PT  - JOURNAL ARTICLE
AU  - Senne Braem
AU  - Jan De Houwer
AU  - Jelle Demanet
AU  - Kenneth S.L. Yuen
AU  - Raffael Kalisch
AU  - Marcel Brass
TI  - Pattern Analyses Reveal Separate Experience-Based Fear Memories in the Human Right Amygdala
AID  - 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0908-17.2017
DP  - 2017 Aug 23
TA  - The Journal of Neuroscience
PG  - 8116--8130
VI  - 37
IP  - 34
4099  - http://www.jneurosci.org/content/37/34/8116.short
4100  - http://www.jneurosci.org/content/37/34/8116.full
SO  - J. Neurosci.2017 Aug 23; 37
AB  - Learning fear via the experience of contingencies between a conditioned stimulus (CS) and an aversive unconditioned stimulus (US) is often assumed to be fundamentally different from learning fear via instructions. An open question is whether fear-related brain areas respond differently to experienced CS–US contingencies than to merely instructed CS–US contingencies. Here, we contrasted two experimental conditions where subjects were instructed to expect the same CS–US contingencies while only one condition was characterized by prior experience with the CS–US contingency. Using multivoxel pattern analysis of fMRI data, we found CS-related neural activation patterns in the right amygdala (but not in other fear-related regions) that dissociated between whether a CS–US contingency had been instructed and experienced versus merely instructed. A second experiment further corroborated this finding by showing a category-independent neural response to instructed and experienced, but not merely instructed, CS presentations in the human right amygdala. Together, these findings are in line with previous studies showing that verbal fear instructions have a strong impact on both brain and behavior. However, even in the face of fear instructions, the human right amygdala still shows a separable neural pattern response to experience-based fear contingencies.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT In our study, we addressed a fundamental problem of the science of human fear learning and memory, namely whether fear learning via experience in humans relies on a neural pathway that can be separated from fear learning via verbal information. Using two new procedures and recent advances in the analysis of brain imaging data, we localized purely experience-based fear processing and memory in the right amygdala, thereby making a direct link between human and animal research.