Renal collecting duct and thick ascending limb, as well as stomach, exhibit strikingly low permeabilities to water and solutes. However, the apical membrane characteristics responsible for these unique permeabilities remain unknown. While the lipid composition of artificial membranes governs membrane permeability, exoplasmic and cytoplasmic leaflets of biological apical membranes exhibit striking asymmetries in lipid composition. This asymmetry, as well as the presence of membrane proteins, may be critical to barrier function. To determine the role of bulk lipid composition in apical membrane barrier function, we compared permeabilities to water (Pf), protons, ammonia, and several small nonelectrolytes of gastric apical membrane vesicles [native gastric vesicles (NGV)] and liposomes prepared from lipids quantitatively extracted from these vesicles [gastric lipid large unilamellar vesicles (LUV)]. Permeabilities were measured on a stopped-flow fluorimeter by monitoring self- or pH-sensitive quenching of entrapped carboxyfluorescein. NGV exhibited low Pf (2.8 +/- 0.3 x 10(-4) cm/s) while gastric lipid LUV Pf averaged 1.2 +/- 0.1 x 10(-3) cm/s, a fourfold increase compared with the value in NGV. Gastric lipid LUV also demonstrated higher permeabilities to protons, ammonia, propylene glycol, butyramide, ethanolamine, and acetamide compared with values in NGV. In contrast, gastric lipid LUV exhibited the same or lower permeabilities to urea, glycerol, and ammonia compared with values in NGV. We conclude that lipid composition alone can reconstitute membrane permeabilities to some, but not all, molecules. These results indicate that bilayer asymmetry may be required for the unique permeability of "water-tight" apical membranes and reveal different barrier mechanisms for water and protons, as opposed to ammonia, urea, and glycerol.