic stimulation was also given to the other SN, or when L7 was hyperpolarized during the tetanus to the SN. Raising cAMP levels in one SN increased synapse efficacy and the rate of new varicosity formation by the injected SNs without affecting the development of the connections formed by the noninjected SNs. These results suggest that different forms of presynaptic and postsynaptic activities in neurons can regulate specific aspects of the competitive process associated with the fine-tuning of connections formed by converging presynaptic inputs.