Abstract
Ventral tegmental area (VTA) neurons play roles in reward and aversion. The VTA has three major neuronal phenotypes: dopaminergic, GABAergic, and glutamatergic. VTA glutamatergic neurons—expressing vesicular glutamate transporter-2 (VGluT2)—project to limbic and cortical regions, but also excite neighboring dopaminergic neurons. Here, we test whether local photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons expressing Channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) under the VGluT2 promoter causes place preference and supports operant responding for the stimulation. By using a Cre-dependent viral vector, ChR2 (tethered to mCherry) was expressed in VTA glutamatergic neurons of VGluT2::Cre mice. The mCherry distribution was evaluated by immunolabeling. By confocal microscopy, we detected expression of mCherry in VTA cell bodies and local processes. In contrast, VGluT2 expression was restricted to varicosities, some of them coexpressing mCherry. By electron microscopy, we determined that mCherry-VGluT2 varicosities correspond to axon terminals, forming asymmetric synapses on neighboring dopaminergic neurons. These findings indicate that ChR2 was present in terminals containing glutamatergic synaptic vesicles and involved in local synaptic connections. Photoactivation of VTA slices from ChR2-expressing mice induced AMPA/NMDA receptor-dependent firing of dopaminergic neurons projecting to the nucleus accumbens. VTA photoactivation of ChR2-expressing mice reinforced instrumental behavior and established place preferences. VTA injections of AMPA or NMDA receptor antagonists blocked optical self-stimulation and place preference. These findings suggest a role in reward function for VTA glutamatergic neurons through local excitatory synapses on mesoaccumbens dopaminergic neurons.
SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT We show that previously discovered glutamatergic neurons within the ventral tegmental area (VTA), through their local connections, play a role in reward. The participation of VTA glutamatergic neurons in reward involves VTA glutamatergic neurons that establish local excitatory connections. These neurons concentrate the protein VGluT2 in their axon terminals to transport and accumulate glutamate into vesicles for its synaptic release. The VTA activation of these terminals is rewarding and involves local synaptic glutamate release, which in turn activates glutamatergic receptors in neighboring mesoaccumbens dopaminergic neurons.
Introduction
Subsets of ventral tegmental area (VTA) neurons are involved in motivated behaviors. Some of them participate in reward processing, and others participate in aversive processing. The behavioral involvement of VTA neurons appears to depend on their molecular phenotype and projection targets. Optogenetic studies have shown that local activation of VTA dopaminergic neurons (Tsai et al. 2009; Witten et al., 2011; Ilango et al., 2014) or their terminals within the nucleus accumbens (nAcc; Steinberg et al., 2014) is rewarding. In contrast, activation of VTA GABAergic neurons is aversive (Tan et al., 2012), whereas their inhibition is rewarding (Jennings et al., 2013). Yet, activation of GABAergic terminals within the nAcc results in enhanced learning without effects on reward or aversion (Brown et al., 2012).
In addition to dopaminergic and GABAergic neurons, the VTA contains glutamatergic neurons expressing vesicular glutamate transporter-2 (VGluT2; Kawano et al., 2006; Yamaguchi et al., 2007, 2011). VTA VGluT2 neurons form both local connections (Dobi et al., 2010) and long-range connections within the prefrontal cortex, nAcc, lateral habenula (LHb), amygdala, and basal forebrain (Yamaguchi et al., 2011; Hnasko et al., 2012; Root et al., 2014a; Taylor et al., 2014; Zhang et al., 2015). Axon terminals from VTA VGluT2 neurons establish asymmetric (putative excitatory) synapses within the VTA (Dobi et al., 2010), LHb (Root et al., 2014a), and nAcc (Zhang et al., 2015). Slice electrophysiology recordings have shown that glutamate release from these terminals evokes EPSCs on VTA dopaminergic and nondopaminergic neurons (Dobi et al., 2010), nAcc medium spiny neurons (Hnasko et al., 2012; Zhang et al., 2015), or LHb neurons (Root et al., 2014a).
Due to anatomical and electrophysiological studies showing an excitatory pathway from local VTA VGluT2 neurons to local VTA neurons, we suggested previously that VTA glutamatergic neurons are part of an anticipated (and unexplored) local VTA microcircuitry (Dobi et al., 2010; Morales and Pickel, 2012). Here, we used a multidisciplinary approach to determine whether activation of VTA VGluT2 neurons participating in local circuitry plays a role in reward or aversion.
Materials and Methods
Animals.
Animal procedures were performed in accordance with NIH guidelines and approved by the National Institute on Drug Abuse Animal Care and Use Committee. Male VGluT2::Cre mice were used (25–30 g body weight).
Surgical procedures.
VGluT2::Cre mice were injected into the VTA with Cre-inducible recombinant AAV encoding Channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) tethered to enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (eYFP; VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice) or mCherry (VGluT2-ChR2-mCherry mice). VGluT2::Cre mice injected with AAV tethered to eYFP (VGluT2-eYFP mice) served as controls. All viral injections were done as described by Root et al. (2014b). Mice were unilaterally implanted with ferrules or cannulas 10 d after injections.
Immunolabeling for confocal and electron microscopy analysis.
Brain tissue for immunodetection of mCherry, VGluT2, and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) were processed as described by Zhang et al. (2015).
Real-time place conditioning test.
VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP and VGluT2-eYFP mice were connected to an optical fiber, and mice freely accessed a three-chamber apparatus (for details, see Qi et al., 2014). On photostimulation conditioning days 1 and 2 (30 min sessions), we assigned one chamber as the stimulation-paired chamber. The mice were photostimulated (473 nm, ∼8 mW, 10 ms duration at 20 Hz; training timeline, see Fig. 2A) in the VTA whenever they entered the photostimulation-paired chamber, and stimulation continued until the mouse left the chamber. Mice were not photostimulated on the test day.
Optical intracranial self-stimulation.
VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP and VGluT2-eYFP mice were placed in operant chambers equipped with two response wheels (left and right) for a daily 30 min self-stimulation test (for details, see Qi et al., 2014). Quarter-turns of one wheel (active wheel) caused a 0.5 s train of 20 Hz photostimulation (473 nm, ∼8 mW, 10 ms duration per pulse, 10 pulses). Responses on the other (inactive) wheel did not result in photostimulation. During the first 8 training days, the right wheel was designated as the active wheel; during the next 4 training days, the left wheel was the active wheel. A week later, VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice were retested in 30 min daily sessions at 10 pulses with 10 ms duration under different stimulation frequencies (see Fig. 3C). After 1 week, VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice were retested in 30 min daily sessions at 20 Hz under different stimulation pulses (see Fig. 3D). After behavioral tests, brain sections from tested mice were examined. Mice with out-of-target cannula or probe implantation were excluded from the data analysis (Fig. 4).
Slice electrophysiology.
Eight weeks after virus injection, the retrograde tracer cholera toxin B subunit (CTb) was delivered into the nAcc of VGluT2::Cre-infected mice as detailed by Qi et al. (2014). A week later, VTA slices were obtained, and whole-cell recordings of CTb neurons were done as described by Qi et al. (2014).
VTA injections of glutamate receptor antagonists.
For pharmacological studies, we injected into the VTA the NMDA receptor antagonist MK-801 (catalog #0924, Tocris Bioscience) or AMPA receptor antagonist CNQX (catalog #C239, Sigma-Aldrich; 0.2 μl) dissolved in artificial CSF (ACSF), as described by Qi et al. (2014).
Statistics.
We performed one-, two-, or three-way ANOVA to analyze the behavioral data when applicable. When we obtained significant main or interaction effects, we performed Newman–Keuls post hoc tests for group comparisons. All statistical analyses were performed with STATISTICA 12. The level of significance was p < 0.05.
Results
We showed previously the selective expression of Cre-recombinase under the regulation of the VGluT2 promoter in VTA neurons of VGluT2::Cre mice (Root et al., 2014b). Here, VGluT2::Cre mice were used to express either mCherry or eYFP alone or tethered to ChR2 in VTA VGluT2 neurons.
Axon terminals from infected VTA VGluT2 neurons coexpress VGluT2 protein and mCherry and establish asymmetric synapses on single dendrites of neighboring neurons
By immunofluorescence we verified induced expression of mCherry (or eYFP) confined to VTA neurons. VTA boundaries were determined by the presence of TH (Fig. 1A). Within the VTA, we detected mCherry in cell bodies and processes, but detected VGluT2 immunoreactivity only in varicosities (Fig. 1B), some of which coexpressed mCherry (Fig. 1C). By electron microscopy, we found that VTA varicosities coexpressing mCherry and VGluT2 (mCherry-VGluT2) corresponded to axon terminals establishing several asymmetric synapses on dendrites of local neurons (Fig. 1D). Some of these dendrites were TH positive (Fig. 1E). The glutamate release from local VTA VGluT2 neurons on dopaminergic neurons is suggested by the detection of VGluT2 protein (for the vesicular accumulation of glutamate and its synaptic release) in axon terminals (from VTA-infected neurons) that form asymmetric synapses on neighboring TH neurons. Thus, to confirm that TH neurons are excited by local glutamatergic neurons, and to determine whether these TH neurons innervate the nAcc, we performed whole-cell recordings in VTA slices from VGluT2-ChR2-mCherry mice injected with the retrograde tracer CTb in the nAcc. Optical-evoked currents were detected in 9 of 50 CTb neurons (five mice) showing long action potential durations (1.9 to 4.0 ms, values associated with TH neurons). EPSCs higher than 20 pA and sensitive to the AMPA receptor antagonist CNQX were found in five of the nine CTb neurons, which were confirmed to be TH positive (Fig. 1F,G). Under current-clamp mode, these five neurons showed spontaneous tonic firing, the frequency of which was increased by trains of photostimulation (20 Hz, 20 pulses), greatly attenuated by CNQX, and further eliminated by application of the NMDA receptor antagonist APV (Fig. 1H,I). Together, these findings indicate that (1) terminals from VTA VGluT2 neurons established asymmetric synapses on VTA dopaminergic neurons, (2) these terminals contained VGluT2 protein, and (3) local activation of VTA VGluT2 neurons increased firing of mesoaccumbens dopaminergic neurons (Fig. 1J).
Photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons caused conditioned place preference mediated by VTA glutamate receptors
We tested whether photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons resulted in conditioned place preference or aversion (Fig. 2A). Mice were tested in a three-chamber apparatus in which they received continuous trains of photostimulation each time that they entered the photostimulation-paired chamber. VGluT2-eYFP (control) mice spent similar time in the photostimulation-paired or the photostimulation-unpaired chamber, whereas VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice spent significantly more time in the photostimulation-paired chamber (p < 0.01; Fig. 2B). When VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice were subsequently tested in the absence of photostimulation, they spent more time in the chamber where they had previously received photostimulation (p < 0.001; Fig. 2B,C). These results indicate that VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice not only earned the photostimulation by entering the stimulation chamber when photostimulation was available, but they also acquired a preference for the photostimulation-paired chamber as reflected by the time spent there on the subsequent day, when the photostimulation was no longer available.
Next, we evaluated the involvement of VTA glutamate receptors in real-time place preference, evoked by photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons, by VTA injections of NMDA receptor antagonist (MK-801) or AMPA receptor antagonist (CNQX) on the conditioning day (Fig. 2D,E). Mice that received a VTA injection of ACSF showed preference to the laser-paired chamber on both the photostimulation training day and the test day (p < 0.05; Fig. 2E). By contrast, mice that received a VTA injection of MK-801 or CNQX did not show preference for the photostimulation-paired chamber either on the photostimulation training day or on the test day (Fig. 2E). These findings indicate that the VTA VGluT2 neurons mediate the development of place preference by releasing glutamate into the VTA, resulting in activation of both NMDA and AMPA receptors.
Photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons served as an instrumental reinforcement mediated by VTA glutamate-receptors
To further characterize the rewarding properties of photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons, we next determined whether photoactivation of these neurons supports instrumental responding. VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP or VGluT2-eYFP mice were placed in chambers in which they were allowed to earn VTA photostimulation by rotating response wheels; a quarter-turn of one of the wheels (active wheel) resulted in photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons (a 0.5 s train of 10 ms light pulses, 20 Hz). During a first period of eight daily optical intracranial self-stimulation (oICSS) training sessions (D1 to D8), the right wheel was designated as the active wheel (Fig. 3A). VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice rotated the active wheel significantly more times than the inactive wheel from the second and subsequent sessions (Fig. 3B), and significantly more than VGluT2-eYFP mice turned either wheel (p < 0.001; Fig. 3B). To confirm that the frequency of wheel turning reflects the rewarding effect of the stimulation, we then switched the position of the active wheel for 4 d of reversal training (reversal D1 to D4) and found that VGluT2-ChR2-eYFP mice quickly changed their preference to the new active wheel on the second reversal training day (Fig. 3B). We next tested different frequencies and pulses of photostimulation and found that frequencies of 2, 20, and 40 Hz were increasingly effective in evoking oICSS, but decreasingly effective at 80 Hz (Figure 3C). Photostimulations with 3, 10, 30, or 90 pulses at 20 Hz evoked oICSS (Fig. 3D).
Finally, we evaluated the involvement of VTA glutamate receptors in the instrumental responding caused by photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons. We found that the number of active wheel turns evoked by photostimulation of VTA VGluT2 neurons was significantly inhibited by VTA injection of either MK-801 or CNQX (p < 0.01 vs ACSF group; Fig. 3E), but did not significantly decrease the number of inactive wheel turns compared with ACSF group (p > 0.05; Fig. 3E). These findings indicate that instrumental responding evoked by activation of VTA VGluT2 neurons is mediated by local AMPA and NMDA receptors.
Discussion
Local VTA cellular photoactivation versus photoactivation of their long-range fibers
Emerging evidence indicates that different behaviors may be elicited by photoactivation of VTA local neurons versus photoactivation of their long-range fibers. We and others have shown that LHb photoactivation of mesohabenular fibers expressing ChR2 under the VGluT2 promoter elicits glutamate receptor-mediated conditioned place aversion and promotes aversive conditioning (Root et al., 2014b; Lammel et al., 2015). In contrast, we report here that photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons expressing ChR2 under VGluT2 promoter causes conditioned place preferences and also reinforces instrumental behavior. Whereas these rewarding effects were driven under different parameters of VTA photoactivation, the tested parameters did not result in any observable aversion. In addition, we determined that VTA local activation of glutamate receptors was necessary for both conditioned place preferences and instrumental responding.
We propose that the observed rewarding effects induced by photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons are due, in part, to the release of glutamate from terminals that establish local excitatory synapses on mesoaccumbens dopaminergic neurons. In clear contrast, LHb photoactivation of terminals from VTA VGluT2 neurons is aversive (Root et al., 2014b; Lammel et al., 2015). In this regard, it is important to make the distinction that although we demonstrated that photoactivation of VTA VGluT2 neurons results in the activation of local glutamatergic receptors, it is unclear whether the same parameters of photoactivation also result in the activation of glutamate receptors in the LHb or other brain areas outside the VTA, some of which may also participate in reward or in overriding the aversive effects induced by activation of LHb glutamatergic receptors.
As reward and aversive conditioning differs by photoactivation of VTA glutamatergic intrinsic or extrinsic fibers, different behaviors appear to be elicited by local photoactivation of VTA GABAergic neurons or their long-range terminals. While photoactivation of VTA GABAergic neurons causes conditioned place aversion (Tan et al. 2012), nAcc photoactivation of fibers from VTA GABAergic neurons plays a role in reward consumption (van Zessen et al., 2012) and a role in associative learning (Brown et al., 2012). On the other hand, LHb photoactivation of fibers from VTA GABAergic neurons is rewarding (Stamatakis et al., 2013). These findings indicate that different behaviors may be elicited by either local activation of VTA GABAergic neurons or their long-range fibers.
Heterogeneity among VTA glutamate neurons
The VTA VGluT2 neurons are diverse in their molecular composition, signaling properties, and neuronal connectivity (Morales and Root, 2014). While the majority of rat and mouse VTA VGluT2 neurons lack both dopaminergic and GABAergic markers, there are subpopulations of VTA VGluT2 neurons that coexpress molecules responsible for the synthesis or the vesicular transport of either dopamine or GABA (Li et al., 2013; Root et al., 2014a; Yamaguchi et al., 2015). Anatomical and electrophysiological studies have shown that some of the VTA VGluT2 neurons coexpressing TH (VGluT2-TH neurons) innervate the nAcc and evoke EPSCs on medium spiny neurons (Stuber et al., 2010; Tecuapetla et al., 2010; Zhang et al., 2015). Previous findings have provided evidence for dopamine and glutamate release from segregated microdomains within a single VGluT2-TH mesoaccumbens axon (Zhang et al., 2015). Another subset of VTA VGluT2 neurons has been shown to express GABA markers (VGluT2-GABA neurons) and innervate LHb (Root et al., 2014a). LHb photoactivation of fibers from these VGluT2-GABA neurons results in the corelease of glutamate and GABA from the same axon terminal (Root et al., 2014a). While these findings provide evidence for cotransmission by some VTA glutamatergic neurons, it remains to be determined whether some VTA VGluT2-TH or VTA VGluT2-GABA neurons are also part of the VTA local circuitry.
In summary, we provide converging evidence for the existence of a VTA excitatory microcircuitry by local glutamatergic neurons in which activation of these neurons promotes glutamate receptor-mediated conditioned place preference and appetitive instrumental conditioning. We suggest that this microcircuitry is likely to participate in the VTA integration of information from brain areas innervating the VTA and in modulating VTA output neurotransmission
Footnotes
The Intramural Research Program of the National Institute on Drug Abuse supported this research.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
- Correspondence should be addressed to Marisela Morales, National Institute on Drug Abuse, Intramural Research Program, Neuronal Networks Section, 251 Bayview Boulevard, Baltimore, MD 21224. mmorales{at}intra.nida.nih.gov